The Hill District’s most expensive townhomes have yet to find a buyer five months after they went up for sale and despite recent price cuts.

The six modern townhomes on a quiet stretch of Rose Street were built by developer Steffan Johnson — who saw them as a personal response to the difficulty he experienced while shopping for urban housing desirable to upwardly mobile Black professionals when he and his family moved here in 2009 from Minneapolis.

“I wanted to show what’s possible for this side of the city by bringing modern architecture and high-end finishes — almost custom homes — to a part of the Hill that is long overdue,” he said.

But five months after listing the homes — for $480,000 — Mr. Johnson has yet to find a single buyer.

Advertise with us

In May, he slashed the price to $449,900. When that didn’t move the needle, he offered four of the townhomes as an investor package deal for $1,799,600, cutting hundreds of thousands off what he had hoped to make.

Still, no bites.

Mr. Johnson’s dilemma puts on full display the risk and complexity of venturing into new housing projects these days — even as housing shortages become severe in more parts of the country, and as the median cost of a home steadily climbs year after year. Add to the equation construction delays, pandemic price spikes and the inevitable surprises developers run into during processes such as land excavation — and Mr. Johnson’s costs have risen from $300,000 per unit to more than $400,000.

Mr. Johnson said he went into the project with the goal to change the narrative for people like him. Instead, he faced opposition to the project from community groups who said the Hill did not need such housing options, and a project that for every day it sits empty, just bleeds more money on carrying costs.

Steffan Johnson sits inside one of the townhomes in the Hill District he built. Four months after listing the homes — for $480,000 — Mr. Johnson has yet to find a single buyer. (Justin Guido / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“I saw Shadyside and said, ‘Why can’t Centre Avenue have the things that Walnut Street has in terms of housing accessibility and opportunities?’ ” Mr. Johnson, 50, said. “That was the idea.

Advertise with us

“But I was met with skepticism around building new-construction housing in the Hill District. We haven’t seen that kind of stuff before.”

Sending a different message

The three-bedroom, three-bathroom townhouses sit on a scenic hill that overlooks Oakland.

Mr. Johnson said he built them to appeal to professionals with families who want to be close to the universities, the hospitals and Downtown.

While real estate data says the townhomes are priced fairly due to the high cost of new construction, the market is sending a different message.

According to Redfin, an online real estate company and data source for the industry, the median home price in the Hill District hovers around $227,000 — less than half of the initial asking price of the new townhomes.

Advertise with us

Their proximity to Downtown may be a strong selling point, but some buyers — perhaps unaware of the Hill’s storied history — still associate the neighborhood with crime and blight.

The Hill District — once one of the most vibrant Black neighborhoods in the United States, and which pulsed with the brilliance of playwright August Wilson, jazz icon George Benson and screen legend Lena Horne — was cut off from Downtown when the city built the Civic Arena in the late 1950s, displacing residents and isolating the neighborhood. Despite efforts by the city after it demolished the arena, built PPG Paints Arena and worked with community groups to redevelop the area and reconnect the neighborhood, the area is now mostly a draw for developers building for low-income renters, not market-rate buyers.

Carol Hardeman, executive director of the Hill District Consensus Group, says simply: The townhouses are not a good fit.

“First of all, they are very pricey,” she said. “I do know that people who live in our community can’t afford them.”

‘Construction costs are so expensive’

Mr. Johnson’s townhouse project is not the only one offering new housing in the Hill District. Just a few blocks away, on Ledlie Street, another new-build project has encountered similar difficulties finding buyers.

Advertise with us

Amani Christian Community Development Corp. partnered with the Urban Redevelopment Authority of Pittsburgh to list two newly constructed three-bedroom, two-bath townhouses in late 2024 at $165,000 — priced far lower than Mr. Johnson’s.

Still, the homes have languished on the market. Only recently did one go under contract. The other remains unsold.

For his part, Mr. Johnson has tried to remove as many barriers as possible for prospective buyers. Through a partnership with First National Bank, he secured 100% financing and up to $5,000 in closing-cost assistance for first-time homebuyers.

Still — nothing.

The master bedroom in a townhouse that Steffan Johnson, owner of R Kyndall Development, built in the Hill District, on Wednesday, June 25, 2025. (Justin Guido / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

It’s reached a point where Mr. Johnson is seriously considering Plan B — offering the townhomes as high-end rentals, to stem the financial hemorrhage. It’s the last resort for an ambitious project that he hoped would spark homeownership — not a rental.

Advertise with us

“I look at this project as an opportunity to build generational wealth,” he said, referencing the growth in residential and commercial development occurring in the Hill District.

“It’s a strong opportunity to be part of an upward trend in a neighborhood that has had so much promise for so long,” he said. “This is an opportunity.”

‘Costs are so expensive’

While Mr. Johnson navigates the uncertain path of for-sale housing in the Hill, developer William Gatti has found a different formula for success — rental housing, backed by public investment and deep subsidies.

