Five years after first being proposed, a new live music venue at the former Civic Arena site may finally be ready to hit its groove.
Live Nation hopes to start construction on the indoor venue with a 4,500-person capacity this fall and open it in the first quarter of 2026, according to Craig Dunham, senior vice president of development for the Pittsburgh Penguins.
Mr. Dunham outlined the plans during a community meeting Tuesday evening to discuss progress on the 28-acre former arena site in the lower Hill District.
As reported by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette earlier this month, Mr. Dunham confirmed that the Penguins, in conjunction with Live Nation and their other development partners, are prioritizing construction of the live music venue over a 900-space parking garage to be built in the same area.
As originally conceived, the parking garage was to be erected first. But the Penguins decided to switch the order because of “uncertain” user demand for structured parking after the pandemic and high interest rates and construction costs.
During his presentation Tuesday, Mr. Dunham said the Penguins have submitted take down notices to the owners of the arena site — the Sports and Exhibition and Urban Redevelopment authorities — to separate the music venue and garage projects.
Read More
The URA board will hold a nonvoting briefing on the music venue in May. That should be followed by votes in June by the URA and SEA boards, Mr. Dunham said. The Penguins will also need approval from the city Planning Commission to subdivide the parcel.
“Originally the project was set up so that it would be a garage project first ... and then the venue would follow. What we’re doing right now is making some adjustments to that sequence,” Mr. Dunham said.
Under the new plan, the Penguins and development partner Buccini Pollin Group would acquire the land needed for the venue. Live Nation, in partnership with the Fenway Sports Group, the Penguins owner, would build, own and operate it.
Mr. Dunham said Live Nation is “very actively interested in both the Pittsburgh market and facilities in the lower Hill.”
Fenway Sports Group, which also owns the Boston Red Sox baseball team, developed a 91,500-square-foot performing arts venue operated by Live Nation next to Fenway Park in Boston.
The change in order means a 20-year parking tax diversion plan tied to the proposed garage, one that was expected to generate $8 million for housing stabilization in the Middle and Upper Hill, will be delayed. That project also includes construction of a 5,400-square-foot EMS public safety facility at the corner of Bedford Avenue and Fullerton Street.
Mr. Dunham stressed that the Penguins are still committed to those initiatives. At the same time, by advancing the music venue first, it will speed up implementation of a $2 per ticket surcharge that will be used for development activities in other parts of the neighborhood.
He added that commitments also remain in place for Live Nation to book and promote at least 25 events annually for five years at the historic New Granada Theater, which is being redeveloped by the Hill Community Development Corporation.
The hockey team also has pledged to make up to 250 parking spaces available for free at the former arena site for New Granada events for five years.
During Tuesday’s Zoom meeting, one person had concerns about the availability of parking for the music venue without the garage. Mr. Dunham replied that parking should be “more than adequate,” with roughly 1,900 surface spaces available.
Marimba Milliones, president and CEO of the Hill CDC, also has raised concerns that if sufficient parking isn’t available, concert-goers may look for spaces in other parts of the Hill and adversely affect the neighborhood.
The music venue would be the second major project to start at the former arena site, where the Penguins hold the development rights.
Next door, the 26-story FNB Financial Center is racing toward completion this summer. It is now about 85% finished. It will be the headquarters for First National Bank, which will be moving from the North Side. Three other companies also have signed leases to take space in the tower, built at the lower end of the site near Washington Place.
During Tuesday’s meeting, Bomani Howze, vice president of development for Buccini Pollin Group, said the office project has generated about $46 million in contracts for minority-owned businesses, including $25.1 million for Black-owned firms. More than $8 million has gone to women-owned companies.
“We set out to commit to wealth-building and we’ve done just that,” he said.
While the FNB tower is close to completion and the music venue is moving toward construction, the Penguins’ plans for housing on the upper part of the site are still stuck in neutral.
After submitting a letter of intent to the URA and SEA last spring outlining a proposal for 340 apartment units just below Crawford Square, the plan remains in the “earliest conceptual stages,” Mr. Howze said.
“We don’t have any pricing on our units and subsequently we don’t have a start date,” he said.
The housing is to be developed through a partnership involving the Penguins, Buccini Pollin, and Olmec Development Company headed by Mr. Howze.
Mr. Howze said the group continues to explore “a variety of options” to finance the housing. It also has been talking to Mayor Ed Gainey’s office and the Pittsburgh Housing Authority about ways to do so.
The Penguins have committed to making 20% of the housing affordable. Of that, 15% would be for households at 80% of the area median income. That would make the units affordable to someone making about $56,000 a year, Mr. Howze said.
“These are your nurses. These are your teachers, your firemen, electricians and plumbers,” he said.
Of the other 5%, half would be reserved for those at 70% of the AMI and half at 60%.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.