As if the fight for the business of local grocery customers isn’t intense enough, the possible arrival of one of the nation’s most popular chains could portend an even bigger battle ahead.
And that could be good for local consumers, according to one retail expert.
Rochester, New York-based Wegmans Food Market is said to be in “active” negotiations for a spot in the 100-acre Cranberry Springs development that houses the UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex, according to real estate sources.
It would mark Wegmans’ first foray into southwestern Pennsylvania, a market that has been dominated by Giant Eagle for decades. The chain has 19 stores throughout Pennsylvania, including two in Erie and one in State College.
Wegmans would join a market already teeming with competition from the likes of Giant Eagle, Walmart, Target, Aldi, Shop’n Save, BJ’s Warehouse Club and Costco.
The news also comes as Giant Eagle made gains last year in its fight to reclaim the title of the region’s most popular grocer after losing it to Walmart in 2022.
Read More
Wegmans could give both a run for their money. It’s known for being high quality and its customer service, and consistently ranks high in consumer surveys.
In a readers poll conducted last September by USA Today, the chain ranked 10th in the country among grocers in terms of value, selection, and great service. Trader Joe’s finished 9th, Aldi 4th, and Fresh Market, which is opening a store in East Liberty, 1st.
It also would bring a bit of a rock-star type appeal with it. Devoted followers have been known to line up in advance of store openings. A petition drive to bring a Wegmans to Lower Makefield Township in Bucks County garnered 1,721 signatures, according to Philadelphia Magazine.
“Wegmans is very popular and they have a very high customer satisfaction rating so it would definitely be well received by consumers and would likely do well,” said David Glickman, a longtime retail broker who is president of Keystone Real Estate Advisors.
The 100-acre Cranberry Springs development is located near where Interstate 79 and Route 228 meet near the Pennsylvania Turnpike. In addition to the Lemieux complex, the mixed use site includes a Firebirds Wood Fired Grill restaurant, a TownePlace Suites by Marriott hotel, and a retail plaza.
Gary Sippel, owner of the development, could not be reached for comment.
Deana Percassi, a Wegmans spokeswoman, declined to say whether the chain was interested in Pittsburgh.
“We are always looking for new opportunities, but we do not comment on specific sites unless we have negotiated a lease or purchase agreement,” she said.
Pittsburgh viewed as ‘the key prize’
Mr. Glickman noted that Wegmans has stayed out of southwestern Pennsylvania even as it opened stores in areas surrounding it.
He saw a move into the region as a natural progression for the family-owned company, which got its start in 1916 when brothers John and Walter Wegman began selling produce from a pushcart. The chain now has more than 50,000 employees and more than 100 stores in seven states, according to its website.
At the same time, Wegmans’ entry into the market could provide the stiffest competition yet for Giant Eagle, another family-owned chain that already has its hands full fending off challenges.
In fact, Burt P. Flickinger III, managing director of Strategic Resource Group, an international consumer industry consulting firm with a focus on retail, said the local chain could be facing the “greatest challenge in its modern history.”
For decades, he said, Giant Eagle reigned after Kroger largely vacated the Pittsburgh market. But it now finds itself in a “five-front war” facing competition from Walmart, BJ’s Wholesale Club, Costco, and now potentially Wegmans and Publix Super Markets, a Lakeland, Florida-based grocery chain that is expanding to the north, Mr. Flickinger said.
In that regard, Wegmans’ interest in the Pittsburgh region is not an isolated one. Mr. Flickinger saw it as a part of a larger strategy — not to go head to head with Giant Eagle, but to gain a foothold in the market before Publix does so.
Publix, he said, has been moving into Kentucky and Ohio and could hit Pittsburgh and the Great Lakes region next.
“It’s almost like who gets to the capital city in the Great Lakes region first, with Pittsburgh being the key prize,” Mr. Flickinger explained.
He added that Wegmans probably should have entered the Pittsburgh market a decade ago, particularly after opening a state-of-the-art food distribution center in central Pennsylvania.
“Wegmans appeared to take Pittsburgh for granted in the last decade,” he said.
