One of Downtown’s largest historic office towers is officially on the market, reflecting shifting dynamics in the city’s office market since the pandemic — and the uncertain futures of its oldest buildings.

The Grant Building, constructed in 1928, is one of several Downtown properties to lose major tenants as companies continue the post-pandemic trend of downsizing office space.

As the building hits the market without a list price, its future use — office or residential — is up in the air.

“We’ve had an interest from both sides,” said Kyle Prawzdik, senior vice president of real estate firm CBRE’s Pittsburgh office, which last week listed the Grant Building for sale after taking control of the property in March 2024 during an ongoing foreclosure action.

Advertise with us

“We’re going to let the market determine what the building will be in the future.”

The move to foreclose started last year, when a lender claimed McKnight Realty Partners, owner of the iconic building, defaulted on a $38 million loan.

McKnight is set to vacate more than 10,000 square feet of space in the building before the end of the month — one of multiple tenants to leave since the foreclosure action, according to the most recent receiver’s report. The firm, also facing a foreclosure action on a separate property, owes over half a million dollars in late rent payments, the report shows.

McKnight officials did not respond to a request for comment.

When the foreclosure action was filed last year, the Grant Building was 88% occupied. Now, just over 52% of the 37-story office tower is leased, according to CBRE.

Advertise with us

In addition to Huntington Bank, tenants such as PayCom, FTI Consulting and the vacuum manufacturing company Hoover have all moved out since foreclosure proceedings began. That leaves the building about 25% less leased than the average Class B — or second-tier — office property in Pittsburgh’s central business district, CBRE said.

But the building is within the upper class of Downtown’s older office buildings, with several amenities and a prime location that has attracted past tenants, real estate sources said.

It’s also well-suited for conversion to residential use, a trend gaining steam nationwide — the number of apartments set to be created from office conversions jumped over 200% between 2022 and 2025 in the U.S., according to a recent analysis of commercial real estate data from the apartment search site RentCafe.

‘Tenants are gravitating toward newer buildings’

CBRE is pitching the building as a contender for conversion or continued office use.

But attracting office tenants in today’s market could be a challenge as a “flight to quality” continues Downtown, said Dan Adamski, executive managing director of the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm in Pittsburgh. Flight to quality is the trend of tenants downsizing in favor of modern, upgraded office space.

Advertise with us

In marketing materials, CBRE suggests a buyer could boost the Grant Building’s revenue by leasing vacant space at competitive market rental rates. But average rents in the building trail average office rents citywide by about 25%, according to the first 2025 office market reports.

“Achieving market rates in the near term could be challenging without a clear value proposition that sets the building apart from Class A properties that boast great amenities and fit what today’s organizations are seeking,” Mr. Adamski said. “Across Pittsburgh, we’re seeing continued flight-to-quality, where tenants are gravitating toward newer buildings with more amenities — even if it means paying a premium.”

Still, tenants looking for cost-effective space do express interest in Class B buildings. With covered parking, a fitness and conference center, proximity to government buildings and a well-designed floor plan, the Grant Building has more to offer than most, said Gerard McLaughlin, executive managing director of Newmark real estate firm.

The building is also earning twice as much income as expected so far this year, according to the most recent receiver’s report, suggesting stability as it hits the market in the midst of foreclosure proceedings.

However, at least 10 tenants are behind on rent payments — some by multiple months, according to the receiver’s reports.

Advertise with us

Tenants who have failed to make rent payments on time now occupy at least 8% of the building, according to the receiver’s report. The law firm Rothman Gordon, which occupies over 20,000 square feet in the building, owes more than $1 million, with legal action pending. That means at least some of the building’s income could be fragile.

‘Part of the city’s architectural identity’

While Aligned Partners Trust Company recently renewed its space in the building and another tenant is in talks to follow suit, McKnight will vacate this month, and two leases covering more than 45,000 square feet in the building will expire in the next three years, according to the receiver’s report.

That could impact the building’s occupancy, another potential consideration for investors.

“It is likely the Grant Building and its sister Class B buildings will continue to face higher vacancies due to broader market trends” Mr. Adamski said.

The other option for the building — conversion to a residential building — lines up with recent activity Downtown. Of the seven residential projects included in Gov. Josh Shapiro’s $600 million plan to revitalize the Golden Triangle, the majority are conversion projects.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh is among the top 20 U.S. cities with the most office-to-apartment conversions in the works, the RentCafe analysis found.

The shape of the building’s floor plate, its large windows and rooftop deck access all make it suitable for conversion to a hotel or apartment units, Mr. Prawzdik at CBRE said.

But it would be a large undertaking: the Grant Building covers nearly 460,000 square feet.

“Developers may find the sheer scale of the building a hurdle, primarily due to escalating construction costs,” Mr. McLaughlin said.

The Grant Building is one of several Downtown to face a recent ownership change because of issues related to a mortgage.

Advertise with us

The K&L Gates Center entered into foreclosure last year after a lender claimed its owner defaulted on a major loan.

And on Grant Street, One Oxford Centre changed hands in March after a local group led by Rugby Realty president Aaron Stauber won a bid for an outstanding loan. That 45-story office tower, built during the city’s second renaissance, is getting a significant facelift in a bid by the new owners to help the building compete with modern, Class A offices for new tenants.

As the Grant Building heads toward a sale, the choice between that kind of reinvestment or conversion could help define what Downtown looks like in the years to come.

“Pittsburgh’s stock of historic Class B buildings is a defining part of the city’s architectural identity — and with the right vision, they can become anchors of Downtown’s future,” Mr. Adamski said. “But to remain relevant, these assets need thoughtful repositioning.

“It’s not about preserving simply for nostalgia’s sake — it’s about reimagining these buildings to support a more dynamic, mixed-use urban core.”