Moira and Andrew Brennen’s first child is due Saturday. For a few days last week, the Highland Park couple thought they might have to make a last-minute change in their plans to deliver at UPMC Magee-Womens hospital.

The Brennens have Highmark insurance through his employer and for the past nine months Mrs. Brennen has received prenatal care from a 12-physician UPMC obstetrics-gynecology practice. The couple assumed they were covered at in-network rates under the consent decrees signed by UPMC and Highmark last summer ahead of the Dec. 31 end of the contract between the two Pittsburgh health companies.

But conflicting information from Highmark nearly derailed the couple’s plans.

Mrs. Brennen said they called their insurer with a few questions last Thursday. The customer service representative’s response caught them by surprise:

Advertise with us

The delivery would qualify for in-network rates only if one of the five UPMC obstetricians Mrs. Brennan saw in 2014 delivered the baby, she said the representative told them. If any of the other seven doctors in the practice did the procedure, it would be considered out-of-network and likely hundreds of dollars more expensive.

“I didn’t know what to say,” Mrs. Brennen said. “It’s our first baby so I’m already freaking out about everything else.”

For two days, they considered their options.

“I was like, ‘Maybe I should go to West Penn [hospital].’ It was not what I wanted to do, to go find another hospital and see a doctor I’ve never seen before,” Mrs. Brennen said. She thought of another alternative as well: Make an appointment at Magee to be induced, whether it was medically necessary or not.

Their worry, it turns out, may have been for naught.

Advertise with us

In a second call to Highmark on Saturday, Mrs. Brennen said they were assured by a different representative that the birth was covered no matter which doctor in the practice delivered the baby. That interpretation was backed by a Highmark spokesman contacted by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

With just days before the birth of their new daughter, Audrey, the Brennens still feel unsettled.

“It’s nice to hear what you want to hear,” Mrs. Brennen said, “but I still wonder if maybe the first person was correct and the other person was not.”

The same could be said for many patients trying to sort out networks and affiliations in a post-UPMC-Highmark world.

With the network contract now expired following UPMC’s decision not to negotiate with Highmark and its competing health system, questions about what constitutes continuity of care and what tests and procedures are still in-network continue to pop up.

Advertise with us

“It’s good for business in that people need answers, so they reach out to brokers more and more because we’re not biased,” said Liz Kennon, of Kennon Insurance Consultants Inc., which has offices in Venetia, Washington County and in Shadyside.

“What is frustrating is that I can’t give any definite answers because, as it stands, it seems to change from day to day.”

She doesn’t want to make the wrong recommendation for a client, but the choices are not always clear or constant. Ms. Kennon said she personally switched from Highmark to UPMC to have continued access to her UPMC physicians but said clients with out-of-state employees, or parents with college-bound children, might do better with Highmark’s wider network.

“We haven’t seen a huge transition” from one insurer to the other, she said.

The Brennens have a busy spring lined up. In addition to the new baby, Mrs. Brennen said they will be moving to Atlanta before summer.

Advertise with us

Despite Highmark’s assurances, Mrs. Brennen worries there may be surprises when they learn their share of the cost.

“When the bill comes, we’ll let you know,” she said.

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.