A block from the Old State House in Boston’s historic city center, workers are preparing to transform the darkened interiors of three vacant office buildings into a single residential high-rise that could one day house hundreds.

In Cincinnati, developers added 342 residences to once-empty commercial towers in 2023 alone, with more in the pipeline this year.

Just two hours from Pittsburgh, Cleveland’s once struggling downtown has seen a larger share of its offices transformed into more residential space than any other city in the nation — part of a wave of projects that are reshaping cities in the wake of a pandemic that left empty office towers across the country.

While some cities created programs years ago to address the losses in their urban centers, Pittsburgh leaders are now just launching initiatives to reverse the same trends that have irrevocably changed the city’s downtown, the Post-Gazette has found.

Advertise with us

The recent efforts to jumpstart construction projects comes as the city confronts millions in falling revenue, diminishing federal aid and rising payroll costs that experts warn is pushing Pittsburgh toward a fiscal emergency.

“You can't do business as usual,” said Aaron Stauber, president of Rugby Realty, which owns Pittsburgh’s iconic Gulf Tower. Other cities “recognized that much earlier, and they put in place policies that were very supportive of the exact thing that we need now in the city."

Leaders in other cities such as Washington, D.C., have pushed programs to attract developers who can stem the bleeding by adding thousands of residential units — critical to the survival of downtowns that have long served as economic engines.

Rising vacancy rates have sent the values of office high-rises plummeting — and with them, real estate taxes that governments rely on to pay for crucial services for millions of residents.

The number of office-to-residential conversions in U.S. cities is expected this year to be four times what it was in 2021, with the creation of government incentives and easier permitting to draw in the vast amounts of investment dollars needed to keep these key areas from spiraling into disuse.

Advertise with us

In Pittsburgh’s central business district, only one major conversion project is underway. The Urban Redevelopment Authority approved loans for two others in April, part of a $9 million pilot program that began in 2022 and was funded with federal COVID aid.

Fully a quarter of the property tax revenue the city needs to pay for services for hundreds of thousands of residents and visitors comes from Downtown buildings. But in the years since the pandemic began in 2020, those properties have lost at least $383 million in value.

The losses — driven by the exodus of thousands of workers — have impacted some of the most recognizable buildings in Pittsburgh’s skyline. The modernist Three Gateway Center, for example, lost $27.2 million in value.

PNC Plaza, once hailed as a model of sustainable architecture and a symbol of Pittsburgh’s resurgence, fell by nearly $75 million — more than half what it had been worth.

The value of the U.S. Steel Tower, the city’s tallest, fell by a sizable $91.6 million.

Advertise with us

Taken together, the buildings’ losses have slashed tax revenue by more than $3 million in just the last year, and will cost the city millions more in refunds for overpayments dating to 2022.

At the same time, most of the $335 million that was given to Pittsburgh in federal COVID aid has been spent, and a tax on visiting athletes and performers has been declared unconstitutional, sharpening the threat to city finances.

In April, after months of growing concern over the city’s finances, Mayor Ed Gainey said he would address the unfolding crisis with a task force of senior members of his staff and City Council — all individuals who already have control over the city’s budget.

Mr. Gainey declined an interview request and did not respond to a list of questions sent by the Post-Gazette.

In recent months, local officials have scrambled to catch up to other cities that have passed new tax breaks and set up large loan funds to kickstart the transformation of office buildings into apartments, condos and hotels.

Advertise with us

On Wednesday, Pittsburgh officials and Downtown stakeholders will unveil a plan that’s aimed at “a long-term strategic redevelopment and investment strategy” for Downtown.

The sudden push to attract developers — including a plea from the Urban Redevelopment Authority to the state for $30 million in aid — represents a turnaround for Mr. Gainey, who has spent much of his time in office at odds with real estate companies. Major construction projects have stalled or been scaled back in recent years.

Just days after taking office in January 2022, Mr. Gainey put a month-long hold on a large project in Oakland that would have added more than 1,000 apartments to the city’s property rolls, but had drawn opposition from some in the neighborhood.

The developer, Walnut Capital, has since dropped plans to build part of the project — including a grocery store, more than 400 apartments and a hotel — though the company is still trying to add hundreds of housing units to the neighborhood.

Another proposed housing project, the Oakland Portal, foundered after a battle over city zoning changes.

Advertise with us

In early 2023, Mr. Gainey raised the fees for zoning permits twentyfold, an increase so steep that one study said it made Pittsburgh “the most expensive city in the country to do business in.”

After an outcry from developers, the mayor capped the fee at $40,000 — still far higher than many other cities, where the cost can be a few thousand or even hundreds of dollars, according to the study.

