Medicare Advantage plan offerings for 2020, due for unveiling in nine days, seem unlikely to deliver the drama seen a year ago. There will be no hand-wringing about switching doctors or UPMC-like pre-payment surprises this time around.

That doesn’t mean it won’t be an active — even eventful — open enrollment period, with national insurer Aetna now staking its own claim with UPMC and Highmark as a major player in the local Medicare Advantage market.

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services does not allow insurers to market, or even publicly discuss, their plans for 2020 until Oct. 1.

Some local brokers, however, have been briefed on the plans’ particulars and, while circumspect about providing specifics, they did share general observations about what seniors can expect for next year’s offerings.

Advertise with us

“Last year it was about access,” summarized Aaron Zolbrod, president of The Health Insurance Store in Forest Hills and Connellsville. “This year it’s going to be about value.”

Open enrollment, a period during which seniors sign up for their 2020 coverage, runs Oct. 15–Dec. 7. Unlike traditional Medicare, which is administered by CMS, Medicare Advantage plans are Medicare-approved plans offered by private insurers.

For 2020, most network questions have been answered now that UPMC and Highmark have made their peace or, at least, agreed to a truce for the next decade.

In that respect, “I think it’s going to be smoother than it was last year,” said Brian Breisinger, president of MediConnect Insurance brokerage in Kennedy. “I don’t think we’re going to see as much movement as we did last year.”

Liz Kennon of Kennon Insurance Consultants Inc. in Shadyside said last year she saw the same migration that other brokers witnessed — clients moving away from Highmark plans to assure access to UPMC’s vast network of hospitals and providers.

Advertise with us

“We don’t anticipate that this year,” she said. While she could see Highmark regaining some of those members for 2020, she added, “If they’re happy with UPMC, I don’t know that they’ll move back.”

Based on the rates he has seen, Mr. Zolbrod said he doesn’t believe Highmark will regain a large number of members.

“I was expecting Highmark to be more competitive on the Medicare Advantage plans to get these people back,” he said. While their rates will be on par with other insurers, “They did very little to make their plans competitive.”

On the other hand, he added, a national insurer — he wouldn’t volunteer which one — “got very aggressive in 2019 and has gotten even more aggressive in 2020” on premiums and coverage. He thinks that could foretell this third player moving closer to the Medicare Advantage enrollments that UPMC and Highmark enjoy.

“There are people who are afraid of changing carriers they’ve had for years,” Mr. Zolbrod said, “but when you’re talking about saving $600-$800 in premiums and having lower co-payments, sometimes that fear can be overcome.”

Advertise with us

Most likely, the national insurer he’s referring to is Aetna, which has had success in recent years winning long-held contracts — and members — from competitors.

Two years ago, Aetna wrested from Highmark the administration of the Penn State University’s medical benefits program, which covers more than 40,000 employees and their dependents. (Highmark does still have a contract that provides coverage for more than 22,000 employees at Penn State Health, which includes the Hershey Medical Center.)

Aetna also was the clear winner earlier this year during the January-March open enrollment period when Medicare beneficiaries could make a one-time switch to another carrier. By comparison, United HealthCare, the national insurer with the second-largest presence locally, gained 165 members for a countywide total of about 5,700. Highmark had lost nearly 2,000 members by the March 31 conclusion of the open enrollment period.

Aetna’s gain of 1,674 enrollments during those three months helped raise its Allegheny County Medicare Advantage enrollment to 36,176 members, just behind Highmark’s 40,000 members.

Overall, UPMC Health Plan, remains the area’s largest Medicare Advantage insurer with 62,569 Medicare Advantage members in Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

Mr. Breisinger said he has seen a similar swing toward Aetna at MediConnect.

Of the 4,000 or so applications they’ve processed each of the last two years, he said, more clients have chosen Aetna than either UPMC or Highmark — likely because of its members’ access to both UPMC and Highmark Health’s Allegheny Health Network.

Plenty of other factors can come into play for individual seniors, most notably prescription drug coverage. That means finding the best plan will take some research, and maybe some help, and not just for the coming year.

Said Mr. Zolbrod: “I think we’re headed for a period where we could see people changing from one Medicare Advantage plan to another every year for the next five years.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.