Since 2020, Downtown has been losing tenants while the other top markets in the region have been adding them, another indication of the troubles plaguing the central business district.
In all, a net of nine tenants have left the Golden Triangle, while the other top four submarkets — Cranberry/Northern Interstate 79, Downtown Fringe, Oakland/East End, and West — have gained anywhere from eight to 13, according to a new report by the Jones Lang LaSalle (JLL) real estate firm.
The analysis found that 17 tenants moved out of Downtown over the time period while eight, including four new to the market, moved in. Another 47 decided to stay in the central business district.
Of those that moved out, six have done so since the start of 2023, during a time when many stakeholders, including business owners and landlords, raised concerns about safety in Downtown.
To get the results, JLL reviewed new leases signed in the major submarkets since 2020, the year the COVID-19 pandemic hit.
It found that other submarkets benefited from the departures in Downtown, with 68% of those who fled landing in the Fringe, including the Strip District, or the Oakland/East End submarkets.
Read More
In addressing the findings, Dan Adamski, JLL executive managing director, said the dominant commercial trend facing the Golden Triangle wasn’t safety but rather a flight to quality.
In other words, tenants are gravitating to buildings that offer amenities like child care facilities, fitness centers, improved ventilation, indoor and outdoor gathering areas, and restaurant-grade cafeterias — often in other submarkets even if they’re cutting their overall footprint.
For lease deals signed over the last 15 months, Mr. Adamski noted that 56% of the tenants that relocated moved to buildings that were on average 26 years newer than the structures which they were leaving. The most common move has been from Class B buildings to higher quality Class A digs with better amenities.
While Downtown was losing tenants, the report found that Oakland/East End had gained the most, with a net of 13 moving in, including seven new to the market. Cranberry/Northern I-79 and the Downtown Fringe were next, each attracting a net of 12 tenants.

Even the West submarket, which has had its ups and downs over the last decade, outpaced Downtown, with 11 tenants moving in versus three moving out for a net gain of eight.
And according to the report, the migration to other submarkets appears to be gaining momentum. Overall, 65% of tenants that signed new leases since 2020 stayed in the same submarket.
But over the last 15 months, 49% of the new leases involved a move to another submarket, an indication of a shift in attitude, JLL stated.
Mr. Adamski said Cranberry has been a big beneficiary of the trend.
One reason for its gains is the relocation of Giant Eagle’s headquarters to the Cranberry Woods Business Park, where it is taking 100,000 square feet of space with access to amenities like free parking, a gym, and walking and jogging trails.
Of further note is that many of the relocating tenants are shrinking their office footprint. Since 2020, tenants signing new deals have cut their space by about 19% compared with 8% for those who renewed their leases, JLL stated.
Over the past year, tenants signing new leases have reduced their space even more, by 21% on average. For urban tenants, it has been 25% while for suburban ones it has been 10%.
“The differences seen in tenant rightsizing across submarkets are attributed to a variety of factors, including real estate cost, industry, and hybrid work trends,” the report stated.
The losses in Downtown came during the pandemic and its immediate aftermath, when a number of stakeholders raised concerns about issues like safety, open drug use, aggressive panhandling, and public urination and defecation.
There were also some high-profile business departures during that time, including Fragasso Financial Advisors, which moved to Sewickley.
Over the past year, the city and the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership have boosted police presence, added portable toilets, and intensified alley and sidewalk cleanups and outreach efforts to address the concerns.
But Mr. Adamski said stakeholders must do more if they are to turn tenant losses into gains.
That includes prioritizing efforts to convert older failing Class B and C buildings to other uses, whether it’s residential, retail and hospitality, in-fill industrial, or “even demolition for some,” he argued.
“This is a painful but necessary transition to a reimagined Downtown that is more vibrant and activated, and ultimately will help support a more prosperous future for the city and all of its stakeholders,” he said.
To that end, a bill currently before City Council would broaden the tax abatements in Downtown to help with building conversions and the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority has applied for $30 million in state capital funding to be used for the same purpose.
In conjunction with the city, county, and URA, the Allegheny Conference on Community Development is exploring a plan for a Downtown Investment Zone funded by new local taxes or fees to help raise money for conversions or other improvements.
At the same time, Downtown has been hit with a wave of assessment reductions totaling more than $400 million caused by high office vacancies resulting from the pandemic and hybrid work and a big drop in the number used to calculate taxable value at property appeal hearings.
However, not all is lost for Downtown building owners. Some, Mr. Adamski suggested, still could change the trajectory of their assets by making amenity-driven investments to help attract tenants.
Over the last two years, buildings like Four Gateway Center and One PPG Place have experienced “outsized occupancy gains” by making such improvements.
But making such investments could be challenging right now because of “headwinds in the form of high interest rates and lender hesitancy,” he acknowledged.
Still, despite the issues in Downtown, Mr. Adamski sees reason for optimism.
In recent months, there has been “a surge in Downtown office momentum due to increasing return-to-work policies having workers back in the office three to four days per week,” he said.
He also maintained that there “has been a noticeable improvement in public safety and general buzz of Downtown compared to the last two years, aided by the fact that 60% of workers have returned to work versus pre-pandemic.”
“Anecdotally, many of my clients who previously expressed concerns about safety Downtown have stated they’ve seen a notable improvement over the past year. The new police substation on Wood Street should further this perception,” he said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.