A set of bills proposed by Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith has kicked off debate within City Hall about how to speed up development across Pittsburgh — but left officials at odds over next steps.
The two bills, proposed in June, call for fast-tracking the city’s zoning application review and approval process. Both are part of a larger package of legislation introduced by the councilwoman this summer that could overhaul city agencies overseeing land use and alter zoning and permitting processes. Ms. Kail-Smith introduced the package ahead of her planned retirement at the end of this year.
But the legislation has pitted the councilwoman squarely against the Department of City Planning, which oversees land use in Pittsburgh and denounced the bills on Tuesday during a hearing before the Pittsburgh Planning Commission.
The commission must vote on the bills before City Council gets the final say, but on Tuesday delayed a decision, instead asking for city offices to do more work on finding common ground.
The bills would set universal deadlines for determining whether zoning applications are complete, and for approving or denying them. Developers submit zoning applications to use or develop property in Pittsburgh, from master plans for neighborhoods or school campuses to proposed apartment buildings.
Under current rules, certain agencies and types of zoning applications are subject to different deadlines. The city’s zoning board, for instance — which mostly considers requests for exceptions to certain zoning rules — must issue decisions within 45 days of hearings.
Read More
Other types of zoning applications must be approved or denied within 90 days. But there is no standard timeline that applies to all applications.
In an effort to speed up the approval process, one of Ms. Kail Smith’s bills would give the city 30 days after receiving zoning applications to notify applicants in writing if their bids are incomplete. Any applications not handled in that window would automatically advance in the review process.
The councilwoman’s second bill sets a deadline for issuing decisions on complete applications.
Perception vs. reality
Certain agencies, including the city’s zoning board and planning commission, hear different zoning applications. Once a bid is marked complete and the agency handling it holds their first regularly scheduled meeting, the bill calls for approval or denial within 90 days. If the city fails to act before that window closes, applications would be automatically approved.
“It's about speeding up some of the review process and giving some certainty to applicants that for these classes of approvals, this is your hard stop,” City Council legislative projects manager Shawn Carter said.
Ms. Kail-Smith introduced the legislation after the pace of development citywide became a flashpoint in the Democratic primary for mayor earlier this year.
Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, who won the Democratic nomination, campaigned against sitting Mayor Ed Gainey on a pro-growth platform and frequently called for speeding up city approval processes for build-outs.
“We need to show that when you go for a building permit, it doesn’t take you 18 months because you lose your overhead and then you don’t want to do business in Pittsburgh,” Mr. O’Connor said while speaking on a panel in June.
The city’s chief zoning officer, Corey Layman, said that the city has sped up zoning application reviews.
In 2016, amid a backlog of applications and long wait times for hearings, the city’s zoning board was set to hear nearly 400 cases. But city planners eliminated hearings for application-types that are almost always approved, shrinking the backlog and cutting the number of hearings to less than 150 per year as of 2025.
Without a hearing, zoning reviews move faster. Now, the average review time for all applications is 18 business days, while complex zoning applications, such as large developments, take longer, Mr. Layman said.
Despite the improvements, “there is a perception” that approvals take months, Mr. Layman said. What often slows down the process is revisions — applicants take an average of around 30 days to resubmit incomplete bids, he said.
Ms. Kail Smith’s legislation leaves little leeway for applicants submitting revisions, Mr. Layman said.
“We're going to have to deny applications to avoid having them deemed approved when they're not ready,” he said.
That’s one reason why the Department of City Planning opposes the proposals, he added, saying the bills could lead to the approval of incomplete applications — or more applications denied, Mr. Layman said.
‘Willing participants’
Additionally, complex zoning applications often require developers to gather feedback from communities in and around project sites. Scheduling meetings with different organizations can take time, Planning Commission members said.
Auto-approvals after missed deadlines could undermine that process, and lead to less community input, commission member Phillip Wu said.
Beyond that, the legislation would require the city to alter its “OneStopPGH” portal, an online platform for managing permit applications. Mr. Layman said the cost of making those changes “has not been studied.” From 2024 to 2025, the Department of City Planning’s budget decreased by more than 40%.
Still, Pittsburgh is a “restrictive development environment,” said Mr. Carter, the City Council legislative projects manager. The city’s topography can make building difficult, while construction and labor costs nationally are on the rise, making these changes necessary, he said.
“There are a number of different factors that lead to development being either stymied or in fact, stopped by things outside of our control,” he said. “We can't control any of these factors, at least not as a government.”
“The thing we can control is the process by which we review and approve applications.”
The city’s review process can be improved, Mr. Layman acknowledged — but that should not include auto-approving applications, he said.
“We are willing participants,” Mr. Layman said of the Department of City Planning. “Our only request is that we work together.”
Ultimately, the Planning Commission on Tuesday voted to require City Council and City Planning to discuss the zoning review process together. The two sides must appear before the commission again with a report on their progress by Dec. 2.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.