The declining common level ratio in Allegheny County has allowed many homeowners and commercial real estate holders to cut their property tax bills. Now one county assessment board member wants to make it even easier to do.

Mike Suley wants to give property owners the option of arguing for a common level ratio as calculated for their neighborhood or school district rather than the countywide average typically set each year by the state tax equalization board.

This year, the state-set ratio used to determine taxable value at appeal hearings is 54.5%. But Mr. Suley argued the number can vary from neighborhood to neighborhood. In some cases, it can be lower than the countywide average, he contended.

“It’s kind of like looking at the Pirates team batting average. That is not a reflection of what one or two players are doing,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Suley plans to discuss the issue with fellow board members on Thursday in hopes that they will back the proposal. He said it would give property owners “another arrow in the quiver” in appeals seeking a reduction in their taxable value.

“What it comes down to is fairness and equity,” he said. “The idea is to treat everyone the same.”

The impetus for the proposal came in a May 29 order by county Common Pleas Court Judge Alan Hertzberg.

In it, he required the court’s board of viewers, which handles assessment appeals from the county level, to hold a hearing to permit taxpayers “to present evidence of the assessment-to-value ratio of similar properties of the same nature in the neighborhood.”

The order was based on a 2006 state Supreme Court ruling that in essence gave property owners the right to argue for common level ratios based on calculations for their neighborhood.

Advertise with us

Attorney John Silvestri said Judge Hertzberg’s order was an outgrowth of a motion he filed asking for relief for his clients after he became frustrated at the board of viewers’ insistence on using an 87.5% ratio in their case.

Using neighborhood instead of countywide ratios can be a real benefit to taxpayers, he said.

In one appeal scheduled to be heard next month, the ratios Mr. Silvestri has calculated for Ross, where a client lives, are 53.8% for 2022 and 53.17% for 2023 — below the current 54.5% countywide. For the North Hills School District, the ratio is 51.37% for 2022 and 51.95% for 2023.

Mr. Silvestri said he also has an appeal pending before the assessment board for a Lawrenceville property in which he calculated the common level ratio for the neighborhood at a stunning 28.73% — nearly half of the countywide number.

If the board of viewers, the step above the assessment board in adjudicating appeals, must consider neighborhood ratios, the assessment board should be doing the same, Mr. Suley maintained.

Advertise with us

“Everybody should be treated the same in the appeals process in Allegheny County. Period,” he said.

Rather than simply saying OK to the approach, Mr. Suley wants the assessment board to petition Judge Hertzberg to issue an order allowing property owners to present evidence relating to neighborhood common level ratios at the county level hearings.

That way, he asserted, future boards will have to abide by it. “If we get a court order, it will stand the test of time,” he said.

If the assessment board doesn’t act, Mr. Silvestri said he would file his own lawsuit asking Judge Hertzberg to require the county board to consider such ratios.

He maintained that he’s not confident that the assessment board will do so on its own. He said he had one case recently in which he presented evidence that the ratio should have been 68% and the assessment board kept it at 87.5%.

Advertise with us

“Not only do I have no faith, I know that they won’t do it from my past experience,” he said.

But Amy Schrempf, assessment board solicitor, dismissed Mr. Silvestri’s concerns.

The board, she stressed, has always considered the evidence that comes before it. That would include neighborhood ratios.

“Whether you prove it is a different animal,” she said. “You can’t just come in and say my belief is that the common level ratio in my neighborhood is 30% and I want that.”

While using a neighborhood ratio may benefit property owners looking to lower their tax bill, it could also create more havoc for school districts and municipalities already struggling to cope with revenue losses caused by assessment reductions.

Advertise with us

However, Lee Dellecker, an attorney who represents local taxing bodies, said he’s not too concerned about the implications of the court order as it relates to the board of viewers.

Property owners don’t frequently use neighborhood common level ratios to calculate taxable value, he pointed out, in part because such studies can be expensive to do, costing upward of $30,000 to $40,000.

He added the option of using neighborhood-calculated common level ratios has been allowed under state law for a while.

“It’s been out there for a long time. It’s just not one that’s frequently pursued,” he said.

If anything, Judge Hertzberg’s order could help to streamline cases because it gives clear direction to the board of viewers.

Advertise with us

At the same time, Mr. Dellecker said he does have qualms about the assessment board permitting such evidence. One reason is that property owners can submit their evidence up to 10 days in advance of hearings.

That, he said, may not give districts or municipalities enough time to review and evaluate the evidence.

“I do have concerns to the extent that you could get all of these random ratios out there that create anarchy and there’s no consistency,” he said.

Mr. Dellecker also wondered whether the officers hired by the assessment board to conduct hearings would have the expertise to weigh and interpret ratio studies.

“At the board of viewers and court level, you have a slightly more sophisticated, methodological approach,” he said.

Advertise with us

The countywide common level ratio has plunged from 87.5% several years ago to 54.5% this year. In response to a lawsuit, Judge Hertzberg ordered it set at 63.5% in 2022.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.