Highmark’s 182,000 Medicare Advantage members won’t have an opportunity to testify, but nobody has more at stake than they do when state Supreme Court justices hear oral arguments today on whether Pittsburgh health care giant UPMC must include them in its network next year.
The session in the City-County Building, Downtown, convenes just nine days before the annual Medicare open enrollment period begins, when seniors can look over insurers’ various offerings and decide if they will stay with their current plan or find another that would work better for them.
Should the justices rule in UPMC’s favor, the options get more complicated: Do Highmark Medicare Advantage members stay with the Pittsburgh insurer and give up affordable access to their UPMC physician, or do they switch to another insurer?
They likely won’t get direction from the court for weeks or even months.
Selecting a plan “is difficult enough for these people without adding in a huge wild card,” said Erin Ninehouser, policy director for the Pennsylvania Health Access Network, a statewide coalition of more than 60 organizations that advocates for wider access to health care.
“It’s a lot of uncertainty and anxiety for seniors who should not have to deal with this.”
Read More
Ms. Ninehouser said the health access network sent letters to 20,000 local seniors last spring after UPMC said it intended to exclude Highmark Medicare Advantage members from its network beginning in 2016. UPMC said it was responding to Highmark’s decision to reduce payments to UPMC for treating cancer patients.
The letters triggered more than 5,000 responses.
Some seniors indicated they’ll change plans because they’re tired of the back and forth between UPMC and Highmark, she said. But “the overwhelming response was anger that UPMC is doing this. They believe they are unfairly being pulled into this war.”
UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said its termination of the Medicare Advantage agreements “will not harm seniors. They will enjoy the benefits of increasing choice and competition in the marketplace and, as data publicly available since Oct. 1 shows, lower insurance premiums if they choose a non-Highmark Medicare Advantage plan.”
Under state-brokered consent decrees signed last year in anticipation of the two ending their long-term relationship that provided Highmark subscribers full access to UPMC services, Highmark seniors and other “vulnerable populations” had assurances they would retain access to UPMC facilities and physicians.
That changed when UPMC accused Highmark of making a “unilateral material change” to the agreements by withholding what Highmark considered unfair markups by UPMC for treating cancer patients.
State officials filed a complaint over the UPMC threat and Commonwealth Court President Judge Dan Pellegrini ruled in May that UPMC must continue to include Highmark’s Medicare Advantage members.
UPMC has appealed that ruling, setting up today’s oral arguments proceeding, which is open to the public.
Highmark’s Medicare Advantage seniors, meanwhile, face an unsettling prospect: What happens if they renew their Highmark plan and the court overturns the Commonwealth Court ruling months from now?
Brack Barr, 69, of Sheraden no doubt echoed the sentiment of many: He wants to stay with Highmark, but he also doesn’t want to find new doctors. “Both of them are super rich and I don’t think either one would be hurt if things stayed the same.”
With the two sides still haggling over rates and network access, reconciliation seems unlikely.
That has left people like Kay Thomas, 78, of Brookline in a quandary. She and her husband, Charles, like Highmark because it’s familiar and they know they’re still covered when they visit their daughters in Florida and Texas. But Charles has twice battled cancer, so far successfully, under the treatment of UPMC physicians.
“If he had to lose the doctors who have worked with him through this thing, he would be devastated,” she said. “That is painful to even think about. I don’t know what we would do.”
Ms. Ninehouser said simply switching to another national insurer is not always an option. “For some people, the choice is made for them if they have a retiree plan that is offering only one plan.”
Mr. Barr, a Medicare Advantage subscriber for three years, thinks there actually is some certainty regardless of how the Supreme Court justices see it.
“Whoever loses is going to figure out a way to jack up my costs anyhow,” he said. “The only people who get hurt are the patients.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.