Observation status is the original surprise medical bill, arriving on the health care scene years before “surprise bill” became a talking point about narrowing provider networks.

For a decade or so, patients have been baffled and too often blindsided by the hospital observation-admission designation, in which hospitals and insurers decide if a patient’s condition requires an inpatient stay or merely outpatient monitoring.

Small wonder it’s confusing: For the same care, the same tests, the same overnight stay, your insurance plan may cover nearly all the cost -– or hardly any of it.

That decision -– which puts thousands of dollars in out-of-pocket costs in play -– depends on whether the insurer ultimately decides the treatment did not warrant an inpatient admission.

Advertise with us

A final determination may not come until after you’ve left the hospital, arriving as an unanticipated invoice weeks later.

“‘Observation’ is not really a clinical term. It’s an insurance company term,” said Denis Lukes, chief financial officer for the Healthcare Council of Western Pennsylvania.

Because of the dynamic state of Pittsburgh-area health systems — with both UPMC and Allegheny Health Network adding to their hospital rosters — getting precise numbers over multiple years that show how many more patients are classified as “observations” is difficult to pin down.

But data collected by the health care council shows a revealing trend:

In the Pittsburgh region, Mr. Lukes said, traditional fee-for-service Medicare categorizes patients as “observation” less than 20 percent of the time.

Advertise with us

By comparison, Highmark and UPMC Health Plan — the region’s two largest insurers — label visits an “observation” 31.5 percent of the time and national insurers Aetna and United Healthcare 36.6 percent of the time, or nearly twice as often as Medicare.

Using traditional Medicare as a benchmark, Mr. Lukes said the higher rate of observation cases from other insurers means hospitals receive $225 million less in payments — losses they must either absorb or bill patients to recover.

Observation vs. admission: the cost to hospitals, consumers Hospitals in Western Pennsylvania say private insurers are more likely to designate hospital stays as outpatient observations, rather than inpatient admissions, which means hospitals receive millions less in payments while consumers may face greater out-of-pocket costs. The chart below shows how much hospitals would receive if those insurers categorized cases as observations at the same lower rate as Medicare. LOST HOSPITAL REVENUE (in millions of dollars)

*Three months ended 9/30/2019 annualized (projected) Note: Traditional Medicare classifies approximately 20% of cases as observation. Source: Healthcare Council of Western Pennsylvania | graphic: Ed Yozwick/Post-Gazette

The distinction also carries perils after a short-term hospital stay, when the patient is still too fragile at discharge to go home — a not uncommon scenario for seniors, who are more likely to have multiple health issues.

Advertise with us

Under Medicare Part A, inpatient hospital care is covered at a skilled nursing facility. But an outpatient observation would fall under Part B, which covers doctor’s office visits, so the patient pays 20 percent of the bill unless that individual has a Medigap supplement.

That’s not all. If an inpatient admission does not extend over at least three days, Medicare will not pay for skilled nursing care.

Because of the charges involved — anywhere from $150 to more than $700 a day for skilled nursing — the facility may ask for payment, and possibly the entire estimated cost, upfront.

In 2011, Medicare beneficiaries decided to fight back with a class-action suit. They accused the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services of effectively pressuring hospitals to put patients on observation status as a cost-savings measure, violating patients’ rights under the federal Medicare Act.

A judge dismissed the suit earlier this year, saying the law allows physicians to decide who is admitted and who is merely observed.

Advertise with us

Patients, meanwhile, are left to guess and hope.

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.