City officials are still weighing different measures to fast-track development in Pittsburgh — but one influential board on Tuesday shot down a proposal by an outgoing City Council member.

Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith in June proposed legislation that called for speeding up the city’s zoning application review and approval process. The two bills are part of a larger package that could revamp the city agencies overseeing land use and change Pittsburgh’s permitting process.

Ms. Kail-Smith introduced the bills ahead of her planned retirement at the end of this year. After several months of back-and-forth between city officials, the Pittsburgh Planning Commission on Tuesday voted against them.

No representatives from the councilwoman’s office attended the meeting, and Ms. Kail-Smith did not respond to a request for comment.

Advertise with us

City Council gets the final say on the proposal. A date for the vote has not been set.

Planning Commission member Rachel O'Neill said the bills “would likely have the opposite effect of [their] stated purpose, create some confusion, and ultimately extend timelines, if anything.”

The councilwoman’s legislation would have set universal deadlines for determining whether zoning applications are complete, and for approving or denying them.

Zoning applications in Pittsburgh must be approved before land is used or built on. They cover large and small developments, from townhomes to master plans that guide development in whole neighborhoods.

Several city agencies handle different types of zoning applications, and under current laws, they follow different timelines. The city’s zoning board, for instance, mostly considers requests for exceptions to zoning rules, and must issue decisions within 45 days of hearings. Other types of zoning applications are subject to a 90-day approval window.

Advertise with us

Ms. Kail-Smith’s bills called for setting universal deadlines by which all city agencies would notify applicants if their zoning proposals were incomplete, or approved after being deemed complete.

Under the proposal, if city agencies missed those deadlines, all zoning applications would be immediately approved — a cause of concern among some city officials.

The city’s chief zoning officer, Corey Layman, argued repeatedly that, if passed, the bill could lead to the approval of incomplete applications, or more applications denied. Applicants often take a long time to resubmit incomplete proposals, he said, particularly for complex developments. The councilwoman’s bills put forth a tight application approval window that left little room for that process, he argued.

A shorter review of zoning applications could also leave less time for developers to gather feedback from communities surrounding proposed projects, Planning Commission members added.

“Anything from a fence or shed to a large institutional master plan — this bill would put all of those things on the same timeline,” commission member Phillip Wu said. “I think that the whole one-size-fits-all approach does not work in a city of this size with development of this type of complexity.”

Advertise with us

Though the legislation did not win the commission’s support, it kicked off a conversation about speeding up development in Pittsburgh that city officials say they are eager to continue.

After a meeting in October, the Planning Commission first delayed a vote on the councilwoman’s bills and asked her office to work with the city’s Department of City Planning — which oversees land use — on the proposal. The two groups were asked to reappear together, but after one meeting and a scheduling conflict, Mr. Layman said the department never heard from the councilwoman’s office again.

Still, Mr. Layman acknowledged that there will be more attempts to “make doing business with the city as easy as possible” and said he is “entirely open” to working with City Council or others on future plans.

The Planning Commission’s vote comes after citywide development became a flashpoint in the mayoral election earlier this year. Allegheny County Controller and Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor campaigned against sitting Mayor Ed Gainey on a pro-growth platform, repeatedly calling for approving build-outs faster.