A lender is seeking to foreclose against the owner of the historic Grant Building in Downtown and sell the property after a series of defaults, including the failure of a key tenant to renew or extend its lease in accordance with loan terms.
Delaware-based Wilmington Trust filed the complaint in mortgage foreclosure against McKnight Grant Building Associates L.P., an affiliate of McKnight Realty Partners, last month in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
According to the complaint, Wilmington Trust is serving as trustee of the registered holders of Citigroup Commercial Mortgage Trust.
The legal action comes at a time when there has been growing concern about potential defaults in Downtown and elsewhere because of high office vacancy rates and hybrid work models triggered by the COVID-19 pandemic.
In the case of the Grant Building, at issue is a $38 million loan obtained by McKnight from Starwood Mortgage Capital in July 2017.
The complaint alleged that McKnight defaulted on the loan, prompting the lender to demand repayment of the full $37.7 million still owed. It cited as one “trigger event” the failure of building tenant Huntington National Bank to extend or renew its lease 12 months before the current expiration date next year for a term of at least five years and on “terms satisfactory to the noteholder in its reasonable discretion.”
Read More

A Huntington spokesman said Monday, “We have not made a decision regarding our current lease in the Grant Building for our corporate offices in Pittsburgh. We continue to invest in Downtown Pittsburgh, and we look forward to opening our new flagship Market Square branch this year.”
Other factors triggering the loan default, according to the complaint, included McKnight’s failure to make loan debt service payments last August and September and the filing of three mechanics liens totaling $213,593 against McKnight by Zeus Construction Co. for work done at the building. Those filings are still pending in Common Pleas Court.
Besides seeking a foreclosure and possible sale of the property, Wilmington Trust is requesting an order directing that all rents, proceeds, revenues, profits and income be turned over to the lender to reduce the amount McKnight owes on the loan.
In addition, it has asked Common Pleas Judge Christine Ward, who has been assigned the case, to appoint the CBRE real estate firm to act as the property receiver while the foreclosure action is pending in court. Judge Ward has not acted on that request.
Izzy Rudolph, McKnight president and CEO, declined comment on the complaint. The attorney for Wilmington Trust could not be reached for comment.
Judge Ward has scheduled a status conference on the complaint for April 17. That could give McKnight and Wilmington time to work out a deal that would allow McKnight to retain ownership.
Experts in Pittsburgh and elsewhere have been warning about possible defaults as office vacancies have skyrocketed and buildings have lost value in the wake of the pandemic. Many employers are looking to cut their office footprints as employees continue to work from home at least a couple of days a week.
Wilmington moved to foreclosure even though the overall occupancy of the Grant Building is 88%, according to the Newmark real estate firm.
“Any time there’s a foreclosure on a building, it’s never a good thing,” said Gerard McLaughlin, Newmark executive managing director. “My hope is that they can figure it out.”
Dan Adamski, senior managing director of the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm, has said that there “without a doubt” will be more defaults in the years ahead. “There are buildings with debt coming due, buildings worth significantly less than what’s owed,” he said.
JLL has been pushing for a reimagining of Downtown, with fewer office buildings and more residential. The city has joined the effort, offering incentives to property owners who want to convert office buildings to apartments if they will commit to making at least 10% of the units affordable. That has been a stumbling block to some because of the high costs involved.
Pittsburgh isn’t the only one facing such challenges with its office space.
CoStar, a commercial real estate information company, reported that some building owners are voluntarily handing over their properties to lenders through deeds in lieu of foreclosure.
The San Francisco office market has been decimated by vacancies. In Los Angeles, a real estate investment fund defaulted on $750 million in mortgages involving two skyscrapers, according to the New York Times. At the same time, the woes could serve as an incentive for property owners and lenders to work out deals, experts told the newspaper.
Located at 310 Grant Street, the 37-story Grant Building is probably best known for the flashing beacon at its top that spells out PITTSBURGH in Morse code.
The art deco structure, designed by architect Henry Hornbostel, opened in the late 1920s and at one time was the tallest building between New York and Cleveland.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.