Seven years after first acquiring it, a Cleveland developer has outlined its latest plan for revamping an empty seven-story building in the heart of the Smithfield Street corridor Downtown as part of its bid for $12.5 million in state aid.
Stark Enterprises is proposing to convert the one-time department store and former office building into 165 residential units on the top six floors while filling the ground floor with “vibrant restaurants, shops and services.”
The company detailed the plan in its application for $12.5 million in state redevelopment assistance capital grant funding.
Stark has done little with the block-long building at 441 Smithfield between Forbes and Fifth avenues since buying it in 2017 for $10.4 million, leaving a number of Downtown stakeholders, including Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey, frustrated.
“It’s a really important block for Downtown Pittsburgh and we want to see redevelopment happen in that building,” said Jeremy Waldrup, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership.
In its application for the state aid, Stark stated that it was planning a “full building renovation,” including the construction of a light well through the structure to provide more natural light to interior residential units.
Read More
Other work would involve the cleaning and repair of the building’s facade, a new roof, installation of new windows and elevators, and conversion from steam heat to gas and electric with new mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems.
Stark also stated that it would set aside 10% of the residential units as affordable for lower-income renters.
“The redevelopment of this block-long building will bring much needed vibrancy to Smithfield Street and Fifth Avenue and support Downtown’s evolution into a residential community, essential to its long-term economic success,” it stated in its application.
This isn’t Stark’s first plan to redevelop the building, which housed the now defunct Frank & Seder department store from 1918 to 1954.
Months after buying the building, Stark pitched a plan to turn it into the Icon on Smithfield, a project that was to include 160,000 square feet of office space on the upper floors and two floors of retail.
A year later, it won approval from the city planning commission for a tweaked version — three floors of office space, about 40 apartments spread over two floors, and 25,000 square feet of retail.
Nothing came of either of those plans. It later recast the vision once again with a proposal that ditched the office component in favor of 150 residential units on the six upper floors and retail at street level. It also rebranded the project as Smith & Fifth, the same name it currently has.
The latest proposal is nearly the same, with Stark boosting the number of apartments by 15.
In its application, the developer noted that the building, by virtue of its location across from the former Kaufmann’s department store, “plays an outsized impact on the Downtown experience,” adding that “its current condition is detrimental to our goal of creating a welcoming place for workers, residents and visitors.”
Stark, in the past, has appeared to vacillate between redeveloping the structure and selling it. In 2020, it put the building up for sale with an asking price of $22 million — more than double what it had paid for it — but failed to land a buyer.
Two years later, it reportedly tried to sell the property to a New York-based real estate firm but the deal apparently fizzled out.
In its application, Stark estimated the cost of the latest conversion at nearly $68 million, with $12.5 million of that being covered by the requested state grant and the rest through private funding.
It proposed a Jan. 1, 2025, construction start and a June 1, 2026, completion for the residential units.
In response to an email seeking comment on the project and the request for the state redevelopment grant assistance, a Stark spokeswoman said such funding is needed.
“We recognize the critical importance of this city block to the renewal of the Smithfield corridor and are laser-focused on redeveloping the area,” said Stacie Schmidt, vice president of marketing for Stark. “However, due to rising construction costs, interest rates, and the unique challenges of repositioning a century-old office building, we require a public-private partnership to make the project financially viable to execute.”
Mr. Waldrup in the past has said that Stark should either get moving on rehabbing the building or sell it. He said Wednesday he has heard that the company is looking to partner with a team of local developers on the project and that he has the “highest confidence in their collective capabilities.”
“There are significant redevelopment plans for the Smithfield Street corridor, making [the Stark building] an integral part of that entire Smithfield redevelopment,” he said.
The PDP has spent its own money to spruce up the site with public art and to install planters on the sidewalk in front of the building.
Across the street, Philadelphia-based Lubert Adler Partners took over the stalled Kaufmann’s redevelopment in 2020 and spent $40 million to finish the 311 apartments and the indoor parking and to recruit Target, Five Below, and Burlington to fill two floors of retail. The redevelopment also includes a hotel.
At one point, Lubert Adler had considered investing $50 million in the 441 Smithfield building as part of a collaboration with Stark. However, nothing ever came of that overture.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com
This story was updated on March 21, 2024, to include a response from Stark Enterprises.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.