It has been several years since we’ve discussed the topic of Filial Responsibility, which refers to the idea that family members are responsible for paying for the costs of care of another family member if that family member is indigent.
Imagine having a family member who has no money becoming your financial responsibility, even though you have never received anything from that family member that caused them to become indigent and may even be estranged from them.
Historically, this law began with the enactment of the Public Welfare Code of 1937. This “Support Law” states, in part, that “a husband, wife, child, father and mother of every indigent person … shall care for and maintain, or financially assist such indigent person.”
In 2005, Pennsylvania enacted Act 43, which we have discussed in prior articles, to clarify which relatives were responsible to financially assist indigent family members, among other issues.
In a 2012 column, we discussed Pennsylvania case law confirming that once a creditor (such as a health care provider, nursing home, etc.) established the burden of proof that a family member had the ability to pay the debts of another family member, that the creditor could enforce filial responsibility upon just one family member and did not have to seek contribution from other family members.
Since then, the threat of filial responsibility has lurked underneath any family navigating the long-term care system.
Read More
With the average monthly cost of nursing home care in Pennsylvania around $13,000, it behooves family members of a nursing home resident to understand their exposure — and how to reduce it through planning.
New legislation is at the forefront of the filial responsibility debate in Pennsylvania. Earlier this year, PA House Bill 65 was introduced and titled “Ending Familial Responsibility in Medical Bills.”
The title of this legislation is not entirely accurate, as the proposed law does not end filial responsibility. It appears to refine the circumstances under which relatives can be held liable, paying particular attention to the ability of a person to financially support a relative, as well as circumstances surrounding Medical Assistance eligibility.
Focusing on the Medical Assistance eligibility process is relevant as this program pays for the majority of skilled nursing long-term care costs in the Commonwealth.
However, further refinement is necessary as it appears that people can have liability for failing to cooperate in the Medical Assistance application process.
The phrase “failure to cooperate” can have various interpretations, depending on the circumstances. Applying for Medical Assistance in Pennsylvania is a very complex and time-consuming process that requires the review of five years of financial data for a single person or married couple. This can result in hundreds of pages of financial documents.
Not every family member has the time or ability to understand or participate in this exhaustive process. Does this inability to participate rise to the level of liability under proposed law?
The language of the bill also focuses on situations where an indigent person may have made gifts to a family member within the five year look-back period prior to applying for Medical Assistance. However, there are a variety of situations where the net effect of such gifts yields no exposure or loss of revenue to the nursing facility. These are just two examples of the need for further refinement of HB 65 before it can become an effective law that accomplishes its constituents’ intentions.
While the filial responsibility debate (and any proposed solution) continues, the important thing to remember is that the cost of long-term care as we age is extraordinary.
As Elder Law attorneys, many years ago we realized that people hate paying a portion of their nest egg to taxes. They hate even more giving away the whole chicken for the costs of long-term care. And it’s even worse when you lose your henhouse because of your family member’s long-term care costs.
Most of us are going to get old. Some of us will get old without extraordinarily expensive care. And then there’s the rest of us. Planning ahead can mitigate the exposure under these circumstances for the person who needs care and their family.
Julian Gray and Frank Petrich are Certified Elder Law Attorneys with over 70 years of combined elder law experience who practice in the Pittsburgh area at Julian Gray Associates. Send questions for consideration in this column to elderlawguys@grayelderlaw.com and visit their web site at www.grayelderlaw.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.