Mr. Gatti is president and CEO of Trek Development Group, a firm that has completed several residential projects in the Hill District, all focused on low-income and mixed-income rentals. He is currently leading one of the largest efforts yet: a partnership with the URA to build 99 affordable rental units as part of the Bedford Dwellings redevelopment.

The project is backed by $50 million in federal HUD funding and $7 million from the URA, along with tax credits. Even with that support, Mr. Gatti said the math is still tight.

Advertise with us

“Interest rates are higher and construction costs are so expensive,” Mr. Gatti said. “To build a home for sale, you’re talking at least $400,000 just to construct that unit.”

He’s quick to point out that his model — building to rent, not to sell — is as fundamentally different as comparing apples to oranges.

“We don’t have any special magic,” he said. “It’s just that we’re positioned differently.”

Although his focus is on rentals, Mr. Gatti acknowledges that no neighborhood can thrive on rental housing alone. He respects developers like Mr. Johnson and Amani Christian Development for taking on the risk of bringing for-sale housing to transitional neighborhoods such as the Hill District.

“I applaud their efforts,” he said. “The city needs more of that. They are pioneers. Hopefully they don’t regret their decision.”

Advertise with us

The Rose Street townhouses were designed by architect Justin Cipriani, of Cipriani Studios in Mt. Lebanon. He is known for his contemporary designs throughout the city — and is starting to make a mark in the Hill District.

His modernist style also is seen in the lower Hill District on Cliff Street. Mr. Cipriani designed high a six-figure luxury custom home for attorney Jacques Moye, and another luxury modern townhouse for a builder and his family.

“Cliff Street is where a lot of the money is going,” Mr. Cipriani said. “There’s new clients buying lots who have reached out to me. That seems to be a real fertile area.”

Steffan Johnson stands outside one of the townhomes he built — and is trying to sell — in the Hill District. (Justin Guido / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

He said most of the recent high-end investment in the Hill District has focused on the lower Hill, the area closest to Downtown and the Civic Arena site. He said new construction in the lower Hill falls in the luxury category of $1 million or more. But pushing that momentum deeper into the middle Hill — where Rose Street sits — may take more time.

“If you go down Centre Avenue, you’ll notice those big commercial buildings are all being renovated and reinvested in,” he said. “We’re kind of piggybacking on that investment effort.”

Advertise with us

‘They understood the riskiness’

To understand why Mr. Johnson risked so much on a hillside in the middle Hill, he says, you have to go back to 2009.

That’s when he and his wife, Cherie, now 49, moved their family of four from Minneapolis to Pittsburgh for work. She worked for what is now known as Kraft Heinz; Mr. Johnson worked for Highmark. Both were rising professionals eager to plant roots in a community among other Black professionals with newer housing located near Downtown.

But what they envisioned didn’t exist, they recalled.

The Crawford Square development in the Hill District was sold out. Their best chance for finding newer housing was limited to suburbs north, such as Cranberry, their Realtor said. They eventually settled in Gibsonia.

Through his work, Mr. Johnson participated in Leadership Pittsburgh, a program for emerging community leaders. The group studied city neighborhoods poised for revitalization — focusing on Lawrenceville. But he also researched the Hill District, on his own time.

Advertise with us

“I made it my own personal mission to learn about the history of the Hill District and what it had been undergoing, where it’s come from and where it was trying to go,” Mr. Johnson said.

He began his real estate development career in 2015, starting with four parcels in Upper Lawrenceville. But during the pandemic, when the URA offered five parcels for sale on Rose Street, Mr. Johnson said he saw his opportunity.

The initial plan was to spend about $300,000 each to build six townhouses. But materials and labor costs surged during the pandemic.

To make matters worse, the land excavation unearthed old basements and plumbing buried beneath the surface, adding unforeseen costs and delays.

“It is extremely cost prohibitive to build new construction in the city,” he said, “because the topography is very challenging, and the cost to get that topography stable enough to construct on is very costly.”

Advertise with us

Despite each unit eventually costing over $400,000 to build, he said his private investors have, so far, remained patient, even as the units sit unsold.

“They understood the riskiness of this project as we were putting it together,” Mr. Johnson said.

If given the chance, Mr. Johnson said he would do it all over again — but with a different approach.

He would scale the project down, he said. Instead of six units, he would do four, with a smaller footprint. One or two bedrooms instead of three.

And the units would be transitional housing aimed at recent college graduates or young professionals, rather than full-scale family homes.

Advertise with us

Yet, even as he wrestles with whether to hold the line or pivot to rentals, Mr. Johnson stands by his decision to take the leap in the first place.

“We saw an area that had old jazz clubs, restaurants and a corridor of Centre Avenue that had so much promise for walkability for African Americans,” he said. “I would still engage in the project."

Correction: This story was updated at 9:20 a.m. on July 21 to correct the spelling of Jacques Moye’s name.