Come January, a new mayor will take office and inherit a decades-old puzzle with far-reaching implications for the future of a city on the brink of financial crisis.

Pittsburgh’s sprawling networks of hospitals and universities — institutions that redefined the region and rescued it from the economic collapse of heavy industry years ago — have amassed enormous real estate holdings with some of the most valuable properties in the city.

But because of their nonprofit status, the organizations pay little to no property taxes, putting tens of millions of dollars in badly needed revenue out of the city's reach, potentially taking millions of dollars in revenue off the table, according to a Post-Gazette analysis of data provided in response to a public records request.

Those properties are supposed to be re-evaluated regularly to make sure they’re being used for charitable purposes — the main qualification for tax-exempt status — but the tiny county office that conducts those reviews faces a staffing shortage that has made it all but impossible to keep up with the workload.

Advertise with us

In Pittsburgh, one in four tax-exempt properties haven't been reviewed in over a decade, despite a law requiring they be re-evaluated every three years, an analysis by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette has found.

That backlog could be costing the city at a pivotal moment. Pittsburgh recently embarked on historic plans to spend millions revamping Downtown — but is strapped for cash and barreling toward a fiscal cliff, officials have said.

At the heart of the issue are what’s known as the Big Five nonprofits — Highmark Health, the University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon University, Duquesne University and UPMC, the state’s largest employer. Together, they own tax-exempt property worth about $4.5 billion in Pittsburgh alone — a potential stream of revenue that generations of mayors have tried to access.

If that property was taxed, the city would collect $35 million a year, enough to give a 10% tax cut to every other property owner within its borders.

“The city’s not going in the right direction,” said state Sen. Wayne Fontana, D-Brookline. “That’s just one of the main reasons why — because there seems to be a roadblock in trying to get to a resolution with the five nonprofits.”

Advertise with us

A ‘promising yet elusive’ money source

For nonprofits, owning a property isn’t enough to take it off the tax rolls. The buildings have to be used for charitable purposes or they’re subject to the same taxes as any other.

The law requires the county to review all tax-exempt properties periodically to make sure they still qualify.

While the county has reviewed some properties over the past decade, it did not launch another full, countywide audit until 2024 — 11 years after the last one, the Post-Gazette found.

That means just a third of the properties owned by the city’s biggest nonprofits have been reviewed in recent years.

Most of these properties are university buildings, hospitals and health clinics unlikely to ever join the city’s tax rolls. But the Big Five also own parking garages, office and apartment buildings, vacant lots and even homes — all with tax exemptions that deprive the city, county and school district of vital funds.

Advertise with us

Property use often changes over time. A nonprofit might rent out space to a for-profit business. Coffee shops, food vendors and bookstores can pop up within university and hospital campuses, explained Michael Suley, former head of the county office that reviews exempt properties. Mr. Suley currently chairs the county’s Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Reviews, which hears challenges to taxable status.

Allegheny General Hospital’s 10-acre campus on the North Side, for instance, is worth over $167 million and includes Beanthru, a chain coffee drive-through with locations across Pittsburgh.

“I would argue that [retail] use is not a charitable use, despite the fact that the revenue may go toward the school,” said Ira Weiss, the Weiss Burkhardt Kramer attorney who represents Pittsburgh Public Schools. “That property should be taxable.”

Warehouse space on the North Side and a 20,000 square foot vacant plot near a hospital are just a few properties that have had their tax-exempt status revoked upon closer inspection over the last few years.

“What I’m saying is: if you go out and you look and see what’s going on, maybe — just maybe — there’s money there,” Mr. Suley said.

Advertise with us

Consider: UPMC and Highmark pay no taxes on half a dozen parking lots and garages they own across Pittsburgh. If those properties were taxed, the city would collect an additional $300,000 a year.

Carnegie Mellon University owns more than a dozen homes near its campus, including a multimillion-dollar estate that once belonged to the Hillman family. Altogether, the homes are assessed at $7.5 million — but just $1.2 million is taxable, records show. Without the tax breaks, CMU would owe more than $50,000 annually.

