A legal dispute with Sears, the long-struggling department store chain, looms over the upcoming sheriff’s sale of Century III Mall.

The auction, scheduled for July 2, has been postponed again, and is now set for Sept. 4, according to documents filed in the court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County.

When Sears, which has been shuttering stores across the country over the past several years, told the West Mifflin mall’s owners that it planned to close its anchor store in 2014, a question about what would happen to the now-vacant property ended up in court.

Eventually, a judge said the mall owner, Century III Mall PA LLC, owes Sears about $4.2 million after failing to buy back the department store location when Sears terminated the lease early.

Advertise with us

That dispute, which has been winding through the courts for years, has pushed the nearly 40-year-old mall into the position of facing the sheriff’s sale. Originally scheduled for June, the sale has been postponed twice.

Century III once was one of the Pittsburgh region's premier malls, boasting 200 stores and restaurants. It was sold for $10.5 million in 2013 to Century III Mall PA LLC. The price tag was lower than the mall's 2012 property assessment of $27 million.

The company bought the 1.3-million-square-foot mall from an asset management firm that had acquired the property in 2011 from Indiana-based Simon Property Group, which had defaulted on a $79 million loan. In the Pittsburgh region, Simon still owns South Hills Village and Ross Park Mall.

Like many malls, Century III has been struggling to keep its spaces full in recent years. In addition to Sears closing in 2014, Macy’s also shuttered in 2016. Many retailers occupying the smaller storefronts lining the interior of the mall have also closed up shop.

Gary Matta, solicitor for the West Mifflin School District, said so far, no taxes are outstanding on the property, despite the property’s struggles over the years.  

Advertise with us

Though it’s uncertain what the pending sheriff’s sale will bring, it could mean the mall will change ownership yet again.

“If it changes hands, hopefully, it changes to an investor who can finance what they can and has a vision to make it more advantageous to the community and themselves,” Mr. Matta said.

Few retailers remain in the shopping center.

Stalwart anchor stores J.C. Penney and Dick’s Sporting Goods still draw shoppers. New Dimension Comics operates one of its six locations at the mall, where it also hosted 3 Rivers Comicon in May.

On a recent afternoon, all the escalators were shut down and most were blocked by benches or caution tape. The food court was shuttered, with more yellow tape wrapped around decorative pillars. Some machinery rattled behind the counter of a vacant vendor.

Advertise with us

“We’re willing to work with anyone to redevelop the property,” said Brian Kamauf, borough manager. “We reached out to [the mall]. They made promises and nothing ever came of it.”

“It’s a nice location and a good property,” he said. “There’s some use for it.”

This story was updated at 3:34 p.m. on June 29 to reflect the change in the date of the sheriff’s sale.

Stephanie Ritenbaugh: sritenbaugh@post-gazette.com; 412-263-4910; Twitter: @StephanieRit.

Correction, posted May 28, 2025: In an earlier version of this story, the owner of Century III Mall and the entity sued by Sears were identified incorrectly.