As a multimillion-dollar push to revamp Downtown continues, one of the corridor’s longest-standing buildings is at a crossroads.

Pittsburgh-based McKnight Realty, owner of the Heinz 57 Center, must pay off loans on the building totaling $64 million by this Saturday. As the deadline approaches, McKnight is at serious risk of defaulting, according to loan surveillance reports.

The real estate firm secured a two-part $75 million mortgage on the property in 2015 but has paid off just 15% of it as the Heinz 57 Center struggles to bring in revenue. The 13-story office and retail building, once fully occupied, has lost major tenants in the past few years, cutting sharply into its rental income.

“The borrower urgently needs either refinancing, extension, or faces potential default,” a recent loan surveillance report said. McKnight Realty officials did not respond to a request for comment.

Advertise with us

As companies continue to trade older offices for newer smaller ones, Heinz 57 Center is one of several Pittsburgh landmarks caught in the fray. Downtown’s K&L Gates Center and the Grant Building have both faced foreclosure actions in the past year after their owners defaulted on payments and tenants left the buildings.

Meanwhile, demand for the city’s older office space is falling, while the cost of converting such buildings to new uses or investing in upgrades is on the rise.

The question of what’s next for these struggling properties has vexed Pittsburgh’s real estate community — and looms over plans to revitalize Downtown.

The Heinz 57 Center has already weathered a major overhaul: Once the home of Gimbel’s department store, the building sat largely empty for years before McKnight purchased it in 1999 and poured money into transforming it into an office tower.

(CLICK HERE TO ENLARGE)

Once complete, the building housed The Kraft Heinz Company’s North American headquarters until the company scaled back its local operations and vacated that space over a decade ago.

Advertise with us

Still, McKnight found another major tenant in Burlington Coat Factory, which occupied nearly 20% of the building, until the company downsized and moved out in 2023, leaving several floors — including the first — vacant.

After Burlington’s departure, Midland Loan Services — which manages the loan on behalf of the lender — added the building to its watchlist, flagging the loss in rental income as a risk that could cause McKnight to default on loan payments.

The loss of other major tenants followed: UPMC, which occupies more than 40% of the building, said in March that it planned to let “several leases” expire. The University of Pittsburgh let its lease in the building expire in May, and the accounting firm BDO USA left its space for a newer building this summer.

That’s left the Heinz 57 Center under-leased, with McKnight struggling to fill vacancies.

Conversion to residential unlikely

The building is also costing the city and county.

Advertise with us

Property tax revenue — particularly from the Golden Triangle — has long propped up the city’s finances. But as high-profile buildings lose tenants, steep cuts to their assessed value is eroding Downtown’s tax base.

The taxing bodies — the city, county and school district — have lost nearly $740,000 in tax revenue from Heinz 57 Center alone due to assessment cuts since 2022. That’s enough to cover the cost of hiring multiple first responders or replacing street lights in Pittsburgh. And it’s just a fraction of the more than $11 million lost from all assessment rollbacks in the past few years.

Against that backdrop, the city in 2024 unveiled a sweeping plan to revitalize Downtown Pittsburgh, anchored by the conversion of several aging office towers into new residential buildings.

Buildings like the Gulf Tower, First and Market Building and others will all be converted under the plan. The Grant Building, put up for sale after McKnight defaulted on a loan payment, is also expected to sell before the end of the year to a buyer pursuing a conversion. Across Downtown, at least 15 conversions with more than 1,000 units are in the pipeline.

But that may not be an option for the Heinz 57 Center, said Jack Donahue, president of Pittsburgh-based Donahue Real Estate Advisors.

Advertise with us

The building’s floor plates are particularly large, Mr. Donahue said, meaning there’s more distance between its core and windows. That makes it difficult — and expensive — to ensure all apartment units inside have windows and natural light access, a requirement for most buildings under Pennsylvania law, he said.

“It wouldn’t pencil out,” Mr. Donahue said.

Other distressed office buildings in Pittsburgh have sold at steep discounts to owners now investing heavily in upgrades.

Rugby Realty purchased One Oxford Centre after its value dropped, and the developer is spending millions on renovations to help the building compete with newer, modern offices. Since the building’s sale, five tenants have renewed their space inside, while prospective tenants have expressed interest.

Downtown’s Liberty Center could also follow that path. The building was recently purchased by a property owner that’s currently investing in an under-leased Philadelphia office tower.

Advertise with us

Challenges are ‘not uncommon’

Heinz 57 Center has “good bricks and sticks,” said David Koch, executive managing director of Newmark Realty’s Pittsburgh office. Upgrades could be possible. But the building’s layout, again, could be a major drawback.

“What types of tenants would be willing to move into a building with floors of that size?” said Mr. Donahue, adding that most companies today are downsizing and seeking offices that use space efficiently. Tenants are renewing just 60% to 70% of the space they once occupied in new leases across Pittsburgh, according to data from the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership.

Despite McKnight’s renovations, “Heinz 57 Center wasn’t designed as an office building,” Mr. Donahue said. “It was designed as a giant department store.”

While conversions and upgrades have emerged as paths forward for aging buildings, the cost of completing such projects is now elevated, real estate sources said.

In a high-cost environment, “the benefit [to Heinz 57 Center] might be that the space is already built out,” Mr. Donahue said, adding that he’s directed some tenants to consider older, “second-generation” office space to save money.

Advertise with us

“The space might be dated, but tenants could move in without making that many modifications,” he said.

Per the latest office market reports, Downtown’s office market is showing signs of recovery after a long, uphill climb the past few years: Leasing activity is finally on the rise. But it's concentrated in the city’s newest, modern buildings, leaving buildings like Heinz 57 Center behind.

From 2023 to mid-2025, nearly half of all new leases signed in Pittsburgh were building upgrades, while just 7% were downgrades, according to the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm.

The city’s remaining high-quality space has to be filled before tenants will “start considering the outliers, like Heinz 57 or others,” Mr. Koch said.

As it nears a critical juncture, the building is emblematic of the largest question facing Downtown Pittsburgh: What’s next for the corridor's stock of aging office towers?

“The challenge you’re seeing here is not uncommon right now,” said Mr. Koch.