That could help a city battling a looming budget crisis and shortchanged essential services. In Pittsburgh, $350,000 could cover the cost of repaving a few blocks, hiring new first responders or replacing street lights.

“If I was the new mayor going in, that would be at the top of my list: trying to take loose debt — those dollars — and come to some understanding,” Mr. Fontana said. “That will be a big base, as you go forward, for a new budget.”

‘Missing the boat’ on some properties

The key to reviewing properties is visiting in-person to assess their use, Mr. Suley said. But right now, just 14 assessors are tasked with reviewing more than 2,400 tax-exempt properties across the county — among several other duties, the county said in response to questions from the PG.

Advertise with us

“Limited staff and COVID forced [the Office of Property Assessments] to shift resources to immediate needs, including reviewing active building permits to ensure new construction, demolitions and other major work was being captured,” the county said.

Taken together, it’s an enormous workload for such a small staff, said County Councilwoman Suzanne Filiaggi.

“With very few people reviewing this stuff... they’re drinking out of a fire hose,” she said.

The county has attacked the problem in the past. Officials last initiated a countywide review around 2013. Letters were sent to all owners of tax-exempt land, requesting proof that their properties should remain untaxed, said former county executive Rich Fitzgerald, who was in office at the time.

Back then, about 35 assessors worked in the county’s Office of Property Assessments, according to Mr. Suley, who led the office until 2012. That’s more than double the agency’s staff today.

Advertise with us

Still, the effort led to few changes, Mr. Fitzgerald said. Jack Owen, a lawyer at Sherrard, German and Kelly who represents nonprofits, said that some of his clients received updates about their taxable status after they responded to the county.

But for most, it was radio silence.

“It went into [a] file somewhere, I guess,” Mr. Owen said. “They never heard anything again.”

Many of those properties — such as urgent care centers at UPMC Shadyside — serve clear, charitable purposes, according to Mr. Owen. Reviews are not likely to put them on the tax rolls.

“The county, the city is probably missing the boat on some of those properties,” Mr. Owen said. “But frankly, I think most of it is low hanging fruit — you're not going to balance the budget of the city on the back of nonprofits.”

Advertise with us

Yet multiple large, tax-exempt organizations are currently in the midst of expansions. UPMC is building in Oakland, Duquesne University is growing in the Bluff and Point Park University plans to branch out Downtown. New properties should be reviewed, Mr. Suley said.

“UPMC keeps adding buildings,” Mr. Suley said. “I’ve seen evidence of this — they buy the single-family home and either they tear it down, or it becomes an extension of the hospital with facilities.

“What’s very important is the ‘look and see’ — what are they doing inside these buildings?”

Nonprofits ‘need to be part of that solution’

The lapse in scrutiny comes at a critical crossroads for the city. Since the pandemic, companies shifting to remote work have emptied their office space Downtown, causing the value of high-profile buildings in the Golden Triangle to nosedive.

Downtown has long been Pittsburgh’s biggest money-maker, generating roughly a quarter of the city’s real estate revenue, which funds the basics: public safety, road paving and other crucial services.

Advertise with us

But now, cash is dwindling. The property and deed transfer taxes together took in nearly $20 million less than budgeted for last year. At the same time, federal COVID aid is expiring — leaving some city services badly underfunded, according to the most recent annual financial report from City Controller Rachael Heisler.

Pittsburgh’s public safety fleet — its fire and emergency services vehicles — is in “dire” condition and needs $20 million more a year, officials have said.

In all, the city brought in $10.6 million less revenue than expected in 2024, largely because of hits to the city’s property tax base, according to the controller’s report.

“Tax-exempt properties, particularly those owned by our large regional nonprofit partners, remains a promising yet elusive source of ‘lost’ revenue that could solve the city’s current fiscal imbalance,” the recent report said.

