The warning signs about threats to the city’s financial future began emerging soon after Mayor Ed Gainey took office in January 2022.
Key sources of revenue started to diminish in amounts that the city did not expect, while city workers were pushing for raises and Pittsburgh leaders faced massive expenses needed to cover urgent infrastructure repairs that included badly deteriorating bridges.
Instead of imposing critical controls, local leaders moved in another direction: They planned for a hiring spree.
During Mr. Gainey’s time in office, the city has added hundreds of new positions that increased the public payroll budget by millions of dollars, putting Pittsburgh in the precarious position of having to fill potential deficits that could soon spiral out of control, records and interviews show.
The push for more jobs comes as the city confronts a wave of revenue losses driven in part by plummeting values of office towers Downtown, where the city collects a quarter of its property tax revenue.
Another major loss: hundreds of millions of dollars in federal pandemic assistance that generated unprecedented interest returns, but will soon be exhausted as the program ends in two years.
Read More
Ultimately, the losses “will have significant impact on the city’s ability to provide essential services,” Controller Rachael Heisler warned in a letter to city leaders in March.
More money could also be lost in a legal battle over a tax on visiting athletes and performers that two courts have declared unconstitutional. That would amount to more than $4 million a year.
Though the revenue losses took place in increments after the mayor took office, the spending on new jobs — more than 200 — are expected to stretch budgets for years to come.
More than 100 jobs in Public Works. Thirty-four more in city planning and permitting. Twenty-four new positions in the mayor’s office — tripling the size from the previous administration.
Overall, the budget for salaries this year is nearly $11 million more than what was projected before the new jobs were added.
With increased costs and the decline in revenue, the amount of money available for critical services and programs could be in jeopardy, according to budget experts. The Gainey administration is already projecting a nearly 70% cut in street repaving next year alone.
Funding for ramp and sidewalk repairs would fall by $1 million, to just $400,000 for the entire city, projections show.
The Small Business Development fund, which currently receives $550,000, would get no money at all.
While cuts can be made to maintenance projects or programs, there are only a few ways of reconciling salary costs: layoffs or hiring freezes.
“Once you hire folks into positions, you've now employed people and it's really difficult to eliminate those positions, because you're putting those people out of work,” said Deborah Carroll, a former budget analyst for the city of Milwaukee and director of the Government Finance Research Center at the University of Illinois Chicago.
The city’s financial practices are now expected to create mounting challenges for Pittsburgh to ensure that future budgets are balanced — not only against rising payroll, but annual increases in costs and services driven by inflation.
“Without intervention, these figures will quickly put the city in a net operating deficit for the foreseeable future,” according to internal government documents obtained by the Post-Gazette.
The weakened real estate market is already taking a toll. Tax revenue last year came in $10 million below what the city expected, Controller Rachael Heisler said early this month when she released her office’s annual report on the city’s finances.
The size of the shortfall was offset by millions in interest earnings from American Rescue Plan Act funds that the city invested — money that’s part of a $1.9 trillion federal spending package that helped cities, including Pittsburgh, avoid laying off staff during the pandemic.
But the federal dollars that have propped up the city’s budget must be completely spent by the end of 2026 — something the Gainey administration didn’t fully factor into its financial plan, the internal report stated.
At the same time, the city’s overall spending is on the rise. Expenditures jumped more than 10% last year — “a drastic change,” Ms. Heisler said.
In 2023, the city spent just under $270 million on salaries. This year, the budget calls for spending more than $290 million.
Mr. Gainey’s own projections show those salaries topping $300 million by 2026 — and Ms. Heisler warned that might be a lowball figure.
“There’s a $5 million increase in the salary line items from ‘25 to ‘26, which I don’t believe covers the [collective bargaining agreements’] salary increases, let alone the non-union workforce in the city,” Ms. Heisler said during her news conference May 1.
To some, the increase in city jobs is worryingly familiar. Payroll was a key reason for Pittsburgh’s descent into financial receivership two decades ago. From 2003 until 2018, the city was placed under the oversight of two state agencies after it nearly went bankrupt.
The city, which was struggling under a deficit of $35 million, was faulted for creating positions that were seen as unnecessary and duplicative — and that it couldn’t sustain a balanced budget with a tax base that had been diminished by the loss of major industries.
“The biggest cost to the city is payroll. It was a big issue,” said Ann Dugan, who served on the Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority, a board the state created to oversee Pittsburgh’s finances.
During the early days of Pittsburgh’s years-long crisis, then-Mayor Tom Murphy choked up at a news conference when he announced the city might have to lay off more than 700 workers.
Clawing back to financial stability was a long, painful process for the city and its residents.
Just six years after emerging from that oversight, experts like Ms. Dugan worry that city officials are again starting to spend beyond their means.
“Adding over 200 positions and millions of dollars? That’s crazy,” Ms. Dugan said.
Mr. Gainey and Deputy Mayor Jake Pawlak did not respond to interview requests or to a list of questions from the Post-Gazette, but administration officials have rejected dire predictions about the city’s finances, even as they acknowledge the declining revenue.
Last month, a day after the Post-Gazette asked about internal findings that the city was headed toward an “impending fiscal cliff,” Mr. Gainey announced the formation of a task force on city finances.
The mayor insisted that “routine financial management practices” can keep the city budget on firm footing.
“These challenges are real, but they are also manageable,” Mr. Pawlak said in a statement released hours after Ms. Heisler’s annual financial report became public. “The city is categorically not at risk of returning to financial oversight, a process that results from long-term, structural weakness, not economic headwinds.”
He added that “core city services will not be affected” by falling tax revenue.
The city had a $31.9 million surplus last year, and ended 2023 with more than $200 million in the bank, Mr. Pawlak noted.
But records from the controller’s office show that the large reserve fund will likely be severely reduced — and possibly entirely drained — in just a few years if current trends continue.
The administration’s own projections show steep cuts to key infrastructure and maintenance programs as early as 2025.
Each year, the city transfers millions of tax dollars to pay for crucial capital projects. This year, that transfer is set at $22.6 million. Next year, it’s projected to fall to less than $5 million, but the city did not respond to questions about why the number was reduced.
If the administration follows its current plan, the city’s street resurfacing program would be slashed from $16.9 million this year to just $5.5 million next year. The last time the city spent so little on repaving and repairing streets was 20 years ago, during its financial crisis.
“That's something that residents will feel, see and notice,” Ms. Heisler said in her news conference this month.
While that might save money in the short term, it makes the eventual repair even more costly because the problems — from potholes to cracks in the street — only get worse the longer they’re left untended, Ms. Dugan said.
“You need to do more work at that point in time to recover from what was not done properly,” Ms. Dugan said.
In some cases, the consequences can be catastrophic. The city’s neglect of routine maintenance over decades was a crucial factor in the Fern Hollow Bridge collapse in January 2022, the National Transportation Safety Board said in its final report on the disaster.
Replacing the bridge cost more than $25 million — about the same as the entire annual budget of the Public Works bureau that’s responsible for repairing and maintaining infrastructure.
Next year’s budget process is still in its early stages, giving city lawmakers time to pare down costs, look for programs to be cut or shift more money to road and bridge projects.
“You can’t make everybody happy,” said John Brenner, executive director of the Pennsylvania League of Municipalities and a former mayor of York. “But you’ve got to make your payroll.”
Mike Wereschagin: mwereschagin@post-gazette.com; Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.