In Giant Eagle-Wegmans competition, customers win
Wegmans and Giant Eagle have some similarities. Both are family owned and they each have successful food and pharmacy combinations, Mr. Flickinger said.
If they do go head to head for supremacy in the Pittsburgh market, he cautioned against counting Giant Eagle out. One advantage the local chain has is its fuel rewards program, a perk Wegmans doesn’t offer customers.
Giant Eagle, he maintained, also has a better mix of local, regional, and national brands, while Wegmans has been shifting more and more to its own private label selections, which now account for about 50% of total sales.
Daniel Donovan, a Giant Eagle spokesperson, did not comment on Wegmans’ possible entry into the market, but said the grocer has been “relentless” over the past year in trying to win over customers.
“Pittsburgh shoppers have many choices when deciding how to feed themselves and their families,” he said. “We recognize our responsibility to help families stretch their budgets in the face of inflation on food and other necessities. … We’ve invested millions of dollars in lowered prices and market-leading weekly promotions.”
Wegmans’ strengths include its size, with stores typically ranging from 120,000 to 128,000 square feet, and strong prepared food, bakery, meat, and produce offerings. The fresh food it offers ranks as “some of the best anywhere in the world,” Mr. Flickinger said.
Nonetheless, he also argued that the chain, in his view, has become “somewhat competitively complacent” lately, an issue that also has befallen Giant Eagle, he said.
But a head-to-head competition could bring out the best in both.
“They will both bring their A game,” he said. “Both Giant Eagle and Wegmans will do well and make each other better and create a great shopping environment for Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania customers in terms of price, quality, and variety.”
Mr. Glickman said it’s hard to tell how much Wegmans would cut into the existing market share for grocers.
“It would certainly make a dent because the grocery market is only so big. It’s a pie and they would be coming in and taking a piece of that pie,” he noted.
Battle for the Pittsburgh region is intensifying
Against current competition, Giant Eagle improved its position in the Pittsburgh market last year, according to the most recent data available from the Chain Store Guide, a retail intelligence firm.
In 2022, Walmart edged out Giant Eagle as the most popular grocer in the Pittsburgh region for the first time, grabbing a quarter of the market share. The data for the region encompasses Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Butler, Fayette, Washington and Westmoreland Counties.
Giant Eagle showed up with 21% of the grocery dollars spent here in 2022, but last year, the gap narrowed. Walmart retained the top rank but by the narrower margin of just 1%.
Giant Eagle’s Mr. Donovan said Giant Eagle knows “that there is more work to do.”
“In the near future, customers can expect us to announce additional investments in lowered prices on the items they purchase most frequently.”
Giant Eagle also made significant gains in revenue, according to Chain Store Guide. The amount of money customers spent at the Cranberry-based grocer jumped by 17%, compared with 2% at Walmart.
In fact, the entire Pittsburgh market saw an increase of 5% in grocery spending between 2022 and 2023. It’s clear consumers are spending more money, even as the rate of food inflation slowed between the two years.
The United States Department of Agriculture said the tail end of pandemic-era supply chain issues and overall economic inflation in 2022 drove up “food-at-home” prices by more than 11%. Last year, the increase was 5%.
It was Dollar General that made the biggest advance in 2023 by pulling 37% more dollars from area consumers than the year before that, in part by adding more stores to the region. It went from 156 locations in the greater Pittsburgh region to 214 during this time.
Family Dollar grew its grocery revenue by 11%, and added eight more stores in the region, and Dollar Tree added six locations, although its revenue dropped by 5%.
Giant Eagle improved its position even as the past 14 months marked a new chapter for the chain, a nearly century-old grocer founded by five families and, until March 2023, helmed by members of the Shapira family.
When long-time Giant Eagle employee Bill Artman was appointed as the first non-family CEO and Bart Friedman as a non-family chairman of the board, speculation swirled that the company may be preparing itself for a sale.
But a year on, it appears to have retrenched, boosting its regional sales to $1.7 billion among the 67 stories in the Greater Pittsburgh area. It also announced in December that it would be moving its headquarters to Cranberry.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com. Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.