A Pittsburgh Public Schools lawsuit filed against Allegheny County and County Executive Sara Innamorato in an attempt to force a property reassessment in Allegheny County has been thrown out in court.

But what was the goal of and reasoning behind that lawsuit? Why did it fail? And what will the school district do now?

Why was the Pittsburgh Public Schools lawsuit filed?

PPS has estimated that property assessment reductions have cost the district more than $20 million in the last three years. Downtown properties have lost $500 million in taxable value during that period, driven by the declining office market.

These reductions have resulted in refunds that occur when property owners take advantage of a declining common level ratio (CLR).

Advertise with us

The district argued in its filing that the scope of the refunds has led to budgetary shortfalls that have forced the district to balance its budgets by using reserves and through “systematic understaffing” (172 unfilled positions in 2025). Additionally, there are legal costs associated with filing and fighting assessment appeals.

The district’s recently passed 2025 budget showed a $28 million operating deficit.

What is the common level ratio, and why does it matter?

The CLR is a percentage that’s applied to market value to account for growing disparities between taxable values and current sales prices on a by-appeal basis.

In Allegheny County, the CLR has fallen from 87.5% to 52.7% in recent years, with base year valuations still relying on the last assessment completed in 2012.

The lower ratio is comparatively more advantageous to property owners than to school districts and municipalities, which typically file appeals to raise assessments closer to the sales price to generate more revenue without increasing taxes.

Advertise with us

With the lower ratio, even in situations where the fair market value of a property is raised significantly, those gains could be more than offset once the ratio is applied to determine taxable value, producing a loss for the taxing bodies.

Why do property reassessments matter beyond budgets?

Supporters of the school district’s efforts argue that the current system has led to people living in communities where home values have significantly appreciated shouldering less of the tax burden than is equitable based on the fair value of their homes.

The district argued the current system is plagued with inequities and violates the uniformity clause of the Pennsylvania constitution, which states “all taxes shall be uniform, upon the same class of subjects, within the territorial limits of the authority levying the tax, and shall be levied and collected under general laws.”

Pennsylvania is the only state in the U.S. that doesn’t require periodic reassessments. Of the 67 counties, 54 haven’t reassessed in at least 12 years. That includes 10 that haven’t done so in more than 45 years.

Why was the Pittsburgh Public Schools lawsuit dismissed?

In an opinion and order issued Thursday, Allegheny County Common Pleas Court visiting senior Judge Kenneth Valasek ruled that the district did not have standing, or the legal right, to bring the lawsuit.

Advertise with us

Judge Valasek sided with Allegheny County’s argument in his ruling that the school district could resolve any budgetary shortfalls by simply raising taxes.

What informed the ruling?

Primarily, the idea that the district has not raised taxes in four years and therefore didn’t demonstrate a “direct interest” in the matter.

According to Judge Valasek’s ruling, the primary legal harm brought forward by the lawsuit could have been avoided by raising taxes by 1 mill this year, a move he said would have generated about $19 million for the district.

“The district allowed the refunds to impair its financial condition (the ultimate harm caused by the refunds) because it chose not to act,” he said. “This choice in four consecutive years was the cause of any degrading of the district’s financial condition.”

“Even a timely one-half mill increase would have prevented the impairment. The school district was not helpless at any relevant point in time to prevent this ‘harm’ from happening.”

Advertise with us

Judge Valasek also ruled the district had not successfully demonstrated violations of the state’s uniformity and the U.S. Constitution’s equal protection clauses on grounds of what the school district alleged was a flawed assessment system, the judge adding that the uniformity clause was designed to “protect taxpayers, not taxing authorities.”

What is Pittsburgh Public Schools saying about the ruling?

Pittsburgh Public Schools solicitor Ira Weiss disagreed with the judge’s reasoning.

“To suggest the failure of the district to raise taxes to the level apparently acceptable to the court simply ignores the fact that raising taxes only worsens the problem and increases the unconstitutional burden on those owning lower-valued properties,” he said.

“...While we respect the opinion of the court, we believe it incorrectly finds the district does not have a direct interest in having a legal constitutional assessment system and further incorrectly finds that the district has not been harmed. The unconstitutionality of the system constitutes harm in and of itself.”

The county has maintained that the current system is equitable in that it treats all taxing bodies the same and that they all have the right to correct inequities through appeals.

Advertise with us

Why doesn’t the county want a reassessment?

The county’s oppositional efforts and its legal representation have said it’s not the county’s duty to balance the district’s budget, that the current property valuation system is sound, that whether or not the district would be in better financial shape with a reassessment amounts to “speculation” and that lost value “alone shouldn’t be the basis for a full reassessment.”

“Any reassessment must be revenue neutral and not a backdoor tax hike for the people of Allegheny County and should protect seniors and low-income homeowners in the process,” said Abigail Gardner, a spokeswoman for Ms. Innamorato, at the time of the lawsuit’s filing.

“Ideally reassessments would be state-mandated, mundane, regular occurrences and not once-per-decade shocks to the system. Our preference is to work with stakeholders to build a more predictable system for everyone.”

Additionally, in September 2024, Virginia Scott, a county assistant solicitor, argued declining property values Downtown are more a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and its effects on the office market than the assessment system.

Does this mean there won’t be an Allegheny County property reassessment?

Judge Valasek’s ruling does not leave the county entirely off the hook. It is still facing a separate lawsuit filed by Churchill homeowner Flavia E. Laun, who, as defined by Judge Valasek previously would have standing as a taxpayer, to potentially force a countywide reassessment via lawsuit.

Advertise with us

That lawsuit, based on the notion that her $142,900 assessment is well above the average for her street even though her house is of similar value or “comparatively inferior to several neighboring properties with lower assessments” also claims that the county’s “outdated, discriminatory and non-uniform” assessment system violates state uniformity and constitutional equal protection clauses.

It is also filed by Mr. Weiss, who was the attorney in the lawsuit filed by a property owner resulting in the county’s last court-ordered reassessment in 2012.

Additionally, in his ruling for the recently dismissed lawsuit, Judge Valasek emphasized that the “dismissal of the lawsuit brought by the school district should not be interpreted to mean that Allegheny County’s current assessments are constitutionally permissible. This issue has not been decided by the court.”

How long has the Pittsburgh Public Schools lawsuit been going on?

PPS filed the lawsuit 10 months ago, in April 2024.

Where will Pittsburgh Public Schools go from here?

Mr. Weiss said the district will “consider its options and take the necessary steps to correct what is obviously an untenable situation.”