Attorneys for Steward Health Care System LLC are asking a bankruptcy court judge to throw out 144 “expensive and burdensome” real estate leases, including Sharon Regional Medical Center properties, clearing the way for the struggling 82-bed Mercer County hospital and many others to be sold.
Steward attorney Clifford W. Carlson, from the Houston firm of Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, late Friday petitioned U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas to reject the leases as part of the health system’s reorganization under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. The leases, which are held by Birmingham, Ala.-based Medical Properties Trust Inc., have been the biggest impediment to the transfer of ownership of Steward’s hospitals in the Shenango Valley and elsewhere since Steward declared bankruptcy, attorneys have said.
“MPT’s undermining behavior and brinkmanship jeopardizes the future of dozens of hospitals, tens of thousands of jobs and the safety of patients,” according to the petition. “This cannot be tolerated.”
“The rent and other payment obligations under the master leases are substantial and have crippled the debtors’ operations for years.”
MPT denied being obstructionist in a statement Monday.
“Throughout this bankruptcy process, MPT has been collaborative and accommodating to help ensure Steward’s hospitals can remain open,” a spokesman wrote. “We categorically reject any accusation that MPT has interfered with Steward’s marketing and sales efforts — on the contrary, we have proactively worked with potential bidders to address real estate-related matters.”
Read More
The latest bankruptcy court motion echoes an Aug. 8 letter to Apollo Global Management Inc. by U.S. Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Edward J. Markey, both Democrats from Massachusetts, which also sought relief from the property leases. The letter identifies New York City-based Apollo as the “key economic stakeholder” in the Steward bankruptcy.
“Specifically, we ask that you act quickly to negotiate with prospective buyers and provide relief from onerous leases to enable these hospitals to remain open and serving health care needs of their communities,” the letter said.
MPT officials were not available for comment Sunday. MPT and others have three weeks to file objections to the debtors’ motion, which requires court approval.
Meanwhile, state Sen. Michele Brooks, a Republican from Mercer County and chair of the Health & Human Services Committee, has been working with Sharon area civic leaders and local foundations in putting together a financial package that would allow Meadville Medical Center to acquire Sharon Regional, according to one person involved in the discussions, but who was not authorized to speak publicly about them. Meadville Medical, which operates two hospitals in Crawford County, about an hour from Sharon, has submitted a letter of interest in acquiring Sharon Regional — minus the real estate leases.
The Pennsylvania attorney general and Sharon-based Christian H. Buhl Legacy Trust are also been involved in the discussions, along with the nonprofit Penn-Northwest Development Corp., this person said.
The future of two other Steward hospitals in the Shenango Valley was uncertain. No bidders have come forward for Trumbull Regional Medical Center and Hillside Rehabilitation Hospital, both in Warren, Ohio, although the debtors also requested relief from their real estate leases in the filing.
Sharon Regional, which eliminated labor and delivery and cancer care services in recent years in cost-cutting moves, needs about $10 million in deferred maintenance costs, officials have said.
Steward, the largest private, physician-owned for-profit health care network in the U.S. and owner of 31 hospitals, filed for bankruptcy in May, putting the 82-bed Sharon Regional and some 300 jobs at risk in northwest Pennsylvania. Sharon Regional is located in the post-industrial Shenango Valley, where heavy industry jobs evaporated and the population has been declining for decades.
Steward bought Sharon Regional in 2017 from for-profit Community Health Systems Inc. Before that, Sharon Regional was a nonprofit founded in 1893 and it would again be operated as a nonprofit if Meadville Medical Center becomes the new owner.
As Sharon Regional slid into bankruptcy with the Steward system, UPMC has been filling in gaps in care in Mercer and Crawford counties. UPMC Horizon - Shenango Valley, 3 miles from Sharon Regional, added five bays to a 16-bay emergency department as part of a $1.5 million expansion while also increasing cancer care.
In Crawford County, UPMC expanded an outpatient clinic in Meadville that nearly doubled the existing space to accommodate specialty services such as bariatric surgery, gastroenterology, medical imaging and other care.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.