There apparently will be no parole for Western Penitentiary.
Despite at least two proposals for the old North Side prison’s redevelopment, the state is moving ahead with plans to raze the buildings at the site.
The Department of General Services “is currently planning for the full demolition of the site as recommended by the SCI Pittsburgh Feasibility Study and will issue a competitive solicitation for proposals following demolition to sell the site” as authorized by the General Assembly, spokesman Eric Veronikis said.
In a separate email, Mr. Veronikis said demolition and remediation work is expected to be finished in 2027. The department intends to sell the property after that, he added.
DGS’ statement comes at a time when two developers have expressed interest in using the closed prison, formerly known as the State Correctional Institution Pittsburgh, for other purposes.
The newest involves a proposal by the family that operates the former Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum tourist attraction in Weston, W.Va., to convert the prison into a similar entertainment-type use.
Read More
Anthony Jordan, the Jordan family member who has been spearheading the initiative, has told local officials that he would privately fund the proposed redevelopment.
He has also said that he would continue to make the facilities available to the film industry, which has used Western Pen for a variety of productions, including “Mayor of Kingstown.”
Also interested in the site is Thomas Tripoli, a resort owner and retired developer who has proposed turning the penitentiary into a jail-centric hotel and hostel and the prison yard into a park for recreational vehicles.
Mr. Jordan said Monday that he is aware that DGS is sticking with the recommendation made last year by consultant Michael Baker International calling for the demolition of all 42 buildings on the prison grounds, including the main penitentiary, at a cost of $44 million and the repurposing of the site for industrial reuse.
Nonetheless, he is holding out hope that he can get DGS officials to reconsider.
“We’re trying to persuade them to look at another option,” he said.
Mr. Jordan, vice president of SafeCo Environmental Services in Morgantown, said he has meetings scheduled with DGS officials and others and has also reached out to state elected representatives in an effort to discuss the issue.
“It’s literally going to take everyone to get involved to change their minds,” he said of DGS.
While Mr. Jordan has declined to discuss details of what he is proposing for Western Pen, it is believed to be similar to what his family has done at the West Virginia asylum property, a hospital for the mentally ill that closed in 1994. There, the Jordans offer a variety of tours, including some that discuss the history of treatment for the mentally ill, architecture and medical procedures used throughout the years.
Mr. Tripoli, meanwhile, has written to Gov. Josh Shapiro, urging him to postpone the demolition and to “be open to receiving this viable restoration development proposal along with any others that may be offered.”
Along with the letter, he sent a petition signed by more than 1,000 people calling on the state to stop the demolition and to accept proposals for the reuse of the buildings and the courtyard.
Following the Michael Baker recommendation to raze the structures would simply “create a pad-ready site which would join the many, languishing pad-ready industrial sites in Hazelwood and around the area at a cost to the state of Pennsylvania of $44 million dollars,” he wrote to the governor.
“Selling the site as a privately funded, historic preservation project would save multi millions of dollars which could be used for Pennsylvania taxpayers in more valuable ways,” he stated.
Mr. Tripoli has dubbed his initiative as Save the Castle. He envisions at the site a theme hotel, a hostel to accommodate bicyclists utilizing the adjacent trail, and an RV park with space for more than 100 vehicles. His plan also would allow for the continuation of filming on the property.
The DGS plan would scuttle both of the proposed redevelopments, because all of the buildings would be razed. That, in turn, would bring an end to filming at the site.
In its report, Michael Baker found that demolishing the prison structures and repurposing the 21.7 acres for industrial reuse would be the most viable of the three options it studied in determining the highest and best use for the real estate.
It stated that retaining the main penitentiary building, the North Wall, and guard stations 1 and 2 for filming was “not feasible” absent a long-term agreement with the film industry for their use.
Michael Baker also stated in its report that representatives of the Marshall-Shadeland neighborhood where the lockup is located “voiced their strong opposition to retaining any portion of the facility, which left standing would serve as a continuing reminder of its negative emotional legacy and social injustice."
The city also has supported the recommendation to demolish the buildings to make the property development ready.
Local preservationists, on the other hand, see value in retaining at least some of the buildings because of their historic significance. The site is listed as a historic district on the National Register of Historic Places, with the main penitentiary and 23 other buildings included in the nomination.
The Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation has described the warden’s residence at the prison as “very important” and has lobbied for its retention and to save a section of cells.
In 2022, the state Legislature authorized DGS to solicit proposals for the site. At the time, the department was tasked with determining “what offers the best value and return on investment” in terms of a sale after proposals were received.
Factors that could be weighed included price, use of the real estate, job creation, and getting the property onto the tax rolls. The sale was authorized about a year before the Michael Baker study was released.
The state closed SCI Pittsburgh in 2017.
This story was updated at 12:19 p.m. on June 25, 2024, to remove a reference to the Great Allegheny Passage.
— Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.