Developer Walnut Capital has agreed to a push by Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey to set aside 15% of housing to be built as part of a proposed Bakery Square expansion as affordable.

The decision could have implications for a community benefits agreement related to the expansion that has been billed as potentially the first in the nation to include a private commitment to building homeownership in Larimer and East Liberty.

Todd Reidbord, Walnut Capital president, acknowledged Tuesday that the deal with the Gainey administration could involve a recasting of the benefits agreement. But he argued that’s not unusual for such accords.

“No community benefits agreement has ever ended up exactly the way it started,” he said. “It’s tough. These are difficult issues.”

Advertise with us

The centerpiece of the CBA between Shadyside-based Walnut Capital, the Larimer Consensus Group, and the Village Collaborative of East Liberty was the “Build 100” plan. The goal was to raise $25 million to build and rehab 100 for-sale houses in East Liberty and Larimer.

As part of that initiative, Walnut Capital was to contribute $6 million and ongoing resources to create the fund to be used for the homes.

However, the developer will now use that $6 million to help fill the gap in funding needed to build affordable housing as part of the expansion. The expansion will include as many as 800 apartments, as well as mixed-use office and retail along Penn Avenue to the west of Bakery Square.

Mr. Reidbord said the mayor has agreed to work through the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority and to find other resources to try to fund the for-sale housing component that was part of the community benefits agreement.

“Nobody is giving up on those goals,” he said. “The city has agreed to study and devote resources to those goals.”

Advertise with us

Olga George, Mr. Gainey’s spokeswoman, declined comment, citing the ongoing strike by some Post-Gazette employees.

K. Chase Patterson, the board chair of the Larimer Consensus Group who was instrumental in negotiating the community benefits agreement, had no comment.

Mr. Reidbord said Walnut Capital would continue to work with the Larimer and East Liberty neighborhoods on possible benefits as the expansion and a companion zoning change move forward.

He disagreed with the contention that the community benefits agreement was essentially dead. He said there are components that are still viable and other ways to achieve some of the goals built into that plan.

“The concepts and goals and aspirations are still in place. We’re working with the community groups, councilman [Khari] Mosley, and the mayor’s office to find a way to achieve those goals,” he said.

Advertise with us

The decision to do more affordable housing within the Bakery Square expansion itself came after a meeting with Mr. Gainey. Walnut Capital had planned to set aside 5% of the units as affordable, according to Mr. Reidbord.

“His goal is to have more affordable rental housing onsite and we’ve agreed to do that,” he said.

Mr. Reidbord characterized the concession as a way to get the development moving.

“We’re now all working together. We’re in agreement with what the path forward should be,” he said. “We’re all working together toward the same goal.”

With the affordable housing deal in place, Walnut Capital is hoping that it will help to speed up the zoning change needed to expand the boundaries of the specially planned district created to build Bakery Square on the Larimer and Shadyside borders.

Advertise with us

That amendment has been languishing in the city bureaucracy and still needs to go before the planning commission and city council.

“It’s important, as it always is, to have the mayor’s support on all of your projects,” Mr. Reidbord said.

The proposed expansion, totaling about 12 acres, would include the Village of Eastside shopping center and the former site of the Club One Fitness building, which has been demolished.

Walnut Capital also has been mulling razing the old East Liberty Post Office, which now houses grocer Trader Joe’s. If the developer follows through with that plan, Trader Joe’s would be relocated within the redevelopment.

Besides apartments, the expansion could include as much as 800,000 square feet of office space.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com