For a major project on the scale of what’s been proposed in Pittsburgh’s Oakland neighborhood, the fee in Philadelphia would be $2,621. In Columbus, Ohio, it would be $565. In Raleigh, N.C., $2,272.

In Pittsburgh’s east end, a major expansion of Bakery Square that would add retail and housing space to the area has bogged down amid talks with Mr. Gainey’s administration, even after the developer and a community group signed an agreement that would have resulted in millions of dollars in investment in Larimer, one of the city’s poorest neighborhoods.

At the same time, rising interest rates and building costs continue to make it harder for developers to start new projects without massive amounts of assistance from governments, real estate executives say.

Advertise with us

"We're not making this up,” Mr. Stauber said. “This is not some fantasy. Costs of construction are higher than they've ever been. Banks are way more conservative than they've ever been. Interest rates are higher than they've ever been. When you put all that together, you can't make market deals happen. And you're going to look for cities and communities that get it — and that's where you invest your money."

Officials in Boston began devising a program to spur residential conversion projects in 2020, just months after its downtown office towers emptied out in the wake of the pandemic.

As part of the initiative, which was formally announced in October, city officials offered tax abatements to developers and slashed a tangle of red tape in the permitting process. The time it took to secure a permit plunged from two years to about nine months.

Now, seven buildings that had been at least half vacant are in the pipeline for conversion. More than 300 new apartments are expected.

In Cincinnati, Mayor Aftab Pureval, who came into office in January 2022 — the same time as Mr. Gainey — recognized the dangers of a languishing downtown early in his tenure.

Advertise with us

He assembled a group of more than 30 major stakeholders in the city — developers, CEOs, government officials and community leaders, including Procter & Gamble CEO Joe Moeller as the chair — to dive into the city’s financial woes and come up with a rescue plan.

Overspending, persistent losses in tax revenue and a lack of investment in critical projects that could spur economic growth were projected to blast a $487 million hole in Cincinnati’s budget by 2033, the commission reported.

“When I say everything's on the table, I mean it,” Mr. Pureval told reporters after the report came out.

The commission's members recommended a slew of fixes: a slight increase in income tax, and a housing investment fund that would operate alongside the city’s thriving office-to-residential conversion program.

“The local strategy is to direct as much vibrancy back downtown as possible, as quickly as possible,” Jack Willingham, a senior official in the Cincinnati mayor’s office, told the Post-Gazette. “That has been a core part of the rebound from the pandemic years.”

Advertise with us

St. Paul, Minn., unveiled its downtown revitalization plan in March, an effort that brought together researchers from across the country.

The city has introduced a publicly subsidized coworking model to bring office employees back to the urban center.

“Downtowns depend on … having people there close to 24/7,” said Rebecca Noecker, a St. Paul City Council member whose district includes the business district. “As soon as you hollow out downtowns of their people, they become these empty shells that feel and are unsafe.”

Officials have already begun to waive permitting fees for developers downtown and established a point person specifically for conversions to “get them from concept to construction much more quickly,” Ms. Noecker said.

One hurdle that confronts industry leaders in Pittsburgh is what they describe as a morass of bureaucracy that frequently slows their efforts to get major projects off the ground. The permitting process alone can take months, along with requests for zoning changes and negotiations with top city officials.

Advertise with us

Other cities have worked to remove such roadblocks.

In Newark, N.J., a city long plagued by poverty and reeling from the pandemic, leaders created one-stop shopping to usher projects from the planning stage through all the steps that projects must undergo to get approval, said Mr. Stauber, whose company portfolio includes properties in Ohio, New Jersey, New York and Connecticut.

"All you have to do is say, 'I have the land, I have the project,' walk into the mayor's office and they will literally walk you through the process and say, 'Done,'” Mr. Stauber said.

"Because they want to have these projects, they approve them.”

Local leaders say Pittsburgh needs to look for ways to remove barriers, otherwise investors will pull their money and launch projects in other areas of the country.

Advertise with us

“The developer bears all the cost of the delay, but has no control about how to minimize that delay of a permitting system,” said Kendall Pelling, executive director of Rising Tide Partners, a local non-profit that restores deteriorating homes.

“Downtown projects are big. And if you get delayed six months waiting for permitting, that's a huge expense for a project that could make the difference between moving forward or not.”

That can be costly not just for developers and downtown property owners, but for residents. As property taxes plummet in the business district, more of the city’s costs for basic services will fall on everyday homeowners through higher taxes as the government struggles to close gaps in its budget.

“We recognize that any tax impact downtown, property value impact downtown, is going to then spread out the tax burden — shift it to the neighborhoods and to residents,” said Ms. Noecker. “Downtown is our economic engine. It's really important that we keep it strong.”

Staff writers Mark Belko and Michael Korsh contributed to this report.