Mark Mikesell got a lucky break five years ago — so it seemed — after learning that he and his 12-year-old brother were named heirs to their great-grandfather’s estate.
The windfall could not have come at a better time. He was 24 years old, recently married with a newborn son. His great-grandfather’s will entitled him and his younger brother to split $250,000 in cash. They also gained ownership of six vacant lots in Esplen, in city’s west end.
“Money was tight at that time,” he said.
In his haste to liquidate the six properties and divide the proceeds between himself and his brother, Mr. Mikesell had the properties converted into his name prior to the estate being settled.
But when he tried to sell the parcels, he got a rude shock — the lots were saddled with more than $50,000 in back taxes.
Part of his inheritance had become a serious burden.
Like many people who inherit real estate, Mr. Mikesell was not prepared for the surprises that popped up.
When it comes to a surviving spouse who inherits property, the legal transfer of real estate should occur relatively quickly and without tax penalties. But receiving inherited real estate in many other circumstances can be a complicated process that could take the executor of the estate and the courts months to sort out.
In any given year, about 7,000 estates are opened in Allegheny County as a result of someone passing away who owned property. The majority involve real estate transfers, although the county does not specifically track how many houses, vehicles, bank accounts, or how much in stocks and bonds are distributed to heirs.
The total dollar amount of the assets changing hands is substantial. Allegheny County collected a total of $123 million in inheritance taxes last year on behalf of the commonwealth.
Heirs are required to pay a tax on assets they inherit, minus expenses that could include the decedent’s funeral, flowers and tombstone. The inheritance tax also would be minus any debt left by the decedent, including medical bills, mortgages and settlement costs for selling a home.
The inheritance tax rate in Pennsylvania depends on the heir’s relationship to the decedent. Children of the decedent pay a rate of 4.5 percent; siblings pay a 12 percent rate and collateral heirs — aunts, uncles, cousins and friends — owe a tax rate of 15 percent on the value of all inherited assets, except life insurance.
Watch out for back taxes
Had Mr. Mikesell researched the property before having it transferred to his own name, he could have made a case that the lots did not belong to him and that he owed no money for past taxes.
If he waited for the estate to settle, the estate would have paid the debt with whatever cash his great-grandfather left.
But after the properties transferred to his name, Mr. Mikesell was solely responsible for the back taxes.
“If I had it to do all over again, I would have done more research,” he said. “I could have been more patient and let the estate deal with those properties. But I was a 24-year-old kid looking at a big paycheck and I got anxious.”
For four years from the time he inherited the properties, he lived in regret.
“There wasn’t a day during those four years that I didn’t think about how these properties would impact my financial future,” said Mr. Mikesell, 28, who works as a manager for Walmart.
Fortunately for him, some of the properties were next to land owned by real estate investor Aaron Chaney. Mr. Chaney contacted Mr. Mikesell in February and offered to buy the lots for the amount of back taxes owed.
“Esplen is a blank slate because there are not many houses left,” said Mr. Chaney, co-owner of West Carson Development LLC. “Because of its proximity to Downtown, the prospects for development are huge.”
They completed the transaction in about one week.
“The fact that he would take responsibility for the properties and get them out of my name, that alone was worth its weight in gold,” Mr. Mikesell said. “I got no money on the deal. But I got peace of mind and a clean slate.”
A complicated asset
With nearly $2.5 trillion in assets under management, financial advisers at Fidelity Investments work with clients who inherit real estate.
“Property is a more complicated asset to inherit than cash, stocks or bonds,” said Kevin Ruth, head of wealth planning and personal trusts for Fidelity in Jersey City, N.J.
“It comes with all the bills a regular property comes with, such as heating, electric and water,” he said. “And if it’s a property you don’t want and wish to sell, you may find it is an illiquid asset.”
One case involved a client who inherited land with an underground oil tank that had leaked. The client was responsible for cleaning up the soil and removing the tank, which cost more than the value of the land.
But inheriting property can still be more tax-efficient than receiving it as a gift while the owner is alive.
“If you inherit a piece of property worth $500,000 that your parents bought years ago for $100,000, the property [is taxed at] its fair market value of $500,000. So when the children sell it for $500,000, there is no capital gains tax,” Mr. Ruth said.
If the parents had transferred the property to the children prior to death, the children would be saddled with the old cost basis of $100,000. A hefty tax bill, typically in the 20 percent range on a $400,000 gain, would follow.

Live in it? Sell it?
When multiple heirs are involved in a real estate inheritance, disagreements may break out.
One heir may want to live in it; another may want to sell it, or even turn it into a shrine for the deceased.
Often the inherited properties have not been renovated for years. The property may even be so rundown that the heirs refuse to claim it.
Real estate investor Chris Herisko, owner of Pittsburgh Property Guy, said many homes he has purchased from heirs have required extensive work before they can go on the market. Not to mention the liens.
“Just about every house I’ve come across this way, they all have back taxes,” he said. “There’s always something owed. Some of them have unpaid water bills in the hundreds and even thousands of dollars.”
One of his former clients — Marla Perri, 61, of Allegheny Township, Westmoreland County — sold Mr. Herisko the Penn Hills home she was raised in for $36,000 after her sister died in 2014.
“I knew it would be easier to sell the house as is rather than try to fix it up,” Ms. Perri said.
The most difficult part of the process was going through the home, sorting out personal items and dealing with memories of her parents.
“When I left for the last time, I asked Chris if I could come back and see it when he was done. It felt nice knowing maybe some other 1-year-old kid would live there and create memories like me.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.