As the crisis in Downtown deepens, with 26 office buildings in danger of foreclosure, the region’s top economic development agency is calling for the creation of a $200 million pot funded by new taxes or fees to help with residential conversions and other improvements.
The Allegheny Conference on Community Development pitched the establishment of a Downtown Investment Zone, or DIZ, during a meeting last week with state lawmakers and other stakeholders, including Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey.
Based on the presentation obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the rescue plan would be funded through enabling legislation that would authorize the city to generate “new local revenue” to help with the conversion of struggling office buildings to residential.
State Sen. Wayne Fontana, who attended the meeting, said Thursday that options being explored include new taxes or fees — although he cautioned the legislation is still being drafted by the conference.
The proposal is one of several being advanced to address the growing calamity facing Downtown because of high office vacancies caused in large part by the COVID-19 pandemic and hybrid work policies that have emptied out buildings.
Confidential real estate information obtained by the Post-Gazette presents a frightening analysis of the woes potentially confronting the Golden Triangle and public officials. It estimates that 17 buildings are in “significant distress” and another nine are in “pending distress,” meaning they are either approaching foreclosure or at the risk of foreclosure.
Read More
Among those listed as being in “significant distress” are BNY Mellon Center, which BNY Mellon, the anchor tenant, is vacating; the half empty 525 William Penn Place; and Gulf Tower.
Those listed as being in “pending distress” include Downtown landmarks U.S. Steel Tower and One Oxford Centre.
In addition, the data found that the office vacancy rate — now at 27% with subleases factored in, one of the country’s highest — could soar to 46% by 2028.
Beyond that, K&L Gates Center is facing a possible sheriff’s sale after a lender foreclosed on the property. And the owner of the Grant Building is trying to forestall a foreclosure after it defaulted on a $38 million loan when it failed to renew or extend the lease of a key tenant.
Adding to the woes, property assessments on 10 buildings, including U.S. Steel Tower and PPG Place, have been sliced by $364.4 million for the 2023 tax year alone, as high vacancies drive down income.
Together, the troubles prompted City Controller Rachael Heisler to issue a warning to Mr. Gainey and City Council members Wednesday. She said the combination of continued spending and reduced tax revenues puts the city on a direct path toward severe fiscal turmoil.
A ‘future-focused Downtown’?
The proposed Downtown Investment Zone would run for 20 years. Of the $200 million, half would be dedicated for office conversion projects and the rest would be earmarked for what the conference described as “public realm infrastructure and improvements.”
Based on the Allegheny Conference presentation, the DIZ would facilitate the conversion of more than 5 million square feet of office space to residential and create 3,000 to 5,000 new housing units.
It stated that the proposal would funnel existing office demand into high-value office buildings, decreasing vacancies and raising property values. It would also stabilize values and help “avoid [a] fiscal cliff.”
The proposed enabling legislation would allow cities across the state to create downtown investment zones, according to the presentation.
But it added that Fourth Economy Consulting is studying “a menu of potential options to understand their revenue-generating potential” for Pittsburgh itself.
“In the legislation, revenue options should be flexible to allow localities to determine what works best for them,” it stated.
The Allegheny Conference also is pushing for $30 million in state funding to provide gap financing to help get shovel-ready conversion projects started. It cited as a potential source a state redevelopment assistance capital grant (the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority has applied for that amount).
In a statement, the conference said it has been “bringing partners together around creating a collective impact plan and agenda that will build a vibrant, future-focused Downtown Pittsburgh.”
Among the priorities are continued investments in clean and safe programs as well as “policies and financing mechanisms — at the local, state and federal levels — to support necessary reinvestment and redevelopment in Downtown.”
The Downtown Investment Zone, it added, “could be a tool at the state level, as proposed by the City and URA, that could support Downtown reinvestment.”
“We are committed to working with our local leaders, Downtown stakeholders, and with the corporate and philanthropic communities to explore and design solutions that will meet the moment and the needs of Downtown today and in the future,” the conference stated.
City Council President R. Daniel Lavelle could not be reached for comment Thursday. A spokeswoman for Mr. Gainey did not return an email requesting comment.
‘We need to act now’
Mr. Fontana, a Brookline Democrat whose district includes Downtown, said that if the enabling legislation were to pass, it would take a vote by City Council to enact any new taxes or fees.
The senator said he’s prepared to introduce the legislation once it has been crafted and the details have been finalized. But he stressed that everyone — the mayor, the county executive, developers, building owners, foundations, and other stakeholders — must rally behind it if it is to pass the divided Legislature quickly enough to help the central business district.
“It’s very concerning,” he said. “There’s no doubt that we need to act now to turn the tide here.”
Mr. Fontana said he is looking at introducing his own legislation to allow cities to offer tax abatements for 20 years. They are now limited to 10. “I feel like I need to do my part representing Downtown to give it the tools I can,” he said.
At the same time, Pittsburgh Councilman Bobby Wilson plans to introduce a bill next week that would remove a $250,000 limit on the amount of city tax abatement a developer or building owner could receive to convert or redevelop a structure.
But Mr. Fontana also questioned whether the various relief measures being discussed would be enough to handle the worsening situation.
He said that some struggling Downtown buildings may not be candidates for residential conversions.
“So what do you do with them if you can’t convert them? You don’t want to mothball it, I don’t think. What do you do? Do you want to demolish it? Do you want to have a demolition fund?” he said. “I think these are details that need to be discussed as we move forward. Can you imagine how much money it will take to demolish a building? How do you pay for that?”
Aaron Stauber, president of Rugby Realty, which owns Gulf Tower, said he has yet to see full details of the Allegheny Conference proposal so he can’t discuss it much.
He said he is currently focused on two proposals that he believes will help the proposed conversion of Gulf Tower into 226 apartments and a 126-room luxury hotel.
One is the expanded city tax abatement being proposed by Mr. Wilson. The other would be a change to the Strategic Investment Fund, a private sector financing source for regional real estate projects, to target resources specifically to Downtown.
The latter, he said, would provide low-interest loans to fill funding gaps to help get conversion projects rolling. Both the expanded tax abatement and the change to the investment fund could be implemented quickly without the need for state legislation, he said.
“What [the conference is] doing, it’s a yearslong process. What I’m talking about can be done in days. We don’t have yearslong to do this. This stuff is going off the cliff by next year,” he said.
Mr. Stauber stressed that time is of the essence in doing building conversions. He has said that if he can’t get the funding he needs to do the Gulf Tower conversion, he may empty out the building and mothball it.
“We’re going to call it quits if the quagmire doesn’t get cleaned up,” he said. “I’ve been shouting [about the office troubles Downtown] for a year and a half and it’s like you’re looking at blank faces and it’s exhausting. I’m in the trenches. I know what’s happening to the city and the buildings.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.