Meadville Medical Center in Crawford County is poised to acquire bankrupt Sharon Regional Medical Center, about an hour away, on Dec. 1 as thorny real estate negotiations continue.

The U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas on Wednesday endorsed an interim global settlement, paving the way for the 80-bed Sharon Regional and other bankrupt Dallas-based Steward Health System hospitals to be sold in voluntary Chapter 11 proceedings. Eighteen miles from Sharon Regional, across the state line in Warren, Ohio, a Michigan-based health care consultant has taken over managing two other Steward hospitals with the intent of buying them.

“What has transpired over the past few weeks has been nothing short of remarkable,” Judge Christopher M. Lopez said at the Wednesday hearing. “This is a good thing. It helps keep hospitals open.

“This is an incredibly complicated case.”

Advertise with us

Sharon Regional in Mercer County and Trumbull Regional Medical Center, 346 beds, and 69-bed Hillside Rehabilitation Hospital in Warren were among 31 for-profit Steward hospitals that filed for protection from creditors in May. Since then, civic leaders and elected officials in both communities have mounted campaigns to keep their hospitals open to meet residents’ medical needs and to save hundreds of jobs.

Real estate leases for hospital properties, described in court filings as onerous, have been a sticking point in finding new owners for the hospitals. The leases are held by Birmingham, Ala.-based Medical Properties Trust Inc.

Real estate negotiations were continuing with Sharon Regional officials, an MPT attorney told Judge Lopez Wednesday. MPT officials did not respond to a request for comment Thursday.

MPT bought the real estate for about 25 medical properties in Sharon for $18.9 million in 2017 and the annual lease payments total about $2 million, according to a person involved in the talks, but who was not authorized to speak publicly about them. Sharon Regional is negotiating to buy the properties from MPT, getting out from under the lease payments and helping assure the hospital’s future financial security.

“The leases are the problem,” said Maureen Tkacik, senior fellow at the American Economic Liberties Project, a 4-year-old Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit, who is not involved in the talks. “That’s the problem with private equity: ownership change doesn’t solve the problem. None of these leases were ever sustainable.”

Advertise with us

If the deal is consummated, the 178-bed Meadville Medical Center would become a three-hospital system. Meadville acquired Titusville Area Hospital in 2015 when the 25-bed critical access facility had an operational deficit of 12% and local residents worried that it might close.

A lot has changed since then. The hospital opened a pharmacy in Titusville in September 2022 and a new CT scanner was installed several months later at the hospital as finances stabilized.

Titusville Area’s net patient revenue grew 11% between 2021 and 2023 to $54 million while its operating margin hit 9.28% last year, well above the region’s average loss from hospital operations of 3.5%, according to the Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council, a Harrisburg governmental study group. Meadville Medical’s net patient revenue hit $237 million last year, up smartly 9% for the three-year period, while its operating margin last year was less than 1%.

By comparison, Sharon Regional reported a loss from operations of 20% in 2023.

Meadville Medical officials did not return calls for comment Thursday.

Advertise with us

In Warren, MPT on Wednesday named Insight Health System as manager of Trumbull Regional Medical Center and Hillside Rehabilitation Hospital as the Flint, Mich.-based consultant tries to acquire both entities.

“While our immediate goal is to keep the doors of Trumbull and Hillside open for patients and staff, we will assess all aspects of those facilities’ operations in the coming weeks to identify sensible pathways to stabilize operations to ensure these organizations can meet the needs of the communities they serve for generations to come,” Insight founder and neurosurgeon Jawad Shad said in a prepared statement.

Insight manages hospitals and other health care facilities in Michigan, Iowa, New Jersey and Illinois, where it owns Chicago’s 414-bed Mercy Hospital. If Insight acquires the Warren hospitals, both would revert to nonprofit operations, the company said.