Labor law may be bumping up against public health policy in the face of a highly contagious virus and vaccines aimed at preventing its spread.

When Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald was asked Thursday why current county employees were not required to be vaccinated against COVID-19, he veered into labor law by way of an answer.

“It becomes more complicated when it comes to collective bargaining and some other things along those lines,” he told reporters. Only new hires are required to be vaccinated.

County spokeswoman Amie Downs declined to elaborate.

Advertise with us

Creating a COVID-19 vaccination mandate for a unionized workforce means amending collective bargaining agreements because the requirement changes the terms and conditions of employment. 

Not many employers want to do that, labor attorneys say, especially when some unions are vocally opposed to vaccination mandates for their members.

Moreover, pressing the issue risks alienating union workers in a labor market where finding enough people to fill job slots is an issue, said Craig M. Brooks, an employment and labor lawyer at the Downtown firm of Houston Harbaugh.

“Without government guidance, employers are afraid they won’t be able to unilaterally impose that action on a unionized workforce,” Mr. Brooks said. “Most employers don’t want to be the test case. They don’t want to go there.”

Contract language found in the existing agreement between psychiatric nurses and JNESO District Council 1 at UPMC’s Western Psychiatric Institute & Clinic is typical of that included in many contracts.

Advertise with us

“Bargaining unit employees will be required to abide by all health and safety policies, including, but not limited to, policies on influenza vaccination and tobacco use,” according to the contract, which expires Sept. 30. “The hospital will negotiate with the union before any new vaccinations are required of bargaining unit members.”

Doug Placa, executive director of the North Brunswick, N.J.-based union, did not return calls for comment.

The reluctance to take up the issue with a unionized workforce comes as a growing chorus of public health officials is calling for mandatory vaccinations for COVID-19, especially for health care workers who treat people who are most vulnerable to the virus.

“A strong case could be made for the vaccine, particularly in health care workers who provide direct care and present the most significant risk to patients,” Mr. Brooks said. “The issue is the choice between harm to your patients, your customers, compared to the risk of complications to employees.”

Research so far has shown that the likelihood of complications from a COVID-19 vaccination is extremely low, while the number of new cases for the seven days ending Saturday reached 1,127 in Allegheny County — up 121% from the preceding week — and new hospitalizations for the disease rose by 76, or 43.4%, from the previous week, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Advertise with us

Neither Allegheny Health Network nor UPMC — the Pittsburgh region’s biggest health care providers — require hospital nurses to be vaccinated as a condition of employment.

UPMC’s no-COVID-19-vaccine policy extends to Cumberland-based UPMC Western Maryland, a 200-bed hospital that the health care giant acquired in 2020. In Maryland, nearly two-thirds of the state’s 60 hospitals and health systems are committed to making COVID-19 vaccines a condition of employment with options for people who are opposed to the shots for religious or health reasons.

Bob Atlas, president and CEO of the Maryland Hospital Association, said the requirement, which represented a consensus by hospital members, was the “right thing to do.” The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, which enforces anti-discrimination laws, ruled in May that employers have the right to require inoculation.

But the SEIU local representing health care workers in Maryland and the District of Columbia was against the requirement.

“We do not agree with the decision to mandate the COVID-19 vaccine for all health care staff,” 1199 SEIU executive vice president Lisa Brown for the Maryland-D.C. region of United Healthcare Workers East said in a statement.

Advertise with us

AHN and UPMC each have Pittsburgh-area hospital workers represented by SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania, where the union’s policy on mandatory COVID-19 vaccines was unclear. Union spokeswoman Karen Gownley on Friday declined to say whether the union backed such mandates.

Messages from other unions on the issue have been mixed.

In addition to D.C. and Maryland, SEIU Healthcare Michigan has come out in opposition to vaccination mandates imposed by Livonia-based Trinity Health for its 117,000 employees in 22 states. So has 1199 Service Employees International Union, which rallied in July against a vaccination mandate for NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital’s 48,000 employees by September.

Meanwhile, the AFL-CIO, the nation’s biggest labor federation, fully supports vaccine mandates, which are intended to stop the virus’s rapidly spreading variants.

The American Federation of Teachers, the nation’s second largest teachers union, had opposed any vaccine mandate until Sunday, when union president Randi Weingarten said the union should work with employers on the issue.

Advertise with us

“As a matter of personal conscience, I think that we need to be working with our employers, not opposing them, on vaccine mandates,” she said on NBC.

Amending labor agreements before expiration can be a fairly seamless process, especially when it involves matters of health and safety, said labor lawyer Richard P. Gilardi, principal at Downtown-based Gilardi, Oliver & Lomupo. But labor agreement or not, enforcing the requirement could be a headache.

“An employee can have a religious objection,” he said. “How to prove or not prove that — you can’t.”

Andrew Lacy Jr., founding attorney of the Lacy Employment Law Firm, said the safety of a vaccine can be a legitimate concern, but refusing the inoculation on constitutional grounds doesn’t work.

“There are legitimate concerns, but on the other hand it’s not their constitutional or civil right to refuse the vaccine,” said Mr. Lacy, who has offices Downtown.

Advertise with us

“Employers can require you to be vaccinated as part of your job, and it’s your right not to work for that employer. Your personal choice ends at where you work.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.