More assessment-related relief could be on the way for some Allegheny County property owners.

County assessment board members agreed Thursday to petition Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg for the legal authority to give taxpayers another option to argue for assessment cuts at appeal hearings.

If the judge agrees, property owners will be able to seek an assessment reduction based on the common level ratio in their neighborhood or school district rather than in the county as a whole.

The ratio, a number used to determine taxable value at appeals hearings, is typically set by the state tax equalization board based on countywide sales data. This year it is 54.5%.

Advertise with us

But in pitching the proposal to give taxpayers another option, assessment board member Mike Suley said the ratio can vary from neighborhood to neighborhood and in some cases can be lower than the countywide average.

That means it could provide greater relief to property owners who win their appeals. For example, a house with a market value of $100,000 would be taxed at $54,500 at the 54.5% ratio. But if the neighborhood ratio was found to be 35%, it would be taxed at $35,000.

Mr. Suley offered the proposal in response to a May 29 order issued by Judge Hertzberg requiring the court’s board of viewers, which handles appeals from the county level, to allow taxpayers to present evidence relating to neighborhood-based common level ratios.

In the order, the judge cited a 2006 state Supreme Court ruling that in essence gave property owners the right to argue for common level ratios based on calculations for their neighborhood alone.

During Thursday’s meeting, Mr. Suley said that when he was last on the assessment board in the 1990s, it would allow property owners to present evidence based on such calculations. Back then, a county assessor would provide ratios of assessments to sale prices for each neighborhood.

Advertise with us

The practice, he said, ended about 24 years ago when the county switched from a board of commissioners-run government to one overseen by a county executive.

“What the judge is saying here is there’s another method where different ratios can be used,” Mr. Suley said. “All I’m asking the board to do is to petition the judge.”

Taking a proactive approach, he contended, will avoid litigation. He predicted that someone will sue to allow the option if the board doesn’t act.

“Our job is to just get it right. The purpose of the motion is that we get it right.”

In fact, John Silvestri, the attorney who filed the motion that precipitated Judge Hertzberg’s ruling regarding the board of viewers, said earlier this week that he would file a lawsuit to force the assessment board to do the same if it didn’t act on its own.

Advertise with us

During Thursday’s meeting, Mr. Silvestri also appealed to the board to allow him to present such evidence. He has said that in one case the ratios he calculated for one client who lives in Ross were 53.8% for 2022 and 53.17% for 2023, both below the countywide number.

In another, the ratio he calculated for Lawrenceville was 28.73%, nearly half that for the county.

At the same time, assessment board solicitor Amy Schrempf cautioned that property owners seeking to argue for a neighborhood-based common level ratio must provide evidence to prove its validity.

“They have to prove what’s the applicable neighborhood, what’s the applicable state law,” she said. “You just can’t come in and say, ‘well, I think [this is the common level ratio].’ You have to actually be able to prove it.”

Based on some of the appeals he has heard so far this year, Mr. Suley believes ratios in some neighborhoods are as low as 20% to 30%.

Advertise with us

“So is it fair, is it uniform, does it pass constitutional muster if we just slap a uniform countywide ratio?” he asked.

While one attorney has questioned whether assessment board hearing officers have the expertise to handle appeals involving neighborhood ratios, Mr. Suley said he took “umbrage” to such remarks, arguing that the board has certified general appraisers available to handle such cases.

One who chided the board Thursday for potentially adding neighborhood ratios to the mix of options available to property owners was Dominick Gambino, a former county assessment manager.

He maintained that it masked the real issue — the need for a countywide reassessment.

“Once you’ve dug yourself into a deep hole, the first thing you have to do is to stop digging. That’s what they keep doing,” he said. “They’re just adding another level of meaninglessness that makes things more inequitable.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Gambino, a tax consultant for municipalities and school districts, said the fact the common level ratio varies from neighborhood to neighborhood shows the kind of inequities that currently exist and is proof that a reassessment is needed.

“Now we’re going to walk in [to appeal hearings] and have dueling ratio studies. To me it’s like fighting with paper swords,” he said. “They keep digging themselves deeper and deeper into a mess that no one even understands anymore.”

Dueling common level ratios could also open the door for more lawsuits in the form of equity challenges, he said.

“You will have some folks in the county paying at 20% and others at 70% for the same tax,” he said.

The Pittsburgh Public Schools has sued to force a countywide reassessment. The litigation is pending in Common Pleas Court.

— Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.