The owner of a new craft beer and wine store to open on Sixth Street in Downtown says that it will be an asset to the city. But some neighbors of the venture aren’t toasting its arrival.

Bridges and Bottles will be taking a 3,500-square-foot space at street level in the Roosevelt Building in the heart of the Sixth Street restaurant corridor.

A business plan describes the store at 137 Sixth as a “flagship venture poised to revolutionize the craft beer and wine scene in Pittsburgh,” one that will “serve as a beacon for enthusiasts seeking unparalleled quality and variety in artisanal beverages.”

“The store’s concept is simple yet profound: To offer a meticulously curated selection of craft beers and wines, encompassing a diverse array of styles, flavors and origins. From classic pale ales to bold stouts, refreshing pilsners to complex sour ales, Bridges and Bottles will cater to every palate and preference, ensuring an unforgettable experience for every customer,” it stated.

Advertise with us

However, some Sixth Street restaurant owners and other stakeholders fear the store will be no different than common beer outlets on Wood Street and Liberty Avenue and that it will be detrimental to one of Downtown’s top dining destinations.

“We have a good thing in the Cultural District. We built it up, made it nice with flowers and lighting and street cafes. I’m not putting down the business. I’m just saying the place he’s putting it is not a good thing for us,” said Len Semplice, owner of Redbeard’s Sports Bar and Grill at 144 Sixth.

With the store’s lease prohibiting on-site consumption, he and some other restaurateurs worry that people will buy beer or wine at the store and then just sit at outdoor spaces meant for dining to drink.

While the craft beer concept “sounds great, you can get all of that stuff at the beer distributor on Wood Street. I can make anything sound good. If you’re selling one-off beers, as soon as they leave the store, you have no control over it,” said Rich Bufalini, owner of Olive or Twist restaurant at 140 Sixth.

John Valentine, executive director of the Pittsburgh Downtown Neighbors Alliance, is also opposed to the store. He said he’s concerned about tobacco being sold there and that there are no dine-in options.

Advertise with us

“What Downtown needs is a nice wine bar where people can come in, listen to music and enjoy socializing over a glass of wine. This doesn’t sound like that. To me it sounds like, honestly, a beer distributor,” he said.

Mr. Valentine said the beer and tobacco outlet on Wood hasn’t been good for that street. He said there’s litter and that he has passed by people sleeping outside the store. He fears the same will happen on Sixth.

“I think this is a mistake,” he said.

Mr. Bufalini had similar concerns.

“It brings the wrong kind of vibe. It doesn’t fit in with Sixth Street, the Cultural District, the Benedum, and the Byham,” he said.

Advertise with us

But Aditya Sharma, Bridges and Bottles owner, and Gary Wilson, owner of the Roosevelt Building, said the new store will be nothing like the outlets.

While Mr. Sharma acknowledged that part of his family owns the beer stores on Wood and Liberty, he said he has nothing to do with either of them. Bridges and Bottles, he added, will be a “very beautiful and welcoming store.”

“It will probably be one of the nicest stores in the neighborhood anyone has ever seen. It’s going to be very top notch,” he said.

The idea is to sell specialty wines and beers that are not commonly available in Pennsylvania, explained Mr. Sharma, who operates Cold Stone Creamery stores in Squirrel Hill and the Waterworks shopping center and has two others in the works in Green Tree and Cranberry.

“Our beer selection is a little more on the expensive side. We’re not going to promote low-budget beer. It’s more high-end expensive stuff, even stuff that’s hard to find in other states,” he said.

Advertise with us

While there are no sit-down options within the store, Bridges and Bottles does plan to have wine tastings inside once or twice a month. Tobacco sales, Mr. Sharma said, will be “very minimal.”

He added he’s also willing to consider suggestions for improving the concept, including the possibility of having a sit-down option for wine and beer drinking. He’s planning to open the store in six months or so.

“Whatever helps the people, I’m sure we can work it out,” he said. “It’s not in our business plan right now but it’s something that’s definitely open for discussion.”

Mr. Wilson said he has taken steps to ensure that the store will have a positive impact on Sixth.

They include lease restrictions that limit tobacco sales to 10% of all gross sales and provisions that prevent onsite consumption of alcohol and tobacco and the “sale of anything drug or vape paraphernalia-related.”

Advertise with us

He also said he has a lien on the Bridges and Bottles liquor license in the event the tenant doesn’t comply with the restrictions.

“I have done everything in my power to ensure that this new tenant will be an asset to the 6th Street corridor that we are collectively working to enhance,” he said in an email to Jeremy Waldrup, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership.

But despite the assurances, Mr. Valentine isn’t sold on the concept. He argued the lease doesn’t go far enough — that it should allow Mr. Wilson to close down the business “if it turns out to be detrimental to Sixth Street.”

“Words are cheap. I want to see more action,” he said.

Mr. Waldrup took a more measured approach. He noted that Sixth is a “vital corridor for Downtown” and that “selecting the right mix of businesses is crucial for any street.”

Advertise with us

“There have been instances where the wrong type of business created issues for its neighbors. For example, vape shops and beer stores often raise concerns, prompting us to investigate further. The building owner has conducted extensive due diligence and is confident this new business will positively impact the corridor, especially since he has over 200 residential tenants upstairs,” he said in a statement.

”We do everything we can to support good businesses Downtown and work equally hard to shut down problematic ones. We look forward to continued public and private investment along Sixth Street, fostering its growth and evolution.”

One restaurateur who welcomed Bridges and Bottles was Con Alma, the jazz club located around the corner on Penn Avenue in the Roosevelt Building.

Co-owner Josh Ross said it will be a convenient place to stop for those staying at nearby hotels or who live in Downtown,

“I don’t see what the problem is. I think that it will be a welcomed addition to the neighborhood,” he said.

Advertise with us

Rather than a detriment, Mr. Wilson sees Bridges and Bottles as part of the Roosevelt building’s resurgence. Con Alma just received city approval for an outdoor dining section, adding 18 to 24 seats, and the Phillip Injeian Violin Shop has moved into a second floor space that once housed Pittsburgh Steelers offices.

He also has signed 80 tenants to apartment leases after a building rehab following a 2022 fire that killed one person. Bridges and Bottles is another step in the right direction, he maintained.

“Stuff’s happening here,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com.