Seventeen of the 18 COVID-19 deaths in Westmoreland County as of Thursday were people who came from just three nursing homes, Coroner Ken Bacha said. The nursing homes have not been publicly identified — and there’s no state or federal requirement for the facilities to do so.

Mr. Bacha has declined to name the facilities because COVID-19 fatalities are considered natural deaths and therefore not the purview of the county coroner’s office. He’s not alone in that view. Coroners in Bedford and Blair counties supported that position.

The reluctance by coroners in the state to name such facilities should not be a surprise, said Charles E. Kiessling, president of the Pennsylvania Coroners Association. “It’s a natural disease process,” Mr. Kiessling said about COVID-19. “We don’t post our medical histories on the front doors of our houses.”

The disease ravaging the globe — and many long-term care faclities — has highlighted the issue of what information should be shared with families of nursing home residents, what the public should be told. Pennsylvania doesn’t make the data available beyond a countywide basis, although some other states are moving in that direction.

Advertise with us

Lori Smetanka, executive director of the Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit National Consumer Voice in Quality Long-Term Care, thinks the information needs to be shared.

“We’ve been pushing for public disclosure of these cases,” Ms. Smetanka said, not only to help inform consumers who are choosing a facility for a loved one, but because the information alerts authorities to where help is needed.

Pennsylvania has about 700 nursing homes, where more than 80,000 people with chronic health conditions live, according to the Pennsylvania Health Care Association, an advocacy group for an industry that has an $11.8 billion impact on the state economy.

The state also has 1,200 licensed personal care homes, which are lightly regulated facilities for people who need help with the activities of daily living.

Doctors say the elderly are at risk of contracting COVID-19 infections because of their age and underlying medical conditions and because the disease is 20 times as contagious as seasonal flu.

Advertise with us

“This is our most vulnerable population,” Secretary of Health Dr. Rachel Levine said Thursday during a press briefing.

Pennsylvania ranks fourth in the nation for number of people age 85 and older, and COVID-19 outbreaks have flared in long-term care facilities, both in the state and elsewhere in the U.S.

As of Thursday afternoon, more than half of Pennsylvania’s COVID-19 fatalities — 365 of 707 deaths — have come from nursing homes and personal care facilities, according to the state Health Department. A total of 306 facilities in 34 counties have been affected, with only a small number voluntarily telling the public that a staff member or resident had been infected.

The state Health Department data does not include names of long-term care facilities, just aggregate numbers of cases from those facilities.

Some other states are moving toward more transparency in letting the public know about COVID-19 outbreaks in long-term care centers.

Advertise with us

On Monday, for example, Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine ordered long-term care facilities in the Buckeye State to notify residents and families of COVID-19 cases and said a listing of those facilities must be posted on a state website.

Even though long-term care facilities in Pennsylvania are not mandated to disclose cases to the public, some facilities have done so voluntarily, including Oakmont-based Presbyterian SeniorCare, a sprawling senior residential care complex that operates 56 facilities, including ones housing 675 skilled nursing and 421 personal care beds.

Presby SeniorCare experienced its first COVID-19 case April 4 with a staff member who worked at Southminster Place, a personal care center in Washington County. Later testing identified two employees and one resident with the disease at the facility, said spokeswoman Lisa Fischetti.

Presby SeniorCare immediately notified staff and families, going door to door informing residents of the test results and starting quarantine measures. Details of the outbreak were posted on its website and media outlets were notified.

Disease outbreaks can be especially unsettling for people who are elderly or sick, Ms. Fischetti said, and transparency is the best way to assuage fears.

Advertise with us

“We honor the public’s trust and want to make sure to keep that trust,” Ms Fischetti said. “And part of that is being as transparent as we can. We feel like people need to know.”

Updated 11:26 a.m. April 17, 2020

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.

Correction, posted April 17, 2020: The state Health Department changed its policies this week to include releasing county-level case data on long-term facilities. 

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.