Some of Cindy Siebauer’s earliest memories include taking street cars from Brookline to doctors’ appointments at Children’s Hospital, which was then located on Fifth Avenue in Oakland.

Since age 2, she has had a disease that progressively damaged the tiny blood vessels in her kidneys and caused other problems. The Upper St. Clair woman is now 54 years old. She had kidney transplants in 1984 and 1994.

Ms. Siebauer also has a precancerous condition called smoldering myeloma, a blood clotting disorder and issues with her shoulder. She received the kidney transplants at Pittsburgh health system UPMC, where she was also treated for the precancerous condition at UPMC’s Hillman Cancer Center.

Upcoming UPMC-Highmark split causes anxiety

She’s also very familiar with Highmark’s Allegheny Health Network.

Advertise with us

She has Highmark health insurance through husband Michael’s employer, the U.S. Postal Service, where he is a supervisor. Since AHN accepts her insurance, she’s received care there and her primary care doctor admits patients to both health systems because he’s an independent practitioner.

Ms. Siebauer has no complaint with either health care system. It wasn’t the medical options in Pittsburgh or the pending runout of the Highmark-UPMC consent decrees in June that finally drove her out of the city for care.

Here’s what did it: She worried she would become a casualty in the battle for market share between the city’s two health care Goliaths.

“I want them all together: I want my kidney doctor to talk to my heart doctor to talk to my primary care doctor. Am I going to get the right health care when they’re in a power struggle over money?”

In 2016, Ms. Siebauer switched her care to the Cleveland Clinic, a 2.5-hour drive from Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

She discovered she’s not the only Pittsburgher doing it. During her visits she’s met others from the city going out of town for care. Cleveland Clinic, like virtually every other Blue-certified health care provider in the country, is covered by her Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield insurance.

Cleveland Clinic officials would not say how many patients come from Pennsylvania. Hospitals like UPMC Presbyterian and Allegheny General often refer to the defection of patients out of the region as patient leakage, an uncomfortable statistic that means a loss of revenue.

Ms. Siebauer didn’t know how much her insurer had paid Cleveland Clinic for her care, but said her out-of-pocket expenses were minimal. Among the procedures she’s had done there were surgical repair of a torn shoulder rotator cuff, blood work and pulmonary testing.

The Ohio hospital may draw still more patient dollars from the Pittsburgh area in the years to come.

In February, Cleveland Clinic president and CEO Tom Mihaljevic announced plans to double the clinic’s patient volume over the next five years.

Advertise with us

The health system provided care for more than 2 million people in 2018, a record for the Cleveland institution.

“We can’t take this demand for granted,” Dr. Mihaljevic said in a prepared statement. “It’s our moral obligation to open our doors as wide as possible for those in need.”

Other initiatives meant to increase the Cleveland Clinic’s patient volumes include expanding telehealth services domestically and globally; opening Cleveland Clinic London in 2021; and investing in infrastructure, according to a spokeswoman.

Cleveland Clinic is not like most hospitals in one respect, which some people see as an enhancement to care. The clinic’s doctors are salaried rather than paid according to the number of procedures and tests performed, which advocates say limits unnecessary medical interventions and keeps patients at the center of care.

Ms. Siebauer noticed the difference when her Cleveland Clinic doctor opted not to repeat medical scans that were done in Pittsburgh. Repeating tests at different institutions is a common practice among doctors.

Advertise with us

Ms. Siebauer, who retired with disability in 2006 as a medical records clerk, said patients without a working understanding of medicine will be the biggest losers in the Highmark-UPMC struggle.

They won’t be able to fully evaluate medical options or know what choices are best for them.

“It’s hard for me to think of this health system as a business when it involves my health, but it is a business,” Ms. Siebauer said. “There are people out there with no medical background and they’re just going to be kind of lost. It’s just a mess here.”

Top health care organizations The region's largest health care organizations ranked by 2018 revemnue:

*Pittsburgh Mercy is a member of Trinity Health, serving in the tradition of the Sisters of Mercy. Source: Individual organizations | Ed Yozwick/Post-Gazette

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699