The city of Pittsburgh won’t put on hold a sharp hike in a zoning review fee imposed in January, but is open to at least discussing possible adjustments after hearing from developers outraged over the increase.

During a meeting Friday with members of the development community, the Mayor Ed Gainey administration declined to suspend enforcement of the fee, as developer Walnut Capital had requested, according to sources familiar with the discussion.

But it did agree to meet again in an effort to try to reach a possible compromise, although a deal is far from certain, sources said.

Friday’s meeting was arranged by NAIOP Pittsburgh and the Allegheny Conference on Community Development on behalf of developers who have described the increase as excessive and possibly illegal at a time when they are already wrestling with soaring interest rates, tighter lending requirements and high construction costs.

Advertise with us

The new fee — $3 per $1,000 of project cost — amounts to a twentyfold increase over what developers were charged last year for the same zoning review, according to NAIOP, an association that represents developers, brokers and other real estate professionals.

Brandon Mendoza, NAIOP Pittsburgh executive director, could not be reached for comment Monday. Todd Reidbord, the Walnut Capital president who attended the session, declined comment.

In a statement released after the meeting, Matt Smith, chief growth officer for the Allegheny Conference, said the agency is focused on creating an environment “that is business friendly and is supportive of economic development that attracts investment.”

“As the Allegheny Conference with its focus on the economic future of the Pittsburgh region, we will engage with the city of Pittsburgh — as is our practice — in a manner that enables increased staffing and capacity to process permits and get projects up and out of the ground faster, and we will work with our partners across the development community to engage Mayor Gainey and his team in a constructive dialogue to implement policies that grow our economy,” he said.

Maria Montano, Mr. Gainey’s spokeswoman, did not return an email seeking comment.

Advertise with us

During the meeting, attended by the mayor, the administration also discussed the possibility of rearranging the fee schedule so that the fee is charged later in the process when a project is closer to final approval rather than at the beginning, when it’s still in the tentative stage.

In addition, the city argued that it not only is increasing the fee to cover its costs but also to provide better and more efficient service — in response to complaints by developers that it takes too long to get permits.

Shadyside-based Walnut Capital has threatened to sue over the increase, claiming that it’s illegal.

Jonathan Kamin, its attorney, has said the new fee is not in line with the costs incurred by the city in doing a zoning review. Under state law, fees imposed must be directly related to the costs of issuing a permit or performing the work associated with the application, he has said.

He also has argued that state law doesn’t permit municipalities to use their power to charge fees “for issuing licenses or permits for the purpose of raising revenue,” adding that amounts collected in excess of actual costs will be considered an “unauthorized tax.”

Advertise with us

The estimated $285,000 being charged to Walnut Capital for a zoning review of a proposed residential and hotel project on Halket Street in Oakland would exceed the annual salaries of the people reviewing the application, Mr. Kamin has said.

A study commissioned by the developer and other organizations found that the $285,000 — up from an earlier estimate of $255,000 — far exceeds what a number of other cities would charge for a review of the same project.

In Columbus, for example, the fee would be $565. In Atlanta, it would be $1,730; in Raleigh, $2,272; in Philadelphia, $2,621; in Nashville, $8,483; in Charlotte, $13,270; and in Portland, Ore., $48,554.

The analysis also determined that the estimated cost for a building permit in Pittsburgh for the same project — $665,000 — was much higher than that charged in the other cities.

In those, it ranged from a low of $38,000 in Raleigh to $323,692 in Portland. Philadelphia charged $224,347; Nashville, $220,622; Atlanta, $157,337; Columbus $50,000; and Charlotte $132,000.

Advertise with us

“Pittsburgh appears to now be the most expensive city in the country to do business in,” the study stated.

In analyzing U.S. Census data, it also found that Pittsburgh ranked 39th out of 40 cities for the number of permits issued for buildings with five or more residential units.

“To provide the housing needed to support equitable development and growth in our city and regional economy, instituting the most expensive permitting process in the nation is counterintuitive,” the study stated.

Mr. Mendoza has said that the fee increase could undermine Mr. Gainey’s efforts to build more affordable housing in the city. The fee for residential — $1 per $1,000 of project cost — isn’t as high as it is for commercial projects, but still substantial.

Others also have warned that the increase could have a chilling effect on development and potentially drive away out-of-town investors that do work in multiple cities, not just Pittsburgh.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com