UPMC won a round in a court battle Wednesday when a federal judge in Pittsburgh dismissed a whistle-blower lawsuit against the health care giant.

Three former UPMC employees had alleged that the system’s bonus compensation arrangement with neurosurgeons was essentially a kickback scheme that inflated revenue for the system while hurting patient care.

In October, UPMC battled back in a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, saying in a court filing that such compensation plans are not only legal, but a medical industry standard.

U.S. District Court Judge Cathy Bissoon rejected the plaintiffs’ claims in her order, but allowed them to file an amended “one last, best chance” complaint by July 10.

Advertise with us

UPMC was buoyed by the ruling.

“UPMC is pleased with the court’s decision, which affirms what we knew to be true, that the exaggerated claims about the appropriateness of procedures performed by our neurosurgeons had absolutely no merit and that once those claims were eliminated, there was nothing left to the case,” the statement read.

Lawyer Andrew Stone, who is representing former UPMC employees J. William Bookwalter, Robert Sclabassi and Anna Mitina, was unavailable for comment.

The three former employees filed the lawsuit, called a qui tam, against UPMC in 2012. It was unsealed last year.

In lawsuits filed under the whistle-blower statute, plaintiffs and their attorneys can get anywhere from 15 percent to 30 percent of any eventual settlement or judgment. The government gets the rest.

Advertise with us

In this case, the Justice Department investigated the allegations and without admitting liability, UPMC paid the government $2.5 million to settle some of the claims, while the plaintiffs continued pursuing remaining claims without government involvement.

The lawsuit claimed that UPMC’s compensation plan created an unlawful inducement for surgeons to do procedures that were more complicated than necessary to boost revenue. The number and complexity of procedures performed over an annual minimum set by the health system entitled neurosurgeons to a 28.5 percent bonus in violation of federal law, according to the lawsuit.

The plaintiffs claimed that UPMC neurosurgeons had billed for operations that were actually done by lesser trained medical professionals, including physician assistants, who are master’s degree level trained with clinical experience. Such arrangements would allowed neurosurgeons to double-book operations. Similar claims have been made in Boston and Seattle in recent years, where doctors have sued health care systems over concurrent surgical booking.

Judge Bissoon said she would not tolerate using the pretrial tool of discovery to justify the allegations.

“In the amended complaint, plaintiffs recount page after page of boilerplate standards regarding the statutory and regulatory schemes, yet they offer only bald conclusions that the ‘(contracting) parties did not satisfy any exceptions’” to Medicare rules, Judge Bissoon wrote. “As should be evident, moreover, the court will have a watchful eye toward ensuring that discovery, if any, will not degenerate into a fishing expedition.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699