In the heat of enticements and ultimatums lobbed during U.S. Steel’s ill-fated campaign to sell itself to Japanese company Nippon Steel, the iconic Pittsburgh steelmaker said without this deal, it may close plants and move its headquarters out of the Steel City.

In making the threat, the Downtown-based company followed well-worn foot steps of other Pittsburgh giants — some who threatened loudly and others who quietly left.

Pittsburgh historian Joel Tarr remembers the panic of the mid-1990s when the Pittsburgh Pirates were vowing to find a new home unless Pittsburgh figured out a way to build them a new, old-fashioned ballpark.

He recalled trying to put the threat into perspective, writing at the time that a Pirates’ exit would be a lesser blow to Pittsburgh than a company like, say, Mellon Bank.

Advertise with us

“Some of us wish the Pirates would get sold,” he grumbled last week.

What Mr. Tarr saw in Mellon Bank was an institution “woven into the fabric of the community,” with a commitment to venture capital and corporate giving.

“I thought Mellon Bank was such a fixture here,” he said.

And it was. The bank that began in a Smithfield Street office in 1870 grew to be among the nation’s largest by the time it was sold to Bank of New York in 2007.

Its former CEO Marty McGuinn, writing in 2022 in Pittsburgh Quarterly, said the city was on the losing side of that transaction.

Advertise with us

Mr. McGuinn was pushed out of the company in 2006 and has given his account of why he wouldn’t have sold the investment firm. In 2022, he estimated that BNY Mellon still had 7,000 employees in the Pittsburgh region (down from 12,000 before the sale), but that its executives were in New York. And that was a big loss, he argued.

“Having the senior officers in the city is a big benefit of having the corporate headquarters because there’s a tradition of supporting the community, and the senior officers themselves are involved in the fabric of the community as leaders who support the community,” he wrote.

Back to the Pirates.

The team’s quest for a new ballpark inspired other thought experiments about large corporate players trading Pittsburgh for a better gig.

In a May 1994 column, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Tom Hritz compared the nagging threat of the Pirates leaving to “what would happen to Pittsburgh if USAir flew the coop.”

Advertise with us

“They’re both local economic fixtures, and they’re both hemorrhaging money,” Mr. Hritz wrote. “The only difference is that while the Pirates publicly bawl about it, USAir pretends it isn’t happening.”

USAir, which had made Pittsburgh a hub and was the driving force behind the $1 billion Pittsburgh International Airport construction completed in 1992, had about 12,000 employees here at the time. It would come to control about 80% of the flights at the airport.

It seemed unthinkable then that within a decade, the airline would close its hub and slash thousands of jobs in Pittsburgh. Or that today, Pittsburgh International would be finishing a $1.6 billion new passenger terminal to replace the one outfitted for USAir three decades earlier.

USAir’s departure was a gut punch and a financial mess for the airport. But it opened up room for more airlines to compete in Pittsburgh.

And despite Mr. Tarr’s warnings 30 years ago, the evolution and corporate flight of Mellon Bank (now BNY Mellon) hasn’t decimated Pittsburgh’s banking or philanthropic scenes, as he is first to admit.

Advertise with us

“I think (the impact) was minimal,” he said. “We haven’t suffered from a shortage of banking. PNC — they’ve done amazingly well.”

Mr. Tarr, 91, has seen his fair share of icons coming and leaving the Steel City. His research and many publications have focused on environmental, industrial and urban development here.

He used the same phrase to describe U.S. Steel as Mellon Bank — “a fixture.”

Sometimes, fixtures come loose and sometimes they are replaced by newer models.

Mill 19, part of the Hazelwood Green complex in Hazelwood. The former steel mill is now a mixed-use development that houses start-ups, universities, and other facilities. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Mr. Tarr praised the decision not to “reindustrialize” the abandoned J&L Steel Hazelwood Works. It is now a mixed-use development that houses start-ups, university-related entities, and other facilities that don’t belch black smoke, he said.

Advertise with us

“Let’s say they do close down the coke works,” he said of U.S. Steel’s facility in Clairton. “What kinds of facilities could move into the Mon Valley? A company manufacturing self-driving cars? Maybe Tesla would move a facility into the Mon Valley and that would employ eventually many more people.”

Many of the changes that might provoke anxiety if U.S. Steel decides to leave the region have been cascading over decades, he said.

Today’s U.S. Steel is already a much different company than it was 40 years ago, when it was the largest private employer in the region, with 34,000 workers, and the second biggest Pittsburgh company on the Fortune 500 list. (When the Fortune 500 list began in 1955, U.S. Steel was ranked the third biggest industrial company in the country).

The top Pittsburgh company on that 1984 list was another tale of a local icon leaving the Steel City. Gulf Corp. — whose former pyramid-topped Art Deco headquarters Downtown is now slated for a major redevelopment into luxury housing — was sold to California-based Standard Oil (now Chevron) that year for $13.2 billion.

It was the largest takeover in U.S. corporate history at that point, and by the following year, the Gulf Tower was emptied of the company’s thousands of workers.

Advertise with us

“I lost a good job,” said Jim Murdy, who was Gulf Oil’s CFO. “That’s what happens when headquarters leave.”

Mr. Murdy landed on his feet. He went to work for Allegheny Ludlum, which eventually became ATI, and finished his career in 2003 as the company’s CEO. In 2022, ATI moved its headquarters from Pittsburgh to Dallas.

“I think when you lose a headquarters company, there’s a loss of identity,” Mr. Murdy said.

In addition to the corporate employees who worked at a moved company, there also is a class of professional contractors in the headquarters city that suffers.

Mr. Murdy remembers that Gulf Oil was a significant client of several local law firms, for example, including Pittsburgh-based Reed Smith and Kirkpatrick & Lockhart, which is now K&L Gates.

Advertise with us

“It has a broader effect,” he said.

The Gulf name hasn’t stuck around Pittsburgh the way other departing company monikers have.

If the Post-Gazette’s own breathless reporting on the fate of the Heinz ketchup bottle at Acrisure Stadium is any indication, the Heinz brand’s importance to the city has long ago diverged from its headcount.

H.J. Heinz Co., the consumer brand that began with 16-year-old Henry Heinz making horseradish in his Sharpsburg home, now lives more in its philanthropic offshoots here than in the actual business of making condiments.

Heinz threatened to scale back or leave Pittsburgh at least twice. Once, in 1962, during an eight-week labor strike at its North Side plant, the company took out a newspaper ad wondering whether it erred in expanding its meat products business on the North Side.

Advertise with us

That plant kept churning and at its peak in the 1980s, some 2,500 people worked for the company in Pittsburgh.

In 1999, when Heinz was planning to expand the campus but was having trouble persuading the owner of a nearby building to relocate, the company reportedly threatened to move its operations to Steubenville, Ohio. Pittsburgh threatened to use eminent domain against the reticent building owner, another Pittsburgh manufacturer, to make way for Heinz, according to research compiled by Pittsburgh historian David Rotenstein.

The pressure campaign worked. But in a few years’ time, Heinz would be gone from the North Side, too, having sold off parts of the plant to a real estate developer and the rest to Del Monte.

By 2015, when Heinz announced a $46 billion merger with Kraft, the Pittsburgh company was down to 800 employees here. The combined firm, called Kraft-Heinz, would be co-headquartered in Chicago and Pittsburgh, it was announced.

The C-suite is in Chicago.

But its legacy remains pickled in Pittsburgh.