In four years, Downtown’s second-tallest skyscraper could go from full to empty — perhaps overnight.
That could be the fate awaiting the 54-story BNY Mellon Center in 2028 when the master lease of its main tenant, BNY, ends.
By then, the building at 500 Grant St. could be empty. BNY, which leases all of the tower, has begun systematically moving workers from the structure to its service center behind it on Ross Street.
And, so far, it doesn’t appear that owner MetLife has been able to extend or cut new leases with the smattering of other tenants who are currently subleasing space that BNY has given up.
If nothing changes, that potentially could leave the building empty in 2028 when the BNY lease expires. On paper, the building could be full one day and empty the next. Some real estate experts believe the tower’s fate could be the biggest crisis facing the Golden Triangle.
“You can see it coming,” said Jeremy Kronman, a CBRE vice chairman. “After that lease expires, you will go from 100% full to a 100% empty office tower.”
Read More
That possibility increased this week when the Fox Rothschild law firm announced that it would leave the building either next year or in 2026 and relocate to 6 PPG Place.
Michael Syme, office managing partner for Fox Rothschild, said the firm liked BNY Mellon Center and its Grant Street location but was worried about the expiration of the BNY lease.
If BNY moves out, “that is causing some concern that it is conceivable that we would be in a relatively empty building, and that is not to our liking,” he said. “So we started to look at options and we concluded the best option was to make a move.”
Fox Rothschild has about 30,000 square feet in BNY Mellon Center. It will be taking 22,000 to 23,000 square feet in 6 PPG Place. Like many law firms, it will be reducing its footprint and adopting a “one-size-fits-all” approach that will make for the more efficient use of its space, Mr. Syme said.
It settled on PPG Place after looking at a number of other options in Downtown for its 80 employees, including the U.S. Steel Tower, One Oxford Centre, and EQT Plaza.
“We liked the office. We liked the area. And we liked being in that area of town,” Mr. Syme said. “We’re excited about the move. I think people are really looking forward to the changes.”
The Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm represented Fox Rothschild in the deal to move to PPG Place.
Dan Adamski, the JLL executive managing director who brokered the deal, said the move “reaffirms a dominant trend in today’s office market — many businesses, and particularly law firms, are rightsizing their footprint to reduce cost while simultaneously upgrading their space to provide an enhanced employee experience.
“With 34 of the top 35 Pittsburgh law firms being located in the central business district, the legal sector remains critical to revitalizing Downtown,” he said.
At the same time, the Fox Rothschild departure could signal bigger issues for BNY Mellon Center, which opened in 1984 during the city’s second renaissance.
With roughly 1.6 million square feet of space, the design of the structure doesn’t lend itself to a residential conversion. Some believe if the building does end up empty, the only logical alternative could be to demolish it.
“I don’t know what you do with a 1-million-square-foot office tower that becomes vacant all at once,” Mr. Kronman said.
Mr. Adamski had similar concerns.
“As tenants continue to exit BNY Mellon Center, it becomes even more critical to address its long-term future,” he said. “As the second-largest office building in our region, its status will have a significant impact on Downtown's overall health.”
He added that Mayor Ed Gainey’s office “has been briefed on the situation and is actively coordinating with various agencies up to the state level to explore alternative uses and potential long-term solutions that could involve public-private partnerships.”
Olga George, Mr. Gainey’s spokeswoman, declined comment.
A BNY spokesman also declined comment.
A spokesman for MetLife stated in an email Wednesday: “MetLife Investment Management is considering its future plans for BNY Mellon Center.”
Despite the worries, one local real estate expert cautioned that it’s still too early to be predicting doomsday for the building.
Gerard McLaughlin, Newmark executive managing director, said MetLife may not be in the position to extend or cut new leases at this point because it’s still waiting to find out what BNY intends to do.
“I think what they’re trying to do is figure it out. They’re either waiting for BNY Mellon or figuring out what to do if they aren’t renewing,” he said.
He noted that the BNY lease still has another four years to run so MetLife has time to sort things out.
“It’s probably a wise move on their part to take a step back to look at what their options are and come up with a plan going forward,” he said.
That’s not to say there aren’t potential issues. Mr. McLaughlin pointed out that if BNY does move out altogether, “there’s still going to be a large hole in that building” even if the other tenants stay.
“The bottom line is there will be space in that building going forward. MetLife will have a plan for that building and they will execute it. They’re a very savvy investor,” he said.

According to a breakdown obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, BNY still has 39 floors in the building that bear its name.
It appears that nine other firms have space in the tower spread over all or parts of 14 floors, including a handful shared with BNY. Those subleases are set to expire between this year and 2028.
It’s unclear just how many employees BNY has moved from its Pittsburgh headquarters to the client service center at 500 Ross St. since it notified staff of its plans last year.
Earlier this month, the banking giant formerly known as BNY Mellon announced that it would be dropping the Mellon name, so synonymous with Pittsburgh, for BNY on its marketing materials, letterhead, and in the bank’s Grant Street lobby. But the name will not change at the top of the Grant Street Building it leases.
BNY Mellon Center isn’t the first Downtown building from which the banker has moved employees. In 2015, it put its 41-story office building at 525 William Penn Place up for sale to cut real estate costs.
Over time it moved about 1,500 workers from the property, which it sold to New York-based Pearson Partners in 2016 for $67.65 million. The building is now about half vacant.
Should BNY Mellon Center empty out, it could have dire consequences for Downtown, which has been struggling with high office vacancies caused by the COVID-19 pandemic and hybrid work policies.
Those vacancies, coupled with a steep drop in the ratio used to calculate taxable value at property appeal hearings, have resulted in more than $400 million in assessment reductions for 15 Downtown buildings in 2023 alone, costing the city, the county, and the Pittsburgh Public Schools $9.4 million in refunds.
Among the 2024 appeals, MetLife is challenging the $149.9 million assessment on BNY Mellon Center
The woes have prompted the city to adopt a new 10-year tax abatement program to help developers and owners of failing office buildings to convert them to residential. But one of the concerns about BNY Mellon Center is that the layout doesn’t lend itself to such a use, experts said.
— Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.