Striking a deal with Pittsburgh’s major nonprofits to support city initiatives shouldn’t have been impossible. It would have required everyone swallowing some pride and dialing back expectations, and then creatively aligning their interests.

Specifically, the two sides could have agreed to investments in for-sale affordable housing, which would have helped workers for these institutions find places to live, while revitalizing a Pittsburgh neighborhood and building generational wealth.

Former Mayor Bill Peduto’s dreams for OnePGH, a massive urban wealth fund, never fully came into bloom, and his successor uprooted the seedling. Mayor Ed Gainey has been more interested in prosecuting SEIU Healthcare’s war against UPMC than achieving realistic solutions.

But there’s still time — though likely not before the May 20 primary, which Mr. Gainey will enter empty-handed — to change course, or for a new mayor to chart a new course.

Advertise with us

The moment has passed

The most advantageous moment for squeezing big financial contributions from Pittsburgh’s five major nonprofits has likely passed.

UPMC and Highmark have seen their cash flows reverse as the economics of health care once again shift against major firms. Pitt, Carnegie Mellon and Duquesne are facing the loss of federal money, with hundreds of millions of dollars per year for research and administration under threat.

For the past few years eds and meds were still flying high, but Mr. Gainey’s approach to them was never going to succeed. If there’s one thing the Big Five all agree on, it’s that either all of them will be in, or none of them will be. The mayor has focused his ire entirely on SEIU Healthcare’s white whale, UPMC, dooming the effort from the start.

A so-called “commitment” from Highmark, announced by the administration last month, only reiterated the company’s longstanding position that it would give if everyone else gave. Mr. Gainey’s new claims, just this week, to have had a $125 million deal with UPMC only to be double-crossed are balderdash, according to several people who would have known if such a deal were actually on the table.

And so here we are, back where we started over a decade ago: with many of the region’s biggest employers and land owners not meaningfully contributing to city government.

Advertise with us

Achieving a solution depends on facing reality head-on. The nonprofits will never concede they owe anything to the city beyond the services they already render. The only way to force them to ante up is through changes to state or federal nonprofit law that are extremely unlikely to succeed, at least on any reasonable time frame.

Holding out for unrestricted contributions to the city’s general fund will ensure a perpetual stalemate, which works just fine for the Big Five.

Shared and beneficial

So, what’s a shared initiative that fulfills a city priority while also benefitting the nonprofits? Building an affordable neighborhood of for-sale homes right in their backyard.

There are multiple models for this kind of project, but for illustration purposes I’ll use LEVEL, a Pittsburgh-based nonprofit that’s building affordable for-sale homes in McKees Rocks.

The back-of-the-envelope math goes like this: It takes about $400,000 to build a decent home today, which places the sale price for new construction beyond the reach of most people. But if you can stack subsidies and grants to the tune of, say, $250,000 per home, you can breakeven by selling to a low-income family for $150,000.

Advertise with us

Even better, with some creative financing and further subsidies and grants, you can forgive that mortgage after 10 or 15 years, leaving a low-income family with experience managing a mortgage and a free-and-clear asset worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Affordable rentals, the Gainey administration’s only model, can quickly become traps. For instance, tenants in Pittsburgh’s “inclusionary zoning” units are kicked out of their homes once their incomes reach 80% of the area median income, harshly punishing success.

Affordable for-sale homes enhance neighborhood stability and create generational wealth. This is the model that was proposed for 100 affordable homes in Larimer as part of the expansion of Bakery Square, until the Gainey administration scrapped it.

Consider this: a $10 million annual commitment split among the Big Five, which would fund (at $250,000 in subsidies each) 40 for-sale affordable homes available to their employees. After a decade, that’s 400 homes. Now imagine supplementing with foundation or corporate grants, and you’re getting close to an entire neighborhood’s worth of new or radically renovated homes — a model community for the 21st century.

And what’s a neighborhood with space to build (and existing homes to spruce up), not far from the major nonprofits, which is under threat of gentrification? Hazelwood.

Advertise with us

A transformational offer

Of course there are complications. The Land Bank and the URA would have to be engaged to help with land acquisition. Permitting would have to be expedited. The community itself would have to be on board. Inflation and other economic changes could make the concept more expensive, decreasing the overall output of housing.

But for too long, Pittsburgh’s leaders have failed to achieve anything grand, transformational or even just interesting due to the paralysis of complications. This is an offer of collaboration the nonprofits would struggle to reject, which would further shared goals and transform a community.

If this is too hard even to attempt, what can this city ever hope to achieve?

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Chairman Trump’s great leap forward.”