Unionized workers were on board when Highmark Health announced that every employee is expected to be vaccinated against COVID-19, president and CEO David Holmberg said Thursday, calling SEIU Healthcare of Pennsylvania a “good partner” in the fight against the pandemic.

“We’ve worked closely with the union since the outset of the pandemic and they’ve been a good partner in leading the way with us in serving patients,” he said.

But Highmark and SEIU Healthcare may not be singing from the same hymnal on the COVID-19 vaccination issue, even though Highmark executives put a good face on union relations during a briefing Thursday.

Allegheny Health Network CEO Cynthia Hundorfean met with employees Thursday morning to answer questions about the new vaccine requirement, which goes into effect Sept. 30, she said, adding that union relations have been good.

Advertise with us

“We have a long relationship with SEIU,” she said. “We try to make sure everybody knows what we’re doing. The virus is dictating the pace of change, not us.”

Allegheny General Hospital nurse and SEIU Healthcare member Michelle Boyle issued a statement Thursday praising the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines, but said plans for widespread vaccination of hospital employees “must be guided by health care workers.”

“Nurses at AGH worked with management in negotiations to create an approach to vaccines and personal protective equipment that ensures the highest level of care for our patients and safety for our staff,” she wrote.

Highmark’s new policy aligns with a growing chorus of voices backing the vaccination requirement, including President Joe Biden. Dozens of professional organizations have called for COVID-19 vaccination mandates. On Wednesday, Mr. Biden met with corporate and university executives to promote employer requirements, which have already been announced by McDonald’s Corp., Kaiser Permanente and United Airlines Holdings Inc.

AHN has been in contract negotiations with SEIU Healthcare and nurses at West Penn Hospital in Bloomfield, which a union official previously said had stalled since starting in January. Union negotiators were unavailable Wednesday for an update on the talks.

Advertise with us

Organized labor’s response to the push to require vaccination has been mixed: the California Teachers Association, which represents 310,000 educators, has come out in support of mandatory COVID-19 vaccinations, along with the 50,000-member SEIU Local 99, which represents school bus drivers and other school support personnel in California. But SEIU locals in Michigan, New York, D.C. and Maryland have opposed the rule, preferring instead personal choice and increased education about the vaccines.

On Tuesday, Gov. Tom Wolf announced the requirement that some 25,000 state employees working in health care and other settings would be required to get the vaccine or undergo weekly COVID-19 testing starting Sept. 7. State SEIU Healthcare nurse John Berezansky seemed to back the initiative.

“We are ready to put our voices forward in the discussion and plan for universal vaccination in our workplaces,” Mr. Berezansky said in a statement. Union workers should receive “paid time off to get vaccinated.”

On Tuesday, AHN became among the first health care systems in Pennsylvania to set expectations for the COVID-19 vaccination of employees. About 73% of AHN’s workforce of 21,000 is fully vaccinated. Highmark’s goal is to have all employees get the shots, with exemptions for religious or medical reasons. The vaccination requirement is an expectation, but not a condition of employment, spokesman Dan Laurent said this week.

The new vaccination policy at Highmark doesn’t change the “terms or conditions” of employment for unionized workers, which is the tripwire that often means having to amend a labor agreement, labor lawyers say.

Advertise with us

Highmark’s vaccination expectation comes as its 13-hospital system is seeing an uptick in the number of people hospitalized for COVID-19. Fifty people are being cared for with COVID-19 in AHN hospitals, up from just six at the start of July, said Brian Parker, physician and chief quality officer at AHN.

Since the pandemic arrived in Western Pennsylvania last year, AHN has treated 7,000 people with COVID-19, including 769 people who’ve died from the disease. About half of the deaths occurred in people ages 61 to 80, Dr. Parker said. Vaccination is the key to stopping the spread of the disease.

“It’s the only way we’re going to escape the clutches of this pandemic,” he said.

The rising number of cases is blamed on the delta variant of the new coronavirus, which spreads faster and seems to cause more severe symptoms than the earlier alpha strand, he said.

By Monday, unvaccinated Highmark employees who work in a clinical setting will be required to wear a face shield in addition to a mask. Other measures, including weekly COVID-19 testing, were being considered, Dr. Parker said.

Advertise with us

“We’re closely monitoring our employees’ response to these measures,” Dr. Parker said.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699