As the clock ticks down on the consent decrees linking Pittsburgh health care rivals Highmark and UPMC, the attorney general’s office this week asked the state Supreme Court for an interim order extending the contracts until a final Commonwealth Court ruling on a proposed rewrite can be made.
The filing by Attorney General Josh Shapiro’s office on Wednesday notes that the June 30 expiration of the consent decrees, which will make UPMC doctors and hospitals off limits to thousands of Highmark health insurance members, will come too soon for the court to fully consider the AG office’s efforts to overhaul the contracts.
The move may be a concession that Mr. Shapiro’s push is running out of time if it is to have any impact. UPMC has not yet responded to Mr. Shapiro’s filing.
In the lawsuit that the attorney general filed against UPMC in February, the government sought an indefinite extension of the consent decrees.
Wednesday’s filing by the attorney general adds brackets to the extension he seeks, giving the court an option and saying, in essence, that a slice of the cake — rather than the whole cake — would be fine.
“Even with the court’s expedited briefing and argument schedule, it would be impossible for the Commonwealth Court to proceed to a final judgment on the merits before June 30, 2019, the date the consent decrees are currently set to expire,” Mr. Shapiro wrote in the filing.
Read More
“Legally, the situation the commonwealth finds itself in is admittedly unusual, but also urgent. There is no clear procedure available to obtain relief.”
Attorney general spokesman Joe Grace said there had been no change in the office’s position. The state would continue to press for an indefinite extension of the Highmark-UPMC agreement in Commonwealth Court, he said.
“We have not changed our position,” Mr. Grace said. “The clock is ticking loudly.”
Highmark and UPMC agreed to terms in 2012 that allowed Highmark members to see UPMC doctors at in-network, discounted rates. Those agreements, which were contained in consent decrees brokered by state regulators, expire June 30.
Commonwealth Court upheld the expiration date in an April 3 ruling and the attorney general is appealing the decision to the state Supreme Court.
Arguments on the appeal are scheduled May 16 in Harrisburg.
The Commonwealth Court ruling was a setback for Mr. Shapiro, who had unsuccessfully argued that the modification was not constrained by a time limit.
In a separate, but related matter Wednesday, a judge in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania dismissed a UPMC lawsuit that was filed against Mr. Shapiro challenging his authority to modify the consent decrees.
Overhauling the consent decrees is in the public interest, the attorney general wrote in the brief Wednesday, and upholding the run out date would deny the government the chance to be heard in court.
“To allow UPMC to achieve victory by delay at the expense of the health care of hundreds of thousands of vulnerable Pennsylvanians would, in effect, violate the commonwealth’s right to have its petition to modify heard at all,” the attorney general wrote.
“Specifically, the commonwealth requests that this court extend the end date of the consent decrees until the courts have reached a final, unappealable decision on its petition for modification.”
The attorney general’s court filings have been replete with examples of inconvenience, higher costs and harm that would come to Highmark health insurance members if access to UPMC doctors and hospitals is cut off. Many of the affected people have serious diseases and have been successfully treated by UPMC doctors for years.
The court battle reflects a soured relationship between Highmark and UPMC, who turned bitter rivals in 2011 with Highmark’s announcement that it was getting into the clinical care business by buying the former West Penn Allegheny Health System of hospitals and employed doctors.
UPMC controls many hospitals in Allegheny and surrounding counties and Highmark and UPMC cooperated as allies before the West Penn Allegheny acquisition.
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.