Less than two years after the pandemic officially ended, some Market Square merchants are bracing for a disruption of a different sort — the yearlong reconstruction of the historic Downtown space.
And it’s creating some anxious moments.
“People are worried that it will negatively affect business and stop a lot of business,” said Sammy Fowler, manager of the Yard Gastropub on the north end of the square.
Ms. Fowler’s restaurant will be one of the first to feel the impact when that side of the square shuts down for 5½ months starting on April 1. She’s expecting it to affect business. Just how much is hard to say.
“I’m definitely a little worried, but I’m trying to stay hopeful,” she said.
The $14 million to $16 million overhaul is the second for the square in 16 years. The last one in 2009 — a $5 million project that turned the space into a European-style piazza — cost the square two of its businesses, a fact that still weighs on the minds of those who lived through it.
Read More
“It would be a real shame to see merchants go out of business because of the construction of the square, with the whole point being to make it a more vibrant area,” said Jordan Nicholas, owner of Nicholas Coffee & Tea, a longtime Market Square staple.
The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, which is overseeing the makeover, has said it will do its best to minimize disruptions.
It stated Tuesday after the city Planning Commission approved the project that access to the square “will be carefully managed to minimize disruptions for businesses and the public.”
PDP officials are hoping to prevent problems in part by replacing sidewalks and streets in phases and keeping at least part of the square open to traffic throughout the reconstruction.
But at least one prominent stakeholder doesn’t feel as if the efforts go far enough.
Michael Sriprasert, president of the Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, which owns property in the square, said the group is “very concerned about the impact this construction work will have on the most fully leased and active area of Downtown.”
“We have asked the PDP to provide funding for any lost revenues by the merchants during this construction period and commit to retaining all our Market Square retailers,” he said in an email.
In response, Jeremy Waldrup, PDP president and CEO, said the group is discussing with the city and the Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority programs to assist merchants financially during the revamp.
He added the PDP “will continue engaging with the merchants to understand those needs.”
Mr. Nicholas said discussions about merchants being made whole for lost revenues are still in the early stages. He noted that it came up during a meeting about the construction that generated “a lot of emotion” from business owners.
At the same time, he believes the PDP is doing what it can to offset the impacts.
“They’re trying their best to minimize it as much as possible. You’re not going to get it 100% right. Hopefully, they’re able to alleviate the lost sales or lost revenue being down a year. That’s a big ask,” he said.
While the PDP plans to keep access to businesses open during the renovations, the center of the square will be closed for the entire year. That, too, could impact businesses for customers who are accustomed to cutting across the space to get from one side to the other.
The last time the square was remodeled in 2009, it was “a little disruptive” to Nicholas Coffee “but our customers remained loyal and came to see us,” Mr. Nicholas said. He’s hoping it will be the same this year.
“I’m sure there will be an impact but to what degree, I can’t speak to that,” he said, adding that overall he thinks the work will be beneficial once completed.
At the Original Oyster House, the square’s oldest business dating back to 1870, owner Jen Grippo believes merchants are heading into the project “as prepared as possible.”
She said they learned to adapt and change during the pandemic, lessons that should come in handy during the square work.
As for the impact, “It’s hard to tell until we are in the process of the construction. We have a lot of confidence in the PDP when they say they’re going to work diligently to ensure that we can continue to do business. It will just be a little different,” she said.
At the same time, she admitted all merchants have expressed “some type of hesitation” about the project.
“I do have confidence in our business owners and stakeholders that we will do everything we can to succeed during and after the construction,” she said.
Under the PDP construction plan, work will take place on the north side of the square closest to the Oyster House, Nicholas Coffee, and the Yard for the first 5½ months. It then will switch to the south end closest to Primanti’s and PPG Place for the next 5½ months.
At Alta Via restaurant in 2 PPG Place on the square’s south side, Gregory Koob, manager of the beverage program, isn’t expecting much fallout from the work.
He said that most of the restaurant’s customers come Downtown for sporting events, concerts, or the theater, not specifically to programs in Market Square.
“I don’t necessarily think it will have a huge impact,” he said.
With the renovations, the south end of the square will be closed to all vehicular traffic while the north side will remain open. Parking will be banned throughout the square.
The centerpiece of the overhaul is the construction of a half-moon pergola-like structure that will occupy the east side of the square. Changes also will be made to Market Street to make it more pedestrian friendly.
Other improvements include new lighting, replacing the square’s Belgium Block and brick with precast pavers to make walking easier, and adding historical markers.
The improvements are part of the nearly $600 million plan announced in October to revitalize Downtown.
Mr. Koob said he doesn’t believe eliminating vehicular traffic on the Alta Via end of the square will be an issue for the restaurant, noting that the PDP already does that for events like the farmers markets.
Mr. Nicholas, meanwhile, is thankful that the construction work will start on his end of the square. That means it should be fully reopened for the holiday season, one of its busiest times of the year.
He acknowledged that he is “lukewarm” about the decision to eliminate traffic on one side of the square and to ban parking altogether, noting there are varying opinions on both measures.
The original plan for the rehab called for eliminating all traffic in the square. It was revised after pushback from merchants.
For Mr. Nicholas, his biggest concerns are ensuring safety in the square, particularly with the plans to increase outdoor dining, and getting the work done before the NFL Draft comes to Pittsburgh in April 2026.
“That would be an unfortunate thing for this not to be finished before the draft,” he stressed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.