UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital nurses on Tuesday outlined their proposal to fix nurse-to-patient ratios and embed the guidelines in the contract they are now negotiating.
Bargaining was scheduled to continue Tuesday at noon in Oakland for the first contract for more than 800 registered nurses and 60 advanced nurse practitioners. Hospital nurses voted in August to be represented by SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania.
“I’ve worked at Magee for 10 years and management has often said lactation just can’t see every breastfeeding family,” lactation consultant Celia Emmons said. “We have about half the number that is recommended.
“In business, it makes sense to get as much as you can out of your employees, but this has to do with patient care,” she said. “I want to see something better for our community.”
Magee has about 11 lactation consultants, but nine more are needed to meet professional organization guidelines, she said. UPMC has not recognized the hospital consultants as part of the SEIU bargaining unit.
Because the consultants are not required to be registered nurses, they cannot appropriately be included in the nursing bargaining unit according to labor law, UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said in a prepared statement.
Read More
The nurses are seeking limits on the number of patients nurses care for in every hospital department based on guidelines developed by the Association of Women’s Health, Obstetric and Neonatal Nurses and other professional organizations. Mandated fixed ratio nursing ratios are uncommon in Pennsylvania hospitals, but variations of the rules are used at Allegheny Health Network’s West Penn Hospital in Bloomfield and elsewhere.
“More often than not, we’re getting two patients when we should have one,” adult intensive care unit nurse Dan Melder said. “Sometimes, we find there’s not enough time in the day.”
Magee’s 20-bay emergency department can fill quickly, burdening nurses with more patients than they can handle appropriately, said ER nurse Alix Levy.
“The volume of people just keeps increasing, every shift, every day,” she said.
Labor and delivery nurse Mariah Park said the result of having to care for too many patients is moral injury, a sense of betrayal or distress resulting from having to provide attention that’s less than what the patient needs.
“The moral injury is very real and long-lasting,” Ms. Park said.
Although medical staff and hospital administrators want the best patient care, at Magee and elsewhere they differ on whether rigid staffing mandates, tailored to patient acuity, will achieve that goal better than real time assignments based on patient needs. The issue has become central to the contract talks at Magee.
Mr. Wood said the staffing decisions at the hospital were designed to “keep patients safe by matching care to real-time needs, patient acuity and clinical conditions — not fixed ratios.”
“By supporting nurses with strong care teams and flexible resources, we help ensure safer care, better outcomes, and continued access for the patients who depend on Magee,” he said in a prepared statement.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.