Trader Joe’s in East Liberty probably will be moving as part of the proposed expansion of Bakery Square.
Developer Walnut Capital intends to move the popular grocery from its current location in the old East Liberty Post Office to a new building within the 12-acre footprint of the expansion.
Walnut Capital President Todd Reidbord said on Tuesday that the developer is in discussions with the grocery chain about a possible move, and while the two sides have yet to reach a deal, the intent is to keep Trader Joe’s within the development.
“I can say for sure that Trader Joe’s is not going anywhere,” he said. “They have a long-term lease. We want them to stay there.”
Mr. Reidbord’s comments came the same day the proposed expansion gained some momentum with a key stakeholder, the Larimer Consensus Group, signing a community benefits agreement related to it.
While the plan is to keep Trader Joe’s, the same cannot be said of the former East Liberty Post Office building that currently houses the grocery.
Read More
Mr. Reidbord acknowledged that the old post office as well as the Village of Eastside shopping center, which includes the old Consolidated Ice Co. building, probably will be demolished in the expansion.
Walnut Capital wants to raze the structures in its bid to improve the infrastructure and to create better pedestrian connections and access to Bakery Square from East Liberty, Larimer and other nearby East End neighborhoods.
The plan does not sit well with everyone.
Describing both as historic, the East Liberty Valley Historical Society has warned on Facebook that the old post office and the Consolidated Ice Co. buildings could be at risk in the expansion.
Mr. Reidbord doesn’t believe either has any historic significance. He said both have been gutted and “chopped up” on the inside. More important than saving the buildings, he argued, is creating better access to the expanded Bakery Square from East End neighborhoods.
Even if the old post office is demolished, the plan is to prevent any disruption to Trader Joe’s business. Walnut Capital will build a new spot for the grocer before demolishing the current site, Mr. Reidbord said.
“In all scenarios, Trader Joe’s would be open the entire time,” he said.
At the same time, he emphasized that the overall expansion plan is still in the early stages, with Walnut Capital currently focused on getting a zoning change to extend the boundaries of the specially planned district created to build Bakery Square on the Larimer and Shadyside borders.
“We think it’s important to keep our options open,” Mr. Reidbord said, pointing to factors like high interest rates and high construction costs.
That said, the developer is considering up to 800 units of housing and mixed-use office and retail buildings in the expansion, which would take place just west of Bakery Square along Penn Avenue to Shady Avenue.
Beyond the shopping center and the old post office, the site includes the land that housed the since-demolished Club One Fitness building.
The Larimer Consensus Group negotiated the community benefits agreement as part of the proposed zoning change and expansion.
That deal includes a commitment to build or renovate more than 100 houses in Larimer and East Liberty and to provide about $5 million in funding for affordable housing, health and wellness, education and workforce development in East End communities.
The plan involves a pledge to raise $25 million for the Larimer and East Liberty Revitalization Fund to build or renovate the houses, with Walnut Capital kicking in $6 million of its own money, with hopes of raising the rest from corporations and foundations.
K. Chase Patterson, board chairman of the Larimer Consensus Group, described the CBA as a “fair and reasonable document.” He said it will go a long way toward creating affordable, workforce and market-rate housing in his neighborhood.
Improving and diversifying the housing stock in Larimer is one of the goals of the neighborhood master plan.
Mr. Patterson also is excited about the $5 million that will go toward housing, education, health and welfare, and workforce development.
“To see that kind of investment in Larimer and in East Liberty in those four areas is critically important,” he said.
Mr. Reidbord called the Larimer Consensus Group buy-in an “important milestone” for the expansion and for the community. The idea from the start was to craft an agreement that reflected community values, and the main one in this case was home ownership, he said.
“We feel that both Larimer and the East End communities will benefit highly from the CBA,” he said. “We think it’s a comprehensive understanding of what is necessary for the community.”
The CBA is still awaiting the signature of the Village Collaborative of East Liberty, the registered community organization for the neighborhood.
East Liberty Development Inc., another neighborhood community group, has sent a letter in support of the zoning change needed for the Bakery Square expansion.
During a public meeting earlier this month, some residents expressed concerns about building heights, traffic impacts and other logistical issues in the project. They also worried that it could result in more displacement, which has become a big concern in East Liberty’s revitalization.
The meeting also was notable for state Rep. La’Tasha Mayes, whose district includes the expansion site, saying that Bakery Square “is not for me,” adding that she did not see Black people working at the stores, utilizing the attractions, or living there.
Mr. Reidbord pushed back against the assertions, arguing that Bakery Square was a diverse community consisting of people of varying socioeconomic backgrounds and ethnicities.
“Come on a Friday evening after work, and see the diversity of people there ... you see people of all different colors, sizes, shapes and ethnicities,” he said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.