A debate over who is included in the definition of “vulnerable populations” and over UPMC’s obligation to continue including Highmark’s Medicare Advantage members in its network highlighted more than an hour’s worth of oral arguments Tuesday before the state Supreme Court.
UPMC hopes to convince the five sitting justices to vacate a May ruling by Commonwealth Court President Judge Dan Pellegrini ordering the Pittsburgh health care provider to continue seeing Highmark’s 182,000 Medicare Advantage members at lower in-network rates.
Attorneys with the state attorney general’s office and those representing Highmark argued that the ruling should stand.
Tuesday’s proceeding, held in the Supreme Court chambers, Downtown, revolved around four sentences in a more than 8,000-word consent decree document that was negotiated between UPMC and Highmark more than a year ago in anticipation of the end of their contract this year.
Tuesday’s arguments before the state Supreme Court centered on this passage from the 2014 consent decrees:
“Vulnerable Populations — UPMC and Highmark mutually agree that vulnerable populations include: (i) consumers age 65 or older who are eligible or covered by Medicare, Medicare Advantage, (ii) Medigap health plans, (iii) Medicaid and/or (iv) CHIP. With respect to Highmark’s covered vulnerable populations, UPMC shall continue to contract with Highmark at in-network rates for all of its hospital, physician and appropriate continuity of care services for CHIP, Highmark Signature 65, Medigap and commercial retiree carve out as long as Highmark does not make unilateral material changes to these programs. UPMC shall treat all Medicare participating consumers as In-Network regardless of whether they have Medicare as their primary or secondary insurance. UPMC reserves the right to withdraw from these arrangements if Highrnark should take the position that it has the authority to revise the rates and fees payable under those arrangements unilaterally and materially.”
Read More
The first sentence in the “vulnerable populations” paragraph mentions Medicare Advantage subscribers among the included groups. But the next sentence, which lists which plans UPMC agrees to contract with Highmark at in-network rates, does not.
Medicare Advantage plans are Medicare-approved plans offered through private insurance companies that typically offer additional coverage above standard Medicare.
Representing UPMC, attorney Stephen Cozen of Cozen O’Connor in Philadelphia said it was Highmark that wanted the reference to Medicare Advantage removed in that second sentence to make way for its launch of its narrow network Community Blue product that does not include higher-cost UPMC facilities.
He also argued the consent decrees were not written “as an irrevocable five-year contract” that would imply Highmark subscribers “are owned by Highmark” and unable to consider signing up for competing plans. He maintained that, under the decree provision, “We always had the right to non-renew.”
Chief Deputy Attorney General John Knorr III and Kim Watterson of Reed Smith, representing Highmark, countered that the language is clear in its inclusion of Highmark Medicare Advantage subscribers for the five-year duration of the consent decrees.
“To say people who participate in Medicare Advantage are somehow not part of Medicare is just not true,” said Mr. Knorr.
Rather than isolating one sentence in the “vulnerable populations” provision, “They are all part of a single paragraph and they should be read together,” Ms. Watterson said. “The consent decrees clearly require all UPMC hospitals and physicians to be in-network for the vulnerable populations, including Medicare Advantage.”
UPMC’s appeal has added an element of uncertainty for Highmark’s 182,000 Medicare Advantage members. No decision is expected by the justices for weeks or even months while the yearly open enrollment period begins Oct. 15 and ends Dec. 7.
As long as the Commonwealth Court ruling stands, Highmark’s Medicare Advantage members will continue to be in-network for UPMC physicians and hospitals.
Should the Supreme Court reverse that ruling before Jan. 1, Mr. Cozen said there is a six-month run out clause following the contract expiration during which Medicare Advantage members remain in-network. He said subscribers also likely would be granted a special open enrollment period if they wanted to change plans.
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.