Downtown stakeholders have abandoned a plan to remove vehicles from Market Square after fierce opposition from merchants and others who feared that it would have a devastating impact on business.
Jeremy Waldrup, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, said the initial reports about traffic being eliminated from the square were based on a “conceptual drawing” of “what the future of Market Square could be,” not any formal plan.
In an interview, he stated that vehicles would not be banned, noting that access is needed for everything, including deliveries to food pickups at popular spots like the Original Oyster House.
“Closing the square off to traffic is not really an option,” he said.
Banning traffic from the square was part of “aspirational plans” unveiled by the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, Mayor Ed Gainey, and Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato during a media tour in June in a bid to turn Downtown into more of a neighborhood.
At the time, Stefani Pashman, Allegheny Conference CEO, said the goal in eliminating vehicles was to make the square feel more like a European piazza.
Read More

But several merchants and property owners said that they were never consulted on the plans beforehand and were blindsided by the conference’s announcement.
Michael Sriprasert, president of the Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, said that he and Arthur Ziegler, the foundation’s co-founder and former president, were “shocked” to hear about the plan. The foundation owns several properties in Market Square.
“When everything was announced, no one was talked to. We confirmed that with our own tenants and other tenants,” Mr. Sriprasert said.
But Mr. Waldrup maintained that the initial rollout of the proposal to shut off the square to traffic “wasn’t an approved plan” and that meetings with merchants and other stakeholders were always part of the agenda before any formal proposal was advanced.
The PDP did meet with merchants in July, during which many raised objections to eliminating traffic. Mr. Waldrup said another meeting would be held later this month “to share some new designs and get their feedback.”
None would involve closing the square to traffic altogether, he said.
“It’s just impossible. You can’t do that,” he said, pointing out that there’s a parking garage with an entrance and exit in the square and that there are residents who live in the upper floors of some of the buildings.
Mr. Waldrup said the PDP still would like to close off at least part of the square to traffic during some special events. He noted, for example, that the south end closest to PPG Place typically is blocked to traffic during Thursday farmers markets that run from mid May through October.
In an email, the Allegheny Conference stated that “the PDP is leading on the schematic design and public input process related to Market Square, so the comments made by Jeremy are reflective of plans as they stand at this time. The conference is supportive of the overall project and outcomes.”
The PDP, Mr. Waldrup said, is now focused on priorities outlined by merchants and business owners during the summer meeting. They include improved trash management, expanded outdoor dining for restaurants, better lighting and more reliable power sources for events.
In addition, the PDP is looking at ways to redesign the square to create more flexibility for large and small events. It is also mulling the idea of removing the cobblestone to provide a better pedestrian experience.
Merchants also want more programming like Picklesburgh that brings business into the square and a space that is welcoming with ample police presence. The trees and tree beds also may be evaluated to see if changes are needed, Mr. Waldrup said.
“We want to make sure their businesses thrive,” he said. “That’s why we work hand and hand with them and spend a lot of energy to bring people into the square.”
Jordan Nicholas, owner of Nicholas Coffee & Tea, a longtime Market Square staple, said he doesn’t mind part of the space being shut down for events like the farmers markets. But he’s opposed to eliminating vehicles entirely.
“I think they recognize that probably will be impossible given the logistics of some of the establishments in the square,” he said.
Mr. Nicholas’ top priorities for the square are safety and more programming. “You have to give the community a larger reason to come Downtown. The more activities you develop, they give people a reason to come to town,” he said.
As for safety, which has been an ongoing concern in Downtown for several years, Mr. Nicholas said he has seen improvement, with a larger police presence and greater interaction with merchants. But he added that it “is still an issue” that needs attention.
Jen Grippo, owner of the Original Oyster House, a Market Square landmark that got its start in 1870, said vehicular access is needed for customers who swing by to pick up food for their families.
“I want them to have convenient access. I don’t want them to struggle to find [a parking space] a block up the street to come down for a fish sandwich and a pop,” she said.
After mandatory shutdowns because of the COVID-19 pandemic and fewer people working in Downtown in its aftermath, the last thing the Oyster House needs is another obstacle in doing business by barring vehicles from the square, Ms. Grippo said.
“I pretty much told them in the meeting that there was no option but to change the plan,” she said.
Mr. Sriprasert and Mr. Ziegler said they were pleased to hear that the conference and other stakeholders had backed off the plan to eliminate traffic.
They added that they have no problem with the PDP closing off part of Market Square for special events as long as traffic can flow unimpeded from Forbes and back to Forbes at each end of the square.
But Mr. Ziegler stressed that any closings should be done in consultation with those merchants and property owners affected.
“They aren’t to assume that they have better ideas than the people doing business there and the people owning property there,” he said.
Mr. Ziegler did object to the idea of removing the square’s cobblestones.
“We would not remove that pavement. It slows traffic and has worked well all of these years,” he said. “We think it’s fine to improve the public area inside [the cobblestone], but it should be done by talking to all of the merchants, all of the business owners, and us before saying we have a plan.”
When work begins on a redesign depends on the feedback the PDP receives, and developing consensus on a plan everyone “feels good about,” Mr. Waldrup said. The goal is to start construction next year and have it finished before the NFL draft is held in Pittsburgh in spring 2026.
Market Square last received a makeover in 2010, with merchants enduring more than a year of sidewalk and street closings. Some ended up not making it. Two closed during the construction and another shut its doors after the work was finished.
That $5 million reconstruction gave the square its present look. As part of the work, buses were removed from the square, and the current traffic patterns around the square were created.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.