U.S. Sen. Bob Casey has asked the federal agency that oversees Medicare to intervene before Pittsburgh health care giant UPMC implements a July 1 policy requiring Highmark Medicare Advantage members to pay upfront for services.

Stating that “patient care could be at risk,” Mr. Casey on Monday urged U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar “to prevent this policy from taking effect, while also not allowing UPMC to simply refuse care to out-of-network beneficiaries.”

In addition, Mr. Casey asked Mr. Azar to authorize a special enrollment period that would allow Medicare Advantage members to “select a plan that may better meet their needs.”

UPMC spokesman Paul Wood on Monday said the health system supports Mr. Casey’s call for a special enrollment period once the UPMC-Highmark consent decrees expire June 30. “It would provide Highmark Medicare Advantage members with the opportunity to reconsider their insurance choices and switch to plans that offer the in-network access to the hospitals and doctors of UPMC,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Wood also said that federal regulations allow providers such as UPMC to require pre-payment from out-of-network patients for non-emergency care. “Highmark has acknowledged this and can promptly reimburse its members for advance payments made to UPMC or make other payment arrangements directly with its members,” he said.

Highmark spokesman Anthony Matrisciano, meanwhile, said that his organization agrees with Mr. Casey “that local seniors should be protected from UPMC’s attempts to force them to pay up front for health care before appointments are even scheduled.

“There is broad agreement that UPMC’s pre-payment requirement is unnecessary and violates the spirit of nonprofit health care,” he said. “Highmark has decades of experience paying out-of-network claims nationwide and calls on UPMC to abandon this policy and take patients out of the middle.”

U.S. Health and Human Services’s media relations staff had not responded to a request for comment by close of business Monday.

UPMC announced Oct. 1 that it would begin requiring Highmark and other out-of-network Medicare Advantage members to pay the estimated cost of their care before receiving those services.

Advertise with us

The policy is set to begin July 1, when the five-year UPMC-Highmark consent decrees expire and the two health giants’ contractual relationship ends in the Pittsburgh and Erie markets.

Medicare Advantage plans are approved by Medicare but offered by private insurers. Beneficiaries with traditional Medicare fee-for-service plans with supplements are not affected by the Highmark-UPMC network dispute.

Attorney General Josh Shapiro currently has an appeal before the state Supreme Court in a case meant to extend the consent decrees, at least temporarily. A hearing on that appeal is scheduled for May 16.

In his letter Monday, Mr. Casey told Mr. Azar, “It is unclear if there will be a resolution before June 30 that will provide a definitive answer and needed assistance for Pennsylvanians.”

While the UPMC-Highmark dissolution has been years in the making, many seniors have held off making a final decision to choose between keeping a long-held health plan and keeping access to UPMC hospitals and physicians.

Advertise with us

They had one last chance to switch plans between January and March during the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ extended open enrollment period.

Many did just that, as Highmark saw its Medicare Advantage rolls drop by nearly 2,000 members in the first months of this year while Aetna and other national insurers — who contract with UPMC and Highmark Health’s Allegheny Health Network — saw significant gains.

Mr. Casey said more than 100,000 Medicare Advantage beneficiaries still stand to lose in-network access to doctors and hospitals after June 30 — specifically citing cancer patients with Highmark insurance who will lose in-network access to UPMC’s Hillman Cancer Center.

“This situation is made worse by UPMC’s decision to require all out-of-network beneficiaries to prepay for services from a doctor’s visit, to lab work, to surgery,” Mr. Casey wrote.

He added, “Requiring seniors and people with disabilities to pay thousands of dollars in advance is unacceptable for a nonprofit health system.”

Advertise with us

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.

Updated at 5:17 p.m. April 29, 2019