While Pittsburgh’s property tax base has plunged in value, some of the Big Five have expanded their footprints.

Advertise with us

If all those buildings and lots were fully taxed, the city would raise enough money to cover its entire annual emergency medical services budget, which was $27.7 million in 2025, the Post-Gazette found. 

As Pittsburgh scrambles to replace lost funds, large nonprofits “need to be a part of that solution,” Mr. Fontana said.

For years, city officials have deadlocked in talks with the Big Five. Mayor Ed Gainey in 2021 campaigned for office on promises to force UPMC’s hand and make the health care giant “pay their fair share.”

Over the last two years, the mayor’s administration has challenged the tax-exempt status of at least 130 properties, mostly owned by the Big Five, though lawsuits have so far led to few changes.

Decades of talks

In 2004, as Pittsburgh faced a budget crisis that sent it into state receivership, more than 100 tax-exempt organizations together committed to give the city $13.5 million annually.

Advertise with us

But payments were sporadic and the city was “left unsure” when they would come in, according to a joint city-county report. By the time the agreement expired in 2013, it had brought in just $18.2 million – about 15% of what was pledged, the report revealed. That same year, the city filed a lawsuit challenging UPMC’s tax-exempt status.

After taking office in 2014, former Mayor Bill Peduto dropped that suit and instead founded OnePGH — an independent nonprofit and middleman between the city and its largest tax-exempt groups, meant to channel payments from organizations into city projects. Hospitals and universities pledged $115 million over five years, earmarked for affordable housing, greenspace and more. UPMC alone committed $40 million, the largest contribution, according to spokesman Paul Wood.

But with a new mayor came another new strategy.

Mr. Gainey in 2022 cut ties with OnePGH, citing transparency concerns. Private nonprofits are not subject to the same financial oversight as public agencies. Only already-funded OnePGH projects were completed.

In a new bid to extract payments from the Big Five, the Gainey administration in 2023 directed city lawyers to examine all tax-exempt properties and contest the status of any they believed should be taxed, kicking off a wave of challenges that have, over two years, yielded small returns.

Advertise with us

In 2024, the mayor’s office challenged 104 properties. Just 17 were returned to the tax rolls, generating about $92,800 in revenue, the Post-Gazette previously reported. Challenged sites included parts of UPMC Children’s Hospital, Magee-Womens research offices and parking garages, and Pitt athletic facilities — all of which stayed exempt.

Typically, up to four lawyers represent the city in proceedings, while up to five represent hospitals and universities, according to Mr. Suley. While the city has primarily used its in-house attorneys to challenge tax-exempt properties, it has also spent $247,436 on outside counsel since 2023 — enough to cover the base salaries of five early-career police officers in Pittsburgh, as of 2024 salary figures.

“This is a David [and] Goliath kind of battle. The government is very much the David in the situation.” said Mr. Owen. “They're going against behemoths like CMU and Highmark, which have teams of lawyers that spend all their time making sure they comply with [the law].”

‘It was the right time to make a deal’

Still, the county has revoked the tax exemptions for eight Big Five properties over the past two years, including at least six challenged by the Gainey administration. Properties returned to the tax rolls include a $1.1 million Highmark-owned building being used for daycare.

The mayor has also attempted to lock down a deal with UPMC over three years of talks that stalled in late 2024 and never restarted. Earlier this year, Mr. Gainey suggested that a deal under which UPMC would pay the city $12.5 million each year for a decade was on the table, but the health care giant denies that agreement ever existed.

Advertise with us

Mr. Wood, the UPMC spokesman, said the mayor’s office canceled a meeting planned for last December and hasn’t tried to reschedule. The Gainey administration, however, maintains that UPMC backed out and has refused to meet this year.

“The City of Pittsburgh and Mayor Gainey, with whom we have met several times, have long known UPMC will fully participate in programs that are fair and equitable and include the region’s other major nonprofits,” Mr. Wood said.

