It’s not the kind of issue that generally winds up as an unfair labor practice complaint involving lawyers and hearings.

In 2023, the union representing some UPMC nurses asked for pay data from their employer to ensure that the terms of their labor agreement were being followed. The Pittsburgh-based health system denied the request.

A year later, an administrative law judge at the National Labor Relations Board ordered UPMC to provide the nursing wage schedules as a three-year contract expires this year with the nurses and negotiations get under way.

NLRB Administrative Law Judge Michael A. Rosas in Washington, who issued his ruling Feb. 5, has given UPMC until Feb. 24 to turn over the salary information, which the union said was needed to ensure that new nurses at Western Psychiatric Hospital in Oakland are being paid appropriately.

Advertise with us

UPMC said it was considering its options after the ruling. As a matter of policy, SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania doesn’t respond to requests from the Post-Gazette because of a labor dispute at the newspaper.

Here’s how things unspooled at Western Psychiatric.

By agreement, SEIU joined JNESO District Council 1 in representing nurses at UPMC Western Psychiatric in 1995, with JNESO serving as an agent of SEIU and the union handling such things as contract negotiations and employee grievances. New Brunswick Township, N.J.-based JNESO, which represents health care employees in Pennsylvania and New Jersey, keeps 25 cents of every dollar collected in nurses’ union dues and submits the balance from dues to SEIU.

JNESO has not held formal meetings or had any direct communications with nurses since at least 2014, according to the NLRB judge’s ruling.

In 2022, the second year of the current contract, SEIU President Matthew Yarnell signed the labor agreement between UPMC and Western Psychiatric nurses, although “neither Yarnell nor any other SEIU representative” have ever been a party to the collective bargaining agreement, the labor relations board ruling found.

Advertise with us

In January 2023, the SEIU notified the health system of a pay discrepancy that may have violated the labor agreement: New nurses at UPMC Presbyterian University Hospital, who are nonunion, were being offered $29.77 to $44.13 an hour, while new union nurses at Western Psychiatric were getting $28.09 to $29.09 an hour. Starting wages at both hospitals were supposed to be the same, SEIU organizer Adam Stokes said in an email to UPMC management.

Emails were sent back and forth between labor and management, according to the labor board ruling. By the end of March 2023, UPMC had declined to provide the wage data to SEIU, saying it was confidential.

Furthermore, UPMC said JNESO had “unlawfully delegated its representational responsibilities to SEIU.”

In his ruling earlier this week, the NLRB administrative law judge said the salary information request was justified and SEIU’s role as servicing agent to JNESO was proper, adding that UPMC’s refusal to provide the wage information was, in fact, an unfair labor practice. JNESO’s three-year contract with nurses at Western Psychiatric expires in October.

SEIU has tried to unionize hourly workers at UPMC Presbyterian Hospital for years, without success. That union has also emerged as among the most vocal critics of UPMC’s proposed acquisition of Washington Health System, a deal that is now undergoing a review by the state attorney general and the Federal Trade Commission.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com