Jury selection was scheduled to begin Tuesday in Johnstown in a federal lawsuit that UPMC is pursuing over what it says was grossly inaccurate pension liability estimates for a Blair County hospital before it was acquired by the Pittsburgh-based health care giant.
The three-count civil lawsuit that was filed in the U.S. District Court for Western Pennsylvania alleges that CBIZ Benefits & Insurance Services Inc. and employee Jon S. Ketzner understated the liabilities of two pension plans offered to employees at Altoona Hospital before UPMC acquired the hospital in 2013. CBIZ Inc., parent of CBIZ Benefits, is also named as a defendant.
Instead of $240 million in liabilities for two pension plans as reported by CBIZ, the true liability was $373 million, according to the lawsuit, which was filed 2016. UPMC alleged professional negligence, breach of contract and negligent representation; it seeks unspecified damages and costs.
Judge Kim R. Gibson is presiding.
UPMC acquired Altoona Hospital with the promise of investing $250 million over 10 years in the system and contributing $10 million to the Altoona Foundation. Had UPMC known of the higher pension liability, it would have backed out of or renegotiated the deal, according to the lawsuit. Instead of a surplus of $119 million as of June 20, 2012, the hospital’s balance sheets should’ve shown a deficit of $4 million because of the “massive understatement” of pension liabilities.
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.