In January, the mayor called on four of the Big Five — he excluded Duquesne — to meet with him before the end of the month and negotiate a deal to support city services. There has not been any announcement of a deal since.

Highmark spokesman Bill Toland said the organization is ready to commit once the other large nonprofits do and highlighted the “hundreds of millions” Highmark pays in taxes each year.

Mr. Toland also emphasized the health care provider’s community investments — including free health screenings it provides and sizable donations to pandemic response efforts. The University of Pittsburgh and UPMC similarly stressed their community engagement.

Advertise with us

Like four years ago, the Big Five became a sticking point in this year’s Democratic primary for mayor. But the landscape has shifted: The city is now staring down a budget crisis, and some nonprofits are contending with funding cuts and falling income.

UPMC and the University of Pittsburgh both reported losses at the end of 2023, the most recent year with available tax filings. Carnegie Mellon’s income plunged 58% in two years, and Highmark’s is down nearly half. Only Duquesne University saw its income rise in 2023.

That’s a stark contrast from when the organizations committed millions of dollars to OnePGH in 2021. At the time, all five were in the black. UPMC alone had posted more than $1 billion in net income.

“All engines were humming at that point,” a source involved in the formation of OnePGH said. “It was the right time to make a deal.”

‘A big, big problem’

Just two hours from Pittsburgh, Erie struck a lasting deal with UPMC, Highmark and other nonprofits years ago to recoup some revenue lost to tax-exempt properties. Subsidiaries of both health care providers pay the city, county and school district half of what they would owe in property taxes there — an arrangement that brought in over $2 million in 2020, according to a report from the city of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

The approach is known as a payment-in-lieu-of-taxes program, or PILOT. Pittsburgh has 23 active PILOTs, initiated between 1976 and 2017. Over the past five years, these agreements have collected nearly $2.7 million — but never included the Big Five.

Such a PILOT between Pittsburgh and the Big Five would yield about $18 million — twice the annual budget of the parks department. Half of that would come from UPMC alone. Yet as the city’s budget crisis deepens, the likelihood of striking a deal could be shrinking, Mr. Fontana said.

“I don’t know that these five trust that the money won’t be wasted,” the senator said. “I think that’s a big, big problem.”

Retired police officer and Republican nominee for mayor Tony Moreno has not taken a public stance on the Big Five, the Post-Gazette previously reported. But Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, who beat Mr. Gainey in this year’s Democratic primary, has pushed for targeted investments that align with nonprofits’ mission statements.

On the campaign trail, Mr. O’Connor suggested, for instance, asking health care providers to fund ambulances to upgrade the city’s aging fleet.

“This administration has had over three years to reach an agreement with our nonprofits,” Mr. O’Connor said in January. “Funds are needed to provide basic city services, like keeping our streets safe and plowed, building affordable housing, and investing in our neighborhoods. We deserve better leadership."

Mr. O’Connor has not ruled out PILOTs, but he is not the first to advocate for alternatives. Mr. Fontana in 2008 proposed legislation that would allow cities to enact an essential service fee of up to $100 per 1,000 square feet of tax-exempt property, with some exceptions. Others have suggested that the Big Five invest in neighborhoods where they own the most exempt property.

The next mayor will be the latest in a long line of officials to wrestle with the city’s tax-exempt property. But this year, more could be on the line.

The city’s budget is nearing collapse, some nonprofits are acquiring more real estate — and the office reviewing all exempt properties is still short-staffed and years behind.

Meanwhile, a countdown clock is planted on the North Shore, ticking down the days until Pittsburgh hosts next year’s NFL Draft. Construction is underway in Market Square, Point State Park, the Cultural District and more — all spaces that will require preservation for years to come.

“You make a deal today,” Mr. Fontana said. “But it should be a deal that pertains to the future.”

Correction: A previous version of this article misstated the scope of a 10-acre property located at 314-322 E North Ave. The property includes Allegheny General Hospital in its entirety, not just a complex within the AHN Cancer Institute.