As Pittsburgh’s dueling health titans continue to quarrel over which Highmark customers can keep their UPMC doctors, UPMC is girding for battle by having local Highmark customers preemptively confirming their wish to keep their clinicians.

The state Department of Health had set a Friday deadline for Highmark and UPMC to come to an agreement on that dispute. Otherwise, the state will step in and mediate the issue, it said in a letter to both companies.

Highmark and UPMC have had “interactions this week, and we’re hopeful that we can make progress,” Highmark spokesman Doug Braunsdorf said Friday. No agreement was reached by the Friday deadline, though, and UPMC’s assessment of the interactions was less than upbeat.

“I [am] not sure what Highmark characterizes as ‘progress,’ ” UPMC’s Paul Wood said.

Advertise with us

As of Jan. 1, none of Highmark’s under-65 commercial customers has contractual in-network access to the entirety of the UPMC hospital network. That means Highmark customers are now supposed to be locked out of most of UPMC’s Allegheny County hospitals.

But despite seeking and eventually winning a partial lockout, UPMC is now trying to keep many of those Highmark customers by arguing that their ongoing care is permitted under the consent decree that governs the breakup of the health companies.

The consent decree said that “the continuation of care of a Highmark member in the midst of a course of treatment at UPMC shall be on an in-network basis, at in-network rates,” and that the decision to continue the treatment would lie with the UPMC doctor and the patient.

In a mid-December email, Steven Shapiro, UPMC chief medical and scientific officer, told all health system physicians that UPMC would soon be “calling Highmark commercial subscribers [to explain that] any Highmark patients under your care, whether it is for preventive, acute or chronic care, have the right to continue in your care at in-network rates.”

But at the end of December, the state Health Department sent a letter to UPMC and Highmark, suggesting that UPMC is interpreting the continuity-of-care provision too broadly.

Advertise with us

Even so, UPMC wants to make sure it has an electronic paper trail in place if and when Highmark and the Health Department come calling. That’s why it’s asking patients to review a document attesting the patient’s understanding of the consent decree, and stipulating that “I agree with this recommendation and wish to continue my treatment.”

The document will then be noted in the patient’s electronic medical record.

With the state’s deadline having come and gone, a Health Department spokeswoman said Friday evening that “we do not have anything to report today definitively on next steps.”

Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.