A Cumberland County cardiologist is claiming that he lost his job in retaliation for, among other things, accusing UPMC President and CEO Leslie Davis of having a conflict of interest involving her paid position on a medical device maker’s board whose scientific studies he criticized.
Interventional cardiologist Hemal Gada filed a two-count federal lawsuit against the Pittsburgh-based health system in the U.S. District Court of Western Pennsylvania on March 31.
In the suit, he cites both his criticism of clinical trial results tied to Edwards Lifesciences and his report to human resources of racist texts by doctors discussing the creation of a fellowship as factors in his firing in August 2025.
He is represented by Downtown law firm Ramage Lykos LLC. U.S. District Court Judge Joy Flowers Conti is presiding.
UPMC declined to comment Monday.
In the lawsuit, Dr. Gada said he reported texts exchanged by doctors, including ones suggesting that “patients do not like to be treated by brown physicians with accents and wishing luck with the effort to replace white doctors with brown ones.”
In addition, in LinkedIn postings in 2025, Dr. Gada was critical of Edwards’ five-year follow-up data on a clinical trial for its Sapien 3 heart valve, which is made from treated heart tissue from cows mounted in a metal frame.
The valves are implanted with minimally invasive surgery, and the follow-up data analyzed their effectiveness in low-risk patients. The devices had previously only been used in patients who could not tolerate open-heart surgery.
UPMC was not part of the valve’s original clinical trial, which included 1,000 patients at 71 medical centers, including Cleveland Clinic, Cedars-Sinai Medical Center and other hospitals. The devices are used at UPMC.
Irving, Calif.-based Edwards markets some of the most widely used heart valves in the world, with sales generating $4.5 billion in 2025, according to the company.
The lawsuit said Ms. Davis received more than $300,000 in equity and other compensation for her board work at Edwards in 2024 and 2025. The suit argues the relationship is a conflict of interest because it “impacts UPMC’s institutional independence in being able to justify medical device use in a scientifically uncompromised way.”
Given her board position, Ms. Davis should “necessarily be requested to refrain from involvement in any dealing with Edwards, an entity with which UPMC engaged in multi-million dollar transactions across the health system,” according to the lawsuit.
Dr. Gada said he was subjected to racial harassment and fired in retaliation for reporting the disparaging texts, for criticizing the Edwards’ study results and for calling out Ms. Davis’ involvement with the Edwards board as a conflict of interest.
He is seeking reinstatement with back pay and benefits and punitive damages and reimbursement for legal costs.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.