A press release from Gov. Tom Wolf’s office last week has prompted different interpretations of its meaning, while not settling a key question for many people in the Pittsburgh area:

Will Highmark members be able to continue seeing their UPMC doctors on an in-network basis for routine care?

“We haven’t had a situation where we’ve been called to act on that yet,” said Insurance Department spokesman Ron Ruman on Tuesday. “Our position is that we wanted to make a statement that we’re going to enforce the consent decrees that both parties signed, in the language contained in those.

“We don’t view this as changing anything that was in place.”

Advertise with us

The press release issued Thursday outlined the intent of acting Insurance Commissioner Teresa Miller’s and acting Health Secretary Karen Murphy’s departments “to enforce key consumer protection provisions in the consent decrees signed last year by Highmark and UPMC.”

It also specifically noted that Highmark insurance members who had seen a UPMC physician before the Jan. 1 contract expiration between the two Pittsburgh organizations get to decide, in consultation with their physician, whether they can continue receiving medical care from a UPMC provider “for an ongoing medical condition.”

Does that include yearly physicals or other routine care? Health Department spokeswoman Holli Senior said: “As individual situations with patients arise, these will help us further define how these consent decrees will be enforced to ensure consumer protection. We do not view this [press release] as either reaffirming or changing anything, other than again confirming we intend to enforce the consent decrees as written.

“To date, no enforcement actions have been taken under these agreements, so there is nothing to either affirm or change in that regard.”

Some took note of what the state did not address: Whether it agrees with a Dec. 30 letter from the previous administration saying Highmark patients would be ineligible to see UPMC physicians on an in-network basis for nonserious injuries or illness.

Advertise with us

“Until this latest announcement, I thought only serious conditions would trigger the continuity of care clause. Now, I’m not so sure,” said Stephen Foreman, an associate professor of economics and health administration at Robert Morris University.

The problem, he said, is that the announcement isn’t specific. “If the administration wants to continue with the notion that continuity of care is triggered by serious illness, then they should say that. If they haven’t thought it through yet, they should say that. And if they have reservations about [eligibility] being that narrow, they should say that.

“In certain settings, you need clarity, and this is one of them.”

Mr. Ruman, at the state Insurance Department, said they are certainly aware of the Dec. 30 letter but “the language in the consent decrees on what is covered, that’s the language we’re going to enforce. There will be situations from patients that will further define how these will be enforced.

“Hopefully we’re all trying to do what’s right by the patients.”

Advertise with us

The implications are far-reaching, as a final decision one way or the other could affect a large portion of the region’s residents, as Highmark members may be prompted to switch from their UPMC doctors to avoid higher medical bills while some UPMC physicians might risk losing patients.

The issue may not come to a head until 2016 because of a safety net provision that allows Highmark members to continue seeing their UPMC physicians through 2015. But that hasn’t stopped the questions or confusion.

UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said Tuesday, “UPMC, as always, supports the most patient-friendly interpretation of the ‘continuity of care’ provision of the consent decree as adopted by the Commonwealth in its March 5 press release; namely, it’s a decision between the patient and their physician regardless of diagnoses and with no other qualifications.”

A Highmark spokesman declined to comment beyond a statement issued last week: “We look forward to continuing working with the state as they provide further definition and enforcement of all the protections spelled out in the consent decree.”

For his part, Mr. Foreman remains concerned about the implications of ongoing ambiguity.

Advertise with us

“The consequences of the lack of clarity are so large. Are we now going to be seeing a series of arbitration hearings? Or are we going to see some public interest legal proceedings?” he said.

He can foresee Highmark members asking a judge to decide if they can keep seeing their UPMC physicians, possibly arguing in court that “ ‘I get to keep my physician until these issues are resolved,’ ” he said.

“I think it would help everyone if the administration would be as clear as it could be about their view of the